1. ON THE USE OF HISTORICAL DOCUMENTS AND EVIDENCE.
- Author
-
Silver, Burton B.
- Subjects
SOCIAL sciences ,SOCIAL interaction ,CITIES & towns ,CONDUCT of life ,LIFESTYLES ,SOCIAL structure ,QUALITY of life - Abstract
The article comments on a paper exploring the notion that nighttime social life in urban areas resembles social life on former land frontiers, published in one of the previous issues of the journal. The paper was authored by sociologist Murray Melvin. The author of the article objects the use of historical materials and evidences to test the hypothesis that nighttime urban social organization parallels frontier social organization. It is opined that Melvin exhibits a cavalier expediency with regard to historical data which both weakens a potentially useful argument as well as nullifies any test of relationships. Further, the importance of accurate archival data to Melbin's argument cannot be overlooked. This archival evidence as presented, is no more than introductory sociology term paper tactics. The use of historical materials cannot be taken lightly. The utility of this approach is to observe concepts and variables in a context of closure and control. While there is inevitable error in these sources, the strength of the context which provides closure, control, and no recurrent input gives yet another framework with which to understand the dynamics of society.
- Published
- 1978
- Full Text
- View/download PDF