Search

In a criminal trial, the reconstruction of a crime is one of the fundamental steps of the prosecution process. Common questions, such as what happened, where and how it happened, and who made it happen, need to be solved. Biological evidence at crime scenes can be crucial in the determination of these fundamental questions. One of the more challenging riddles to solve is the when? A trace left at a crime scene can prove a person's presence at the crime scene. Knowledge about when it was deposited there, the time since deposition (TsD), would allow linking the person in space and time to the site. This could fortify allegations against a suspect or discharge accusations if proven to be outside of the temporal boundaries where a suspected crime had occurred. Determining the TsD has yet to become routine forensic casework, despite recent research efforts, especially for blood traces. However, next to blood, other biological traces are also commonly encountered in crime scenes. We here present a study to profile the metabolomes of artificially aged dried body fluid spots of blood, semen, saliva, and urine over 4 weeks by liquid chromatography high-resolution mass spectrometry and data-dependent acquisition. All four body fluids (BFs) exhibited diverse time-dependent changes, and a large number of molecular features (MF) were associated with TsD. Still, significant differences between the BFs were observed, limiting universal interpretability independent of the BF and facilitating a need to further study time-dependent changes of different BFs individually toward the goal of TsD estimation.

Knowledge about when a bloodstain was deposited at a crime scene can be of critical value in forensic investigation. A donor of a genetically identified bloodstain could be linked to a suspected time frame and the crime scene itself. Determination of the time since deposition (TsD) has been extensively studied before but has yet to reach maturity. We therefore conducted a proof-of-principle study to study time- and storage-dependent changes of the proteomes of dried blood stains. A bottom-up proteomics approach was employed, and high-resolution liquid-chromatography-mass-spectrometry (HR-LC-MS) and data-independent acquisition (DIA) were used to analyze samples aged over a 2 month period and two different storage conditions. In multivariate analysis, samples showed distinct clustering according to their TsD in both principal component analysis (PCA) and in partial least square discriminant analysis (PLS DA). The storage condition alters sample aging and yields different separation-driving peptides in hierarchical clustering and in TsD marker peptide selection. Certain peptides and amino acid modifications were identified and further assessed for their applicability in assessing passed TsD. A prediction model based on data resampling (Jackknife) was applied, and prediction values for selected peptide ratios were created. Depending on storage conditions and actual sample age, mean prediction performances ranges in between 70 and 130% for the majority of peptides and time points. This places this study as a first in investigating LC-MS based bottom-up proteomics approaches for TsD determination.

Contamination is a highly controversial issue in hair analysis. Therefore, hair testing protocols typically include wash steps to remove contamination. However, recent studies claim that washing could also lead to permanent incorporation of contaminants into hair, thus questioning the validity of hair testing at all. In the present study, matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry (MALDI-MS) with longitudinal sectioning of single hairs and different decontamination protocols was used to reveal differences between the incorporation of a substance into hair from external sources and an incorporation via bloodstream. Single hairs were longitudinally sectioned using a custom-made sample holder. Data were acquired with MALDI-MS by rastering each hair individually. Single hair samples from drug users, blank hairs, and zolpidem- and zolpidem-D6-soaked hairs were investigated. Different published washing protocols were tested, and an in-house washing protocol was developed. For images with higher spatial resolution, time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (ToF-SIMS) was used. Longitudinal sectioning of hairs dramatically increased sensitivity; even single-dose administrations of zolpidem in single hairs could thus be detected using MALDI-MS. Zolpidem from external sources could be detected in large quantities in superficial hair structures. Zolpidem from consumer hairs, proposed to be strongly bound to inner hair structures, could not be completely removed even by the strongest tested decontamination protocol, whereas zolpidem-soaked hairs could be cleared almost completely with the developed in-house wash protocol. The applied methods allowed a first insight into the connection of decontamination protocols and wash-in phenomena in hair analysis. Further studies with other drugs are necessary to assess the general validity of these findings.

High resolution mass spectrometry and modern data independent acquisition (DIA) methods enable the creation of general unknown screening (GUS) procedures. However, even when DIA is used, its potential is far from being exploited, because often, the untargeted acquisition is followed by a targeted search. Applying an actual GUS (including untargeted screening) produces an immense amount of data that must be dealt with. An optimization of the parameters regulating the feature detection and hit generation algorithms of the data processing software could significantly reduce the amount of unnecessary data and thereby the workload. Design of experiment (DoE) approaches allow a simultaneous optimization of multiple parameters. In a first step, parameters are evaluated (crucial or noncrucial). Second, crucial parameters are optimized. The aim in this study was to reduce the number of hits, without missing analytes. The obtained parameter settings from the optimization were compared to the standard settings by analyzing a test set of blood samples spiked with 22 relevant analytes as well as 62 authentic forensic cases. The optimization lead to a marked reduction of workload (12.3 to 1.1% and 3.8 to 1.1% hits for the test set and the authentic cases, respectively) while simultaneously increasing the identification rate (68.2 to 86.4% and 68.8 to 88.1%, respectively). This proof of concept study emphasizes the great potential of DoE approaches to master the data overload resulting from modern data independent acquisition methods used for general unknown screening procedures by optimizing software parameters.

Sequential window acquisition of all theoretical fragment ion spectra (SWATH) is a data independent acquisition (DIA) method for very fast scanning quadrupole time-of-flight (QTOF) instruments. SWATH repeatedly cycles through 28 consecutive 20 Da precursor isolation windows detecting all precursor ions and fragments MS ALL like and yet fast enough to generate more than 10 data points over the chromatographic peak. It was already shown in previous publications that SWATH, despite its wide Q1 windows, allows the identification of different substances and that SWATH has a higher identification rate than data dependent acquisition approaches. The aim of this study was a proof of concept study whether these same data sets can also enable validated quantification according to international guidelines, exemplified for 39 antidepressants. The validation included recovery, matrix effects, process efficiency, ion suppression, and enhancement of coeluting ions, selectivity, accuracy, precision, and stability. The method using SWATH acquisition proved to be selective, sensitive, accurate, and precise enough for 33 out of the 39 antidepressants. The applicability of SWATH for screening and validated quantification in the same run was successfully tested with authentic whole blood samples containing different antidepressants and other drugs thus proving the QUAL/QUAN abilities of SWATH. In an additional systematic investigation, it could be shown that calibration curves injected a few days after or before the actual sample can be used for quantification with acceptable accuracy.

Single hair analysis normally requires extensive sample preparation microscale protocols including time-consuming steps like segmentation and extraction. Matrix assisted laser desorption and ionization mass spectrometric imaging (MALDI-MSI) was shown to be an alternative tool in single hair analysis, but still, questions remain. Therefore, an investigation of MALDI-MSI in single hair analysis concerning the extraction process, usage of internal standard (IS), and influences on the ionization processes were systematically investigated to enable the reliable application to hair analysis. Furthermore, single dose detection, quantitative correlation to a single hair, and hair strand LC-MS/MS results were performed, and the performance was compared to LC-MS/MS single hair monitoring. The MALDI process was shown to be independent from natural hair color and not influenced by the presence of melanin. Ionization was shown to be reproducible along and in between different hair samples. MALDI image intensities in single hair and hair snippets showed good semiquantitative correlation to zolpidem hair concentrations obtained from validated routine LC-MS/MS methods. MALDI-MSI is superior to LC-MS/MS analysis when a fast, easy, and cheap sample preparation is necessary, whereas LC-MS/MS showed higher sensitivity with the ability of single dose detection for zolpidem. MALDI-MSI and LC-MS/MS segmental single hair analysis showed good correlation, and both are suitable for consumption monitoring of drugs of abuse with a high time resolution.

Forensic and clinical toxicological screening procedures are employing liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) techniques with information-dependent acquisition (IDA) approaches more and more often. It is known that the complexity of a sample and the IDA settings might prevent important compounds from being triggered. Therefore, data-independent acquisition (DIA) methods should be more suitable for systematic toxicological analysis (STA). The DIA method sequential window acquisition of all theoretical fragment-ion spectra (SWATH), which uses Q1 windows of 20-35 Da for data-independent fragmentation, was systematically investigated for its suitability for STA. Quality of SWATH-generated mass spectra were evaluated with regard to mass error, relative abundance of the fragments, and library hits. With the Q1 window set to 20-25 Da, several precursors pass Q1 at the same time and are fragmented, thus impairing the library search algorithms to a different extent: forward fit was less affected than reverse fit and purity fit. Mass error was not affected. The relative abundance of the fragments was concentration dependent for some analytes and was influenced by cofragmentation, especially of deuterated analogues. Also, the detection rate of IDA compared to SWATH was investigated in a forced coelution experiment (up to 20 analytes coeluting). Even using several different IDA settings, it was observed that IDA failed to trigger relevant compounds. Screening results of 382 authentic forensic cases revealed that SWATH's detection rate was superior to IDA, which failed to trigger ∼10% of the analytes.

Matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometric imaging (MALDI-MSI) was used to image the distribution of cocaine and its metabolites in intact single hair samples from chronic users down to a concentration of 5 ng/mg. Acquisitions were performed in rastering mode, at a speed of 1 mm/s and in the selected reaction monitoring (SRM) mode on a MALDI triple quadrupole linear ion trap fitted with a high repetition rate laser (1 kHz). Compared to traditional methods based on LC-MS/MS or GC-MS(/MS) which require to segment the hair to obtain spatial resolution, MALDI-MSI, with a straightforward sample preparation beforehand, allowed obtaining a spatial resolution of 1 mm and thus the chronological information about cocaine consumption contained in a single intact hair over several months could be monitored. The analysis time of an intact single hair sample of 6 cm is approximately of 6 min. Cocaine and its metabolites benzoylecgonine, ethylcocaine, and norcocaine were investigated in nine sets of hair samples for forensic purposes. The analyses were accomplished by spraying α-cyano-4-hydroxycinnamic acid (CHCA), 4-chloro-α-cyano-cinnamic acid (Cl-CCA), or (E)-2-cyano-3-(naphthalen-2-yl)acrylic acid (NpCCA) as MALDI matrices. We also propose a rapid strategy for sensitive confirmatory analyses with both MS/MS and MS(3) experiments performed directly on intact hair samples. Since only part of the hair strand is analyzed, additional analyses are possible at any time on the remaining hair from the strand.