Search

Clinicians often prescribe otic drops anecdotally to try and clear grommets blocked with blood. We carried out an in vitro double-blind randomized controlled study comparing the efficacy of sodium bicarbonate, Locorten Vioform and olive oil drops in clearing Shah grommets placed in 'artificial ears' and blocked with blood in a standardized fashion. There were 33 grommets in each group, and drops were inserted three times a day for 7 days. Olive oil drops cleared 17 of 33 (51.51%), Locorten Vioform cleared one of 33 (3%) and sodium bicarbonate cleared zero of 33 (0%) blocked grommets. Statistical comparison between pairs indicates that olive oil was significantly better than both Locorten Vioform (P < 0.001) and sodium bicarbonate drops (P < 0.001) at clearing grommets blocked with blood.

Around 11-12% of tympanostomy tubes are reported to become blocked by middle ear secretions or blood immediately following surgery, and so no longer function. Many otologists routinely instil an antibiotic and steroid-containing solution at the time of surgery in the belief that this may reduce this complication. The aim of the study was to investigate the efficacy of instilling the antibiotic and steroid-containing solution Sofradex at the time of grommet insertion in preventing grommet blockage. Double-blind randomized-controlled trial, comparing rates of grommet blockage in ears treated with Sofradex drops against control (no drops) in patients undergoing bilateral grommet insertion. Sixty-one pairs of results were obtained. There was a significant difference between the rates of grommet blockage in the two groups. Grommets with Sofradex drops instilled perioperatively were nine times less likely to be blocked than controls [1.6%versus 13.1%, odds ratio (Sofradex/control) = 9.06, 95% confidence interval (CI): 1.04-78.82, P = 0.05]. There was no association between grommet blockage and perioperative bleeding or the nature and presence of middle ear secretions. Sofradex eardrops are effective in reducing the rate of grommet blockage when instilled perioperatively.

•A comprehensive 5-year follow-up study of Paparella grommet use in UK. •Study group consists of children previously treated with short-term grommets and with persistent glue ear. •Mean functional period was 3.73 years with 52% being retainde for the full 5 year duration of the study. •Infection and perforation rates increased with the duration of grommet in-situ and this was especially marked after 36 months. •We advise the elective removal of these long-term grommets after 3 years of function to reduce compication rate.

Several factors are known to affect the length of time a ventilation tube remains in the tympanic membrane. These include the design of ventilation tube, the insertion technique and the presence of intercurrent infection. In addition there are theoretical reasons to suggest that a ventilation tube placed superiorly should remain longer than one placed inferiorly. A randomised prospective study was undertaken on 54 children to test this theory. It showed that there is no significant difference in the extrusion rates for a particular type of ventilation tube (Shah grommet) when comparing the anterosuperior quadrant with the anteroinferior quadrant of the tympanic membrane.

It is commonly acknowledged that otitis media with effusion (OME) can cause behavioural disturbances and that this can be relieved by grommet insertion. However, this widely-held perception has not been documented in the literature. In this study parents were asked to complete a short behavioural questionnaire on the day of the admission and 6 weeks later. A total of 32 children admitted to the Day Care Unit for insertion of grommets at The Royal National Throat, Nose and Ear Hospital, London, UK, were recruited. There was a significant behavioural change, evident by the difference in the scores before and after grommet insertion (P < 0.001).

This paper examines recent trends in glue ear surgery in Scottish children between 1990 and 1994, using routine National Health Service (NHS) data from all 15 Scottish Health Boards (total population 5 132 400 in 1994, with 1 038 296 aged 0–15). Absolute numbers, rates of glue ear operations, and variation in rates declined between 1990 and 1994 across all Health Boards. The proportion of glue ear operations which included grommet insertion increased. Grommet rates in children declined in those Boards with the highest rates, but increased in Boards with the lowest rates, thereby decreasing the variation in grommet rates across Scottish Health Boards from 3.8- in 1990 to 2.6-fold in 1994. Other operations for glue ear, particularly ‘myringotomy and adenoidectomy’, varied 20-fold between Health Boards. The proportion of operations performed as day cases increased, but day cases and repeat grommet insertions still showed two-fold variation across Scotland in 1994. Many aspects of surgical management still show variation, and merit further examination by ENT surgeons and Public Health physicians.

A prospective study on the effect of grommet insertion on the passive Eustachian tube opening pressure was undertaken in children's ears with otitis media with effusion. After an initial immediate improvement following aspiration of the middle ear no further change in Eustachian tube function occurred over 4 subsequent weeks. Grommet insertion probably has no effect on Eustachian tube function.

Sex differences in patients having grommet operations in Scotland were analysed to provide further evidence on whether girls should be managed differently from boys. In children treated at less than one year, 64% were boys, but this proportion declined with age and, after the age of 13 years, became less than 50%. The median age at treatment and the repeat operation rate were similar for both sexes. Different management according to the sex of the patient does therefore not appear to be justified.

The relative ease with which different ear drops pass through grommets of different designs has been investigated using a laboratory model. The viscosities of the various ear drop preparations tested have also been determined. There is a considerable variation in the volume of ear drops required to penetrate ventilation tubes. Their ease of passage is determined by the size of the tube and is probably also related to the ease with which a preparation wets the surface of the grommet. There is no relationship between ease of penetration and viscosity. The penetration of ear drops through grommets during episodes of aural discharge was studied in vivo. Penetration into the middle ear was observed only when the drops were introduced using the displacement technique. It was more readily achieved when the grommet lumen was free of discharge.

Recent investigations have demonstrated an association between sniff-induced negative middle ear pressure and otitis media with effusion. This is taken as evidence of Eustachian tube malfunction. Adenoidectomy is frequently performed as part of the surgical management for otitis media with effusion, but whether this affects Eustachian tube function is uncertain. The aim of this study was to investigate the hypothesis that if adenoidectomy improved Eustachian tube function, children who had undergone adenoidectomy would show less tendency to generate a high negative intratympanic pressure by sniffing. Eustachian tube function was studied actively in 40 children with otitis media with effusion. Twenty children, selected at random, underwent adenoidectomy and all 40 had a unilateral grommet inserted. Eighty-five percent of the children could create a negative middle ear pressure by sniffing, but there was no difference in the number of 'sniff + ve' children between the adenoidectomy and control groups (P greater than 0.5), or in the magnitude of the negative pressure induced. It is concluded that a high percentage of children with otitis media with effusion are capable of inducing a negative middle ear pressure by sniffing, but this parameter of Eustachian tube function is not affected by adenoidectomy.

This paper deals with grommet induced tympanosclerosis. In the first part, patients from a controlled trial of the treatment of bilateral glue ear using unilateral grommet insertion are reviewed 15 years later. Tympanosclerosis due to grommet insertion is summated using computer graphics. Two areas of maximal tympanosclerosis are found, anteriorly and posteriorly midway between the annulus and the umbo. These maximal areas join inferiorly in the classical horse shoe shape. In an attempt to identify reasons for this distribution, the structure of the lamina propria is reviewed, and the changes that occur in tympanosclerosis considered. With this in mind, the tympanic membrane is modelled using finite element methodology to determine the areas of maximal shear stresses. These are found to be in the same position as tympanosclerosis. Such stresses would be increased by the weight of a grommet in situ. These stresses will damage the fibrils interconnecting between the fibrous layers of the lamina propria and this may lead to tympanosclerosis. This raises the question of whether a lighter grommet would decrease the incidence of grommet-induced tympanosclerosis.

This study evaluates whether the use of grommets in the primary treatment really changes the course of secretory otitis media. The patient acts as his own control. Bilateral cases are selected and one ear is treated by a grommet, the other left intact, and all have their adenoids removed. Until now 91 children have been entered. A repeated operation was done in 13, and 6 of them had a contralateral grommet because of persisting middle ear effusion. A discharge occurred from 25% of the operated ears. After the operation the intact ears showed a great improvement in the function of the Eustachian tube according to the tympanograms. The hearing level was normalized within 3 months in both intact and operated ears. In 28 children the grommets had been extruded for more than one month. By comparing the intact and the operated ears no significant statistical difference was found.

The management of otitis media with effusion in adults The management of 38 patients with idiopathic adult onset otitis media with effusion was evaluated retrospectively. Data from 50 ears were reviewed. The standard treatment consisted of myringotomy and grommet insertion. The patients were followed up for an average period of 27 months. Only 2 ears maintained a significant improvement in the air-bone gap when reviewed approximately 3 months following grommet extrusion. In all of the others, the hearing impairment recurred, and continued to recur despite multiple grommet insertions in several patients. It is concluded that adult onset otitis media with effusion has a low tendency to resolve, and that conventional surgical measures have little to offer in its management.