1. New diagnosis in psychiatry: beyond heuristics.
- Author
-
McGorry PD, Hickie IB, Kotov R, Schmaal L, Wood SJ, Allan SM, Altınbaş K, Boyce N, Bringmann LF, Caspi A, Cuthbert B, Gawęda Ł, Groen RN, Guloksuz S, Hartmann JA, Krueger RF, Mei C, Nieman D, Öngür D, Raballo A, Scheffer M, Schreuder MJ, Shah JL, Wigman JTW, Yuen HP, and Nelson B
- Subjects
- Humans, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Heuristics, Psychiatry methods, Mental Disorders diagnosis, Mental Disorders classification
- Abstract
Background: Diagnosis in psychiatry faces familiar challenges. Validity and utility remain elusive, and confusion regarding the fluid and arbitrary border between mental health and illness is increasing. The mainstream strategy has been conservative and iterative, retaining current nosology until something better emerges. However, this has led to stagnation. New conceptual frameworks are urgently required to catalyze a genuine paradigm shift., Methods: We outline candidate strategies that could pave the way for such a paradigm shift. These include the Research Domain Criteria (RDoC), the Hierarchical Taxonomy of Psychopathology (HiTOP), and Clinical Staging, which all promote a blend of dimensional and categorical approaches., Results: These alternative still heuristic transdiagnostic models provide varying levels of clinical and research utility. RDoC was intended to provide a framework to reorient research beyond the constraints of DSM. HiTOP began as a nosology derived from statistical methods and is now pursuing clinical utility. Clinical Staging aims to both expand the scope and refine the utility of diagnosis by the inclusion of the dimension of timing. None is yet fit for purpose. Yet they are relatively complementary, and it may be possible for them to operate as an ecosystem. Time will tell whether they have the capacity singly or jointly to deliver a paradigm shift., Conclusions: Several heuristic models have been developed that separately or synergistically build infrastructure to enable new transdiagnostic research to define the structure, development, and mechanisms of mental disorders, to guide treatment and better meet the needs of patients, policymakers, and society.
- Published
- 2025
- Full Text
- View/download PDF