Search

Undergraduate otolaryngology teaching in the UK is generally limited primarily due to curriculum time constraints with traditional face-to-face (FtF) teaching being restrained by the limitations of time and location. Advances in network technology have opened up new doors for the delivery of teaching in the form of online learning. This study compares a traditional instructor-led lecture with synchronous e-learning (SeL) using otolaryngological emergencies teaching as an educational intervention. A randomised controlled trial was designed involving two groups of medical students attending an otolaryngology emergencies management lecture: one present FtF and the other viewing the streamed lecture online. The primary outcome measure was improvement between pre-and post-lecture test scores. Secondary outcomes comprised the students' ratings of the lecture on a Likert-type scale. Students in both groups had improved test scores following the lecture ( p < 0.001 for both groups) and there was no difference in magnitude of improvement in test scores between the two groups ( p = 0.168). There was no difference in student ratings between the two groups for the usefulness of the lecture ( p = 0.484), interactivity ( p = 0.834) and meeting educational needs ( p = 0.968). The FtF group, however, was more satisfied overall ( p = 0.034). This study demonstrates that SeL may be as effective as FtF teaching in improving students' knowledge on the management of otolaryngological emergencies, and that it is generally positively perceived by medical undergraduates. This highlights the potential utility of e-learning technology in undergraduate otolaryngology training. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Early enteral feeding is vital for successful outcomes in patients who have undergone open pharyngeal surgery, with nasogastric tube (NGT) feeding being a safe and accepted method of providing enteral nutrition in the short-term. Securing the NGT is key to ensure adequate caloric consumption and avoid the potential complications of re-siting the tube. The aim of this study was to compare the efficacy of utilising an anterior septal suture to a bridle system for NGT fixation. A sheep's head model was used to represent the nasal cavity of post-operative patients and a fine-bore NGT was passed. The NGT was secured with either an anterior septal suture or bridle system. A pulley system of weights was applied until the NGT slipped or snapped. Each weight and condition was investigated five times. The anterior and posterior septum were examined for evidence of damage for each condition. At 5 kg the anterior septal suture allowed the NGT to slip and the tube began to become distorted. At 5.5 kg the anterior septal suture snapped the NGT. In comparison, the bridle system was able to sustain a weight up to 15.5 kg (Fisher's exact test, p = 0.0079). There was no evidence of damage to the anterior or posterior septum for each condition. The bridle system was able to fix the NGT without slippage or damage at higher weights than the anterior septal suture. This suggests there may be potential benefits of stronger NGT fixation with reduced tube damage using bridle systems in patients, but further research is required in this domain. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Tympanometric evaluation is a routine part of the complete otological examination. Although tympanometry when performed in standard conditions is known to accurately and precisely assess ear canal volume, the effects of variation in temperature have not been reported upon. This study examines the effect of temperature on the capability of the tympanometer to accurately evaluate external auditory canal volume in both simple and partially obstructed Ear Canal Models. An Ear Canal Model was designed using simple laboratory equipment including a 5 ml calibrated clinical syringe. This was attached to the sensing probe of a Kamplex tympanometer. Two basic trials were undertaken: (a) evaluation of the effect of temperature on the tympanometer in simple canal volume measurement and (b) assessing canal volume with partial canal occlusion. These studies were conducted at 0, 10, 20 and 30 °C in a Thermotron climatic chamber. 1,400 individual test scenarios were completed over the two arms of the study. At volumes of 1.4 cm or below, tympanometry had a very high level of correlation (Spearman's ρ = 1) with the actual volume present at all tested temperatures except 0 °C. There was no significant relationship between temperature and degree of error in ear canal volume measurement in both simple and partially occluded models. The ability of the Kamplex tympanometer to accurately and precisely assess ear canal volume in this scientific model in both simple and partially occluded scenarios up to a volume of 1.4 cm is not effected by ambient temperature. These findings suggest the Kamplex tympanometer could be used as an effective objective tool in both laboratory and human models of the external auditory canal. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Tonsillectomy is a common therapeutic option in the management of recurrent tonsillitis. In 1999, the Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network (SIGN) introduced SIGN 34 outlining appropriate indications for tonsillectomy. Following concerns of increasing hospital admissions for tonsillitis, in 2009 ENT UK suggested that too few tonsillectomies were being undertaken. This study analyses the effect the SIGN guidelines have had on trends in population rates of tonsillectomy and hospital admissions for tonsillitis and peritonsillar abscess in England, Scotland and Wales. A retrospective study was undertaken using the health databases of England, Scotland and Wales between 1999 and 2010. Tonsillectomy, acute tonsillitis and peritonsillar abscess were identified using national classification codes. Changes in rate of tonsillectomy and hospital admissions for tonsillitis and peritonsillar abscess were assessed using a linear regression model. 699,898 tonsillectomies were undertaken in the three national cohorts over the study period. Linear regression analysis suggested that implementation of SIGN 34 significantly reduced the population rate of tonsillectomy in England ( p = 0.005) and Wales ( p = 0.003) but not in Scotland ( p = 0.24), and indicated there had been an increase in hospital admissions for acute tonsillitis in all cohorts (England p = 0.000008, Scotland p = 0.03, Wales p = 0.000005) and peritonsillar abscess in England ( p < 0.05) and Wales ( p = 0.03). SIGN 34 has reduced tonsillectomy rates in England and Wales but not in Scotland. This finding is associated with increasing hospital admissions for acute tonsillitis in all national cohorts, which may suggest that the current stipulated guidelines miss patients who would benefit from surgical intervention. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Rhinosinusitis is a common condition with adults experiencing 2-5 episodes per year. The European Positional Paper on Rhinosinusitis and Nasal Polyps (EP3OS) published in 2005 and updated in 2007 provided evidence-based guidelines on the management of sinus disease promoting a conservative approach to treatment. This study examines the effect of EP3OS on sinus surgery uptake and acute admissions for sinusitis in England and Wales. A retrospective study using the national electronic health databases of England (Hospital Episodes Statistics, HES online) and Wales (Patient Episodes Database of Wales, PEDW) was undertaken from 2000 to 2010 using the OPCS-4 codes E12-E17 (sinus surgery) and ICD10 code J01 (acute admission for sinusitis). Data were analysed for effect following the introduction of the EP3OS in 2005 using linear regression and Chi squared analysis. 116,370 sinus procedures and 10,916 acute admissions for sinusitis were made during the study period. No significant decrease in sinus surgery procedures occurred following the introduction of the EP3OS as may have been expected ( p > 0.05), although subgroup analysis suggested a significant increase in Wales ( p < 0.05). In addition, significant increases in acute admissions for sinusitis were observed following the introduction of EP3OS ( p < 0.05). However, subgroup analysis suggested this was not the case in Wales ( p > 0.05). The EP3OS appears to have had little impact on the rates of sinus surgery but more conservative approaches to managing of sinus disease may have led to an increase in acute admissions. Further research is required to investigate whether changes in practice were adopted. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Grommets insertion is a common otolaryngological procedure for the treatment of persistent otitis media with effusion. In 2002, the Department of Health (DoH) Day Surgery guidelines stipulated that at least 75% of grommets insertions should be undertaken as day-cases. In 2008, after governmental perception of a higher than necessary grommet insertion rate, the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) guidelines aimed at reducing inappropriate grommet insertions. This study analyses the effect these national interventions have had on grommets insertion in England and Wales. A retrospective study was undertaken. Data were extracted from the patient episode databases of England (Health Episode Statistics) and Wales (Patient Episode Database of Wales) from 2000 until 2010 using OPCS-4 code D151. Statistical change in practice following the introduction of the interventions was assessed using linear regression. Results: 341,526 and 16,400 grommets insertions were performed in England and Wales, respectively. Linear regression analysis demonstrated that implementation of the Day Surgery guidelines significantly improved day-case rates in both national cohorts (England P < 0.0001, Wales P < 0.0001) and reduced mean waiting times for grommets insertion in both cohorts (England P < 0.05, Wales P < 0.01). Regression analysis also showed that implementation of the NICE guidelines had no effect on the number of grommet insertions in England ( P > 0.5) and Wales ( P > 0.5). In conclusion, the DoH guidelines have increased grommets day-case provision and reduced waiting times in both England and Wales, whereas the NICE guidelines have not affected overall levels of grommet insertion in either national cohort. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]