1. On the Referee System as a Barrier to Global Anthropology.
- Author
-
Mathews, Gordon
- Subjects
ANTHROPOLOGY ,HEGEMONY ,SOCIOLOGY ,SOCIAL sciences - Abstract
In the present paper, I first discuss the lack of a truly global anthropology in the world today and consider why such a world anthropology does not exist. I then offer a more personal account, based on my experience as an editor of an international journal attempting, to some extent, to counter the hegemony of the American anthropological core. Finally, I look at the referee system and argue that, for all its benefits, it nonetheless serves to prevent the emergence of a global anthropology. The major questions raised in this paper are how, in an anthropological world riven by a huge gap between the core and periphery, as well as by different national schools of anthropology, can refereeing of journal articles take place in a fair and balanced way; and, if it cannot take place, what does this mean about the nature and future of anthropology as a discipline? [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2010
- Full Text
- View/download PDF