1. Both too much and too little: exploring the paradox of federalism in Quebec and the rest of Canada.
- Author
-
Anderson, Lawrence
- Subjects
- *
PARADOX , *SECESSION -- Social aspects , *POLITICAL autonomy ,CANADIAN federal government - Abstract
Research on federalism has arrived at paradoxical conclusions. In some instances, federalism seems to calm secessionism; in others, it fans the flames. Attempts have been made to identify the conditions under which federalism does one or the other. Not surprisingly, then, this research focuses on cases in which federalism works or federalism fails. This focus has developed an overly simplistic view of the impact of federalism in select environments. Federalism is indeed a paradox, but the paradox goes much deeper than has been noted: even in the same county, federalism fans the flames of secessionism for some groups and reduces such calls in others. Canada is often explored as a case of federalism failing to stem the tide of secessionism. In Quebec, for example, secessionists have adeptly used federal institutions to bring Quebec to the brink of independence. This fails to note two obvious points: first, federalists continue to win the day in Quebec; second, independence movements have developed in other parts of Canada. This paper explores the impact of federalism on territorial politics in Canada and its implications for studies of the paradox of federalism. ..PAT.-Unpublished Manuscript [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2009