Search

In the last half century, the rule of law has increasingly been appealed to as a common global value. The Handbook on the Rule of Law analyses the appeal of this idea, its context, and background through a range of questions about the character, history and global reach of the rule of law, offering readers a definitive understanding of this central global norm.Original contributions from leading academics explore the rule of law conceptually and historically through its associated institutions, as well as examine detailed cases evaluating how the everyday application of the rule of law impacts society as a whole. Exploring a wide range of research on the social, political and economic dimensions of the rule of law, this Handbook clearly illustrates the link between the rule of law and the global political system.This informative Handbook will be key reading for post-graduate students of international relations, global politics, and law, as well as for legal scholars wanting to build upon their knowledge with a wider account of the rule of law. Researchers in areas impacted by the rule of law will also find this volume to be stimulating reading.Contributors include: J. Allison, T. Almeida Cravo, D. Banik, A. Bedner, P. Costa, C. Cutler, D.l. Desai, C. Feinäugle, J. Flood, T. Ginsburg, J. Gutmann, S. Hinderling, D. Howath, T. Kellogg, T. Krever, M. Krygier, A. Loretoni, F. Macaulay, A. Magen, C. May, J. Møller, P. Nicholson, L. Pech, M.M. Prado, M. Rishmawi, C. Schwöbel-Patel, L.B. Tiede, V. Vadi, S. Voigt, C. Walker, A. Wiener, A. Winchester, P. Zumbansen

Il tema della legalità è stato oggetto di studi autorevoli e di innumerevoli occasioni di dibattito. Con l'espressione plurale ‘le legalità'si è voluto fare riferimento al continuo lavorio della scienza giuridica e delle istituzioni, dall'antichità fino all'età contemporanea, sulla definizione di diversi e specifici concetti di legalità anche in ambiti diversi da quello, più studiato, del diritto penale. Negli studi che qui si presentano sono ricostruiti alcuni ‘spaccati'della lunga incubazione del principio di legalità e della sua manifestazione in età moderna. Insieme con quello della certezza del diritto, il principio di legalità costituisce uno degli elementi del DNA della civiltà giuridica occidentale, come civiltà, ce lo ricorda A. Padoa Schioppa, fondata sul ‘libro'del diritto. Claudia Storti, professore ordinario di storia del diritto medievale e moderno presso l'Università degli Studi di Milano, Claudia Storti è stata Presidente della Società di Storia del diritto per il triennio 2013-2016. Le sue ricerche vertono sulla storia del diritto nell'alto medioevo con particolare riguardo al Regno longobardo-italico, sulla storia delle fonti del diritto e delle istituzioni in età medievale, sulla condizione giuridica dello straniero, sul diritto internazionale pubblico e privato tra medioevo e età contemporanea, sulla storia della giustizia e del processo penale tra XIX e XX secolo, sulla storia della schiavitù.

This book offers a unique and essential combination of careful self-assessment of the achievements and challenges of international adjudication, in chapters written by scholars who are also members of the most prominent international courts, together with a rigorous and sober external analysis of the promise and limits of promoting the international rule of law through adjudication. The book provides the state of the art contemporary overview of the field and therefore is a must read for scholars, students and practitioners.'- Eyal Benvenisti, University of Cambridge, UK, Tel Aviv University, Israel and New York University, US'This is a timely, fascinating and challenging collection of essays by eminent jurists. The range of courts covered from the International Court of Justice, the International Criminal Court, the European Court of Human Rights to the Appellate Body of the WTO and the Special Tribunal for Lebanon demonstrates the reach of this work as well as the importance and timeliness of the subject-matter. The quality of the authors matches the significance of the topic. The problems as well as the steps forward are well explained. This book should be read.'- Malcolm N. Shaw QC, University of Cambridge and practising barrister at Essex Court Chambers, London, UK'A comprehensive overview, aptly written by eminent specialists of international courts, on a notion at once intriguing and important for international law. Rule of law - a concept of municipal constitutional law, essential for the modern conception of society, and yet such a delicate, but also developing, notion in the sometimes rough jurisprudence of nations.'- Robert Kolb, University of Geneva, SwitzerlandInternational and supranational courts are increasingly central to the development of a transnational rule of law. Except for insiders, the functioning and impact of these courts remain largely unknown. Addressing this gap, this innovative book examines the manner in which and the extent to which international courts and tribunals contribute to the rule of law at the national, regional, and international levels.With unique insights from members of the international judiciary, this authoritative book deals with the fundamental procedural and substantive legal principles, sources, tools of interpretation, and enforcement used by the respective judicial bodies. The rule of law-focused approach offers a unique opportunity for a thorough cross-case analysis of the differences and commonalities in the essential contributions of the respective courts and tribunals to international justice. The book also includes an in-depth theoretical framework and allows for the identification of fundamental principles and commonalities, as well as differences and contrasts between the different judicial bodies.In addition to students, researchers and scholars in international law, this timely and comprehensive study of international courts and their contributions will be an enlightening resource for legal practitioners and those involved with international justice.Contributors include: S. Brammertz, A.A.Cançado Trindade, K. Chan, A.-L. Chané, B. Concolino, P. Couvreur, G. De Baere, A. Follesdal, D. Fransen, P. Gautier, P. Lemmens, K. Lenaerts, P. Van den Bossche, H. Van Houtte, J. Wouters

This project was undertaken not so much as a farewell to the contribution Adama Dieng has selflessly offered to humanity, but mainly as a token of appreciation to his dedication and contribution to the rule of law and human rights, especially in his native continent, Africa. As a high-ranking international civil servant, diplomat, teacher, activist and accomplished jurist, Adama Dieng has inspired, and indeed continues to inspire, a generation of men and women both in Africa and beyond with his unqualified commitment to the advancement of the ideals reflected in the United Nations Charter and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Through his work and commitment to the cause of international justice and conflict prevention, he has consistently placed the interests of his fellow men and women, and indeed those of his continent, before his own interests. It is, therefore, in recognition of his efforts that, his fellow jurists, friends and colleagues decided to honour his contribution through a collection of essays on a life dedicated to the advancement of international peace and justice through the rule of law. The contributions gathered here represent, in good measure, the values and beliefs in rule of law and human rights that have characterized Adama's commitment to work towards a better Africa and a better world.

Der Themenschwerpunkt dieses Bandes des Jahrbuchs ist der Frage nach »Grund und Grenzen der Solidarität in Recht und Ethik – Foundation and Limitation of Solidarity in Law and Ethics« gewidmet. Dieser Fragestellung wird zunächst mit einer Begriffsklärung im Bereich von Ethik und Recht nachgegangen. Danach werden Problemfelder des Solidaritätsbegriffs im Hinblick auf die Staatsverfassung und das gesellschaftliche Zusammenleben näher analysiert. Abgeschlossen wird der diesjährige Band des Jahrbuchs wieder mit einem für unterschiedliche Themenstellungen aus dem »Bereich Recht und Ethik« geöffneten Diskussionsforum.

This volume is a follow-up of the international conference'Courts, Interpretation, the Rule of Law,'which was organized on October 19, 2012, at the Faculty of Law, University of Belgrade. This was an annual conference of the Serbian Association for Legal and Social Philosophy, which operates as the Serbian section of the International Association for Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy (IVR). At the same time, the conference was convened as part of the ongoing project'Constitutionalism and Rule of Law in the Nation-State Building - The Case of Serbia,'which is funded by the Ministry of Science of the Republic of Serbia. Contents include: The Concept, Rule and Interpretation of Law Ors • Adjudication, Democracy, and the Rule of Law • Legal Hermeneutics and Jurisprudence • Various Aspects of Judicial Reasoning. (Series: Democracy and the Rule of Law - Vol. 2)

This timely volume by distinguished scholar Günter Frankenberg offers a sophisticated analysis and sharp critique of the reactions of nations such as the US, Great Britain and Germany to perceived terrorist threats, organized crime actions and other political emergencies that have occurred in recent years. The author demonstrates how governments have increasingly sacrificed the rule of law and human rights for the benefit of security programs – as evidenced by a rise in extraordinary measures such as surveillance, detention and torture – thus normalizing the state of exception and privileging preemptive, proactive and coercive methods of political engineering. An interdisciplinary and multi-jurisdictional study, this book develops and implements a unique theoretical and conceptual framework for understanding the rise of technical-political rationality and the fall of the rule of law, and submits both to a firm critique. Particularly relevant in light of current controversies, this provocative book will appeal to scholars and students of international and constitutional law, legal theory, political science, and terrorism studies.

To speak of human rights in the twenty-first century is to speak of proportionality. Proportionality has been received into the constitutional doctrine of courts in continental Europe, the United Kingdom, Canada, New Zealand, Israel, South Africa, and the United States, as well as the jurisprudence of treaty-based legal systems such as the European Convention on Human Rights. Proportionality provides a common analytical framework for resolving the great moral and political questions confronting political communities. But behind the singular appeal to proportionality lurks a range of different understandings. This volume brings together many of the world's leading constitutional theorists - proponents and critics of proportionality - to debate the merits of proportionality, the nature of rights, the practice of judicial review, and moral and legal reasoning. Their essays provide important new perspectives on this leading doctrine in human rights law.

For too long, the rule of law has been assumed as opposed to rigorously interrogated. Christopher May's excellent study not only draws attention to this oversight, but also lucidly demonstrates how and why the rule of law rule of law has achieved the status of common sense of global politics. For anyone interested in the legalization of global politics as well as its social, political and ideological consequences, this superb book is essential reading.'- Susanne Soederberg, Queen s University, CanadaThis timely book explores the complexities of the rule of law - a well-used but perhaps less well understood term - to explain why it is so often appealed to in discussions of global politics. Ranging from capacity building and the role of the World Bank to the discourse(s) of lawyers and jurisprudential critiques, it seeks to introduce non-lawyers to the important and complex political economy of the rule of law.In accessible terms, Christopher May argues that we can no longer merely use the idea of the rule of law without question but rather must appreciate its multifaceted and contested character if we are to begin to understand how and why it is now seen as a'good thing'across the political spectrum. He expertly examines the problems encountered by rule of law programes in post-conflict and developing countries, as well as presenting the range of contested meanings of the term. The author also considers the possibility of establishing a pluralistic account of the rule of law and investigates the plausibility of an international rule of law.By building on and extending debates in socio-legal studies about the social role of law, and dealing with issues largely absent from international political economy this book will be of great interest to socio - legal scholars and political economists. It also presents an overarching analysis of the manner in which politics and law interact that will be of great value to political scientists and development economists.Contents: Preface Introduction: The Rule of Law as the Common Sense of Global Politics 1. The Rule of Law as Social Imaginary, A Methodological Interlude: How I Do (Global) Political Economy 2. Defining the Rule of Law, Between Thick and Thin Conceptions 3. The Rule of Law and the Legaliization of Politics 4. Building the Rule of Law With a Political Focus 5. Building the Rule of Law With an Economic Focus 6. Global Constitutionalism. The Rule of Law by Another Name? 7. One Rule of Law or Many? Internal and External Challenges to the Rule of Law 8. Concluding Thoughts Bibliography Index

Der Themenschwerpunkt dieses Bandes des Jahrbuchs für Recht und Ethik lautet: »Das Rechtsstaatsprinzip – The Rule of Law-Principle«. Die Beiträge hierzu geben einen Überblick über die Gemeinsamkeiten und Unterschiede der beiden Prinzipien, die oftmals etwas ungenau bloß als wechselseitige Übersetzungen verstanden werden. Untersuchungen zu den Grundlagen der beiden Prinzipien im vorliegenden Band zeigen, dass sie zwar aufeinander bezogen sind, aber durchaus eine unterschiedliche rechtsgeschichtliche Entwicklung genommen haben und deshalb auch die mit ihnen verbundenen Inhalte differieren können. Darüber hinaus befassen sich mehrere Beiträge mit speziellen Anwendungsproblemen der beiden Prinzipien. Es schließt sich weiterhin ein Abschnitt mit Beiträgen zur Interpretation von Kants Rechts- und Moralphilosophie, insbesondere in seinem Werk Die Metaphysik der Sitten von 1797, an.

This book elaborates and defends the idea of law without the state. Animated by a vision of peaceful, voluntary cooperation as a social ideal and building on a careful account of non-aggression, it features a clear explanation of why the state is illegitimate, dangerous and unnecessary. It proposes an understanding of how law enforcement in a stateless society could be legitimate and what the optimal substance of law without the state might be, suggests ways in which a stateless legal order could foster the growth of a culture of freedom, and situates the project it elaborates in relation to leftist, anti-capitalist and socialist traditions.

In most post-conflict states, a strong level of legal pluralism is the norm, particularly in regions of Africa and Asia where between eighty and ninety per cent of disputes are resolved through non-state legal mechanisms. The international community, in particular the United Nations, persistently drives the re-establishment of the rule of law in war-torn areas where, traditionally, customary law is prevalent. Laura Grenfell traces the international community's evolving understanding of the rule of law in such regions and explores the implications of strong legal pluralism for the rule-of-law enterprise. Using the comparative examples of two unique case studies, South Africa and Timor-Leste, Promoting the Rule of Law in Post-Conflict States provides insight into the relationship between the rule of law and legal pluralism. Alongside these studies, the book offers a comprehensive introduction to the conceptual framework of the rule of law in the context of approaches taken by the international community.

Das Jahrhundert der Aufklärung ist nach Kant das »Jahrhundert Friedrichs«. Er schafft unmittelbar nach seinem Regierungsantritt die Folter ab und mildert die Härten der mittelalterlichen Rechtspflege. Wie schon sein Vater, Friedrich Wilhelm I., modernisiert er die Rechtspflege, wobei er unter dem Einfluss Montesquieus die Unabhängigkeit der Gerichte stärkt und vor ihnen den Gesetzen freien Lauf lassen will, was ihn allerdings nicht hindert, gelegentlich, wie im Falle des Müllers Arnold, von seinen Maximen abzuweichen. Mit dem »Allgemeinen Landrecht für die preußischen Staaten«, dessen Entstehung er ungeduldig vorantreibt, bahnt er Preußen den Weg in den Rechtsstaat. Obwohl das Landrecht erst acht Jahre nach dem Tode des Königs in Kraft trat, bleibt es das »Gesetzbuch Friedrichs des Großen« und wird wegen seiner Verständlichkeit und Volkstümlichkeit auch Preußens weltliche Bibel genannt.

When property rights and environmental legislation clash, what side should the Rule of Law weigh in on? It is from this point that Jeremy Waldron explores the Rule of Law both from an historical perspective - considering the property theory of John Locke - and from the perspective of modern legal controversies. This critical and direct account of the relation between the Rule of Law and the protection of private property criticizes the view - associated with the'World Bank model'of investor expectations - that a society which fails to protect property rights against legislative restriction is failing to support the Rule of Law. In this book, developed from the 2011 Hamlyn Lectures, Waldron rejects the idea that the Rule of Law privileges property rights over other forms of law and argues instead that the Rule of Law should endorse and applaud the use of legislation to achieve valid social objectives.

This work demonstrates that Power is prior to Rights and introduces a concept of a Power-Responsibility relationship which affects non-legal moral questions such as the treatment of animals.

In diesem Band werden Überlegungen zum Spannungsverhältnis zwischen Recht und Politik zusammengeführt. Dabei werden Fragen zur rechtsstaatlichen Konstitution von Staatswesen aufgegriffen, die sonst eher am Rande allgemeiner Staatstheorien behandelt werden. Allerdings sollen nicht nur Grenzfragen, sondern immer auch Grundfragen der politischen Ethik zur Sprache kommen. Insbesondere geht es darum, die Reichweite politischer Verantwortlichkeit zu konkretisieren (1. Kapitel), die Gewaltenteilung als Strukturnotwendigkeit des Rechtsstaates zu belegen (2. Kapitel), die starre Dichotomie von Rechtsstaat und Unrechtsstaat infrage zu stellen (3. Kapitel), die Möglichkeiten des Strafrechts bei der »Aufarbeitung« von untergegangenen Unrechtsregimen zu diskutieren (4. Kapitel), die Modalitäten noch akzeptabler Kooperation mit Unrechtsstaaten zu beschreiben (5. Kapitel), die Grenzen des Einsatzes heimlicher Ermittlungsmaßnahmen im Rechtsstaat näher zu bestimmen (6. Kapitel), die Leistungsfähigkeit umfassender Formeln zum Auffinden von Gerechtigkeit zu untersuchen (7. Kapitel), den möglichen Zusammenhang einer Rechtfertigung von Kollateralschäden und Kollektivschuld der betroffenen Staatsbürger zu klären (8. Kapitel) und schließlich die Grenzen eines Folterverbots im Rechtsstaat zu erörtern (9. Kapitel). Soweit dabei auf bereits publizierte Texte zurückgegriffen wurde, sind diese erheblich überarbeitet und ergänzt worden.

An indispensable book for all those concerned about the lasting success of international peacekeeping missions.

Eigenschaften sind, die ihnen im Vergleich mit anderen Normen der Rechtsordnung zukommen. Drittens werden die Anwendungsbedingungen von Prinzipien und Regeln untersucht. Einerseits soll bewiesen werden, dass die Prinzipien nicht nur Werte explizieren, sondern mittelbar auch bestimmte Arten von Verhalten; andererseits wird der Nachweis erbracht, dass die Einführung von Verhaltensweisen durch Regeln auch Gegenstand der Abwägung sein kann. Vorgeschlagen wird ein Modell der Erklärung der Normarten, das über die Einfügung einer strukturierten Abwägung in den Anwendungsprozess hinaus noch materiale Gerechtigkeitskriterien in die Argumentation aufnimmt. Dies geschieht vermittels der analytischen Rekonstruktion der konkreten Verwendung der normativen Postulate, besonders des Postulats der Zumutbarkeit und der Verhältnismäßigkeit. Während die Rechtslehre tatsächlich im allgemeinen von der Auslegung der Regeln und der Anwendung der Prinzipien ausgeht, wird diese Unterscheidung in der vorliegenden Arbeit kritisiert. Es wird der Versuch unternommen, Abwägungsfähigkeit auch der Regeln nachzuweisen. Während die Rechtslehre behauptet, dass ein Normtext aufgrund einer Entscheidung zwischen sich wechselseitig ausschließenden Optionen entweder eine Regel oder ein Prinzip ist, werden im nachfolgenden Forschungsvorhaben inkludierende Alternativen zwischen den manchmal aus einem einzigen Normtext hervorgebrachten Spezies vertreten. Während sich die Rechtslehre auf die Verhältnismäßigkeit und Zumutbarkeit mal als Prinzipien, mal als Regeln bezieht, kritisiert der Autor diese Konzeptionen und schlägt in Vertiefung einer älteren Arbeit eine neue Kategorie vor.

This book is a collection of essays that identify and analyze a new phase in thinking about the role of law in economic development and in the practices of development agencies that support law reform. The authors trace the history of theory and doctrine in this field, relating it to changing ideas about development and its institutional practices. The essays describe a new phase in thinking about the relation between law and economic development and analyze how this rising consensus differs from previous efforts to use law as an instrument to achieve social and economic progress. In analyzing the current phase, these essays also identify tensions and contradictions in current practice. This work is a comprehensive treatment of this emerging paradigm, situating it within the intellectual and historical framework of the most influential development models since World War II.

The rule of law is the most important political ideal today, yet there is much confusion about what it means and how it works. This 2004 book explores the history, politics, and theory surrounding the rule of law ideal, beginning with classical Greek and Roman ideas, elaborating on medieval contributions to the rule of law, and articulating the role played by the rule of law in liberal theory and liberal political systems. The author outlines the concerns of Western conservatives about the decline of the rule of law and suggests reasons why the radical Left have promoted this decline. Two basic theoretical streams of the rule of law are then presented, with an examination of the strengths and weaknesses of each. The book examines the rule of law on a global level, and concludes by answering the question of whether the rule of law is a universal human good.

This book examines the serious social problems that are addressed by liberty and the background or natural rights and procedures that distinguish liberty from license.