1. Difference-making and the control relation that grounds responsibility in hierarchical groups.
- Author
-
Himmelreich, Johannes
- Subjects
- *
RESPONSIBILITY , *ORGANIZATIONAL ethics , *CAUSATION (Philosophy) , *RESPONDEAT superior , *ACCOMPLICES - Abstract
Hierarchical groups shape social, political, and personal life. This paper concerns the question of how individuals within such groups can be responsible. The paper explores how individual responsibility can be partially grounded in difference-making. The paper concentrates on the control condition of responsibility and takes into view three distinct phenomena of responsibility in hierarchical groups. First, a superior can be responsible for outcomes that her subordinates bring about. Second, a subordinate can be responsible although she is unable to prevent the outcome she brings about. Third, a superior can sometimes be responsible to a greater degree than her subordinates. It is argued that difference-making, as an interpretation of the control condition that partially grounds responsibility, accounts for all three of these phenomena within a limited but significant range of circumstances and can hence partially ground individual moral responsibility in hierarchical groups. The paper provides an element of a theory of individual responsibility to complement theories of corporate responsibility. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF