Search

Alzheimer's disease is one of the most devastating neurodegenerative diseases. The exact cause of the disease is still not known although many scientists believe in the beta amyloid hypothesis which states that the accumulation of the amyloid peptide beta (Aβ) in brain is the initial cause which consequently leads to pathological neuroinflammation. However, it was recently shown that Aβ may have an important role in defending the brain against infections. Thus, the balance between positive and negative impact of Aβ may determine disease progression. Microglia in the brain are innate immune cells, and brain-initiated inflammatory responses reflected in the periphery suggests that Alzheimer's disease is to some extent also a systemic inflammatory disease. Greater permeability of the blood brain barrier facilitates the transport of peripheral immune cells to the brain and vice versa so that a vicious circle originating on the periphery may contribute to the development of overt clinical AD. Persistent inflammatory challenges by pathogens in the periphery, increasing with age, may also contribute to the central propagation of the pathological changes seen clinically. Therefore, the activation status of peripheral innate immune cells may represent an early biomarker of the upcoming impact on the brain. The modulation of these cells may thus become a useful mechanism for modifying disease progression.

As is apparent from the many contributions to this Special Issue of the Journal, the impact of age on immunity is nefarious, with all manner of dysregulated responses attributed to "immunosenescence". These range from poorer responses to vaccination, lower capacity to mediate anti-cancer responses, more inflammation and tissue damage, along with autoimmunity and loss of control of persistent infections. Given the grave clinical implications of altered immune status in aged people, it is of paramount importance to understand the nature of and mechanisms responsible for "immunosenescence". As in any rapidly developing research area, certain paradigms establish themselves early on, by necessity based on earlier and fewer data, and have a disproportionate influence on how investigators think about the subject, especially investigators from other disciplines. It may therefore be appropriate to reconsider our basic knowledge at this juncture, asking exactly what do we mean by the term "immunosenescence"? This is attempted in this contribution to the Special Issue.

In addition to measures already used in clinical practice, molecular measures have been proposed to assess health status, but these have not yet been introduced into clinical practice. We aimed to test the association of functional capacity measures used in current practice and molecular measures with age and health status. The cohort consisted of 178 middle-aged to old participants of the Leiden Longevity Study (range 42-82years). We tested associations between functional capacity measures (physical tests: grip strength, 4-meter walk, chair stand test; cognitive tests: Stroop test, digit symbol substitution test and 15-picture learning test) with age and with cardiovascular or metabolic disease as a measure of the health status. These associations with age and health status were also tested for molecular measures (C reactive protein (CRP), numbers of senescent p16INK4a positive cells in the epidermis and dermis and putative immunosenescence (presence of CD57+ T cells)). All functional capacity measures were associated with age. CRP and epidermal p16INK4a positivity were also associated with age, but with smaller estimates. Grip strength and the Stroop test were associated with cardiovascular or metabolic disease, as was epidermal p16INK4a positivity. All associations with cardiovascular or metabolic disease attenuated when adjusting for age. In conclusion, in middle-aged to old persons, the molecular measures tested here were more weakly associated with age and health status than functional capacity measures. Whether these molecular measures associate more closely with health status in the elderly or in specific groups of patients needs to be explored further.

Immunosenescence resulting in decreased ability to control infectious disease contributes to morbidity and mortality not only in the very elderly, but in all likelihood already from middle age. Studying immunity in humans is therefore essential for developing treatments to restore dysregulated immune responses and assure healthy longevity. The past year has seen many significant advances in our knowledge of age-associated alterations to immunity in elderly people, only some of which can be briefly reviewed here.

T cells undergo rapid clonal expansion upon antigenic stimulation to produce an effective immune response. Any defect in the DNA mismatch repair (MMR) system may have a detrimental effect on T cell proliferation. This study employed an in vitro model of human CD4+T cell ageing to investigate MMR capacity at various stages of T cell lifespan. A novel modification of the alkaline comet assay, which utilised T4 endonuclease VII to detect single base DNA mismatches, was used to assess DNA mismatch frequency. No clear pattern in DNA mismatch frequency with increasing culture age was observed. However, the ability to repair induced DNA mismatches (following treatment with acridine mutagen ICR-191) revealed an age-related decline in the efficiency of the MMR system in clones derived from a 26 and a 45-year-old donor, but not from an 80-year-old very healthy SENIEUR donor. This study suggests that unchallenged, dividing human T cell clones have variable levels of DNA mismatches throughout their lifespan, not affecting proliferation. However, when challenged with supra-physiological levels of DNA mismatches, deficiencies were found in ageing T cell clones in MMR capacity, with the exception of T cell clones from a SENIEUR donor previously shown to maintain effective DNA excision repair.

Physical stress induced in healthy volunteers by the Loughborough intermittent shuttle test (LIST) was used to validate a newly developed whole-blood cell culture system (Instant leukocyte culture system (ILCS). Exercise induced immune modulation was investigated through measurement of cytokine levels after activating leukocytes in peripheral blood ex vivo using the physiologic stimulant lipopolysaccharide (LPS). LPS induced production of three different cytokines, interferon gamma (IFNgamma), interleukin-6 (IL-6), and interleukin-10 (IL-10). IFNgamma levels were significantly decreased (P = 0.02 and P = 0.001 ) and IL-10 levels significantly increased (P= 0.04 and 0.03) after exercise. LPS induced IL-6 production was only marginally further increased by exercise. In conclusion, the ILCS system provided a reliable ex vivo method, showing common as well as subject specific features in the time course of the immune modulation caused by the LIST protocol. This system will be useful for studies of the elderly, where cytokine standardisation is notoriously difficult.

T-cell clones (TCC) derived from human peripheral blood lymphocytes of a young control, a healthy elderly ( SENIEUR ) donor, or from CD34 + hematopoietic progenitor cells were utilised in this study to examine how in vivo and in vitro ageing affects T-cell apoptotic capability. The role of CD25, CD28 and the intracellular proteins, FLICE-inhibitory protein (FLIP), receptor-interacting protein (RIP) and caspase 3 were investigated. We observed an age-related decline in the expression of the IL-2 receptor α chain CD25, and absence of the co-stimulatory receptor CD28 on three of the four TCC studied. In young donor- and CD34 cell-derived TCC, but not in SENIEUR donor-derived TCC, we observed an age-related increase in susceptibility of the cells to mFas-L-induced apoptosis, which correlated with the age-related decrease of CD25 expression. Expression levels of full-length RIP and FLIP did not show any correlation to apoptotic susceptibility. However, expression levels of the cleaved form of RIP were greatly reduced in the SENIEUR donor-derived TCC, which together with a trend towards increased caspase 3 activity, could indicate an age-related alteration in utilisation of different apoptotic signalling pathways.

Immunosenescence is an age-associated decline of immunity involving multiorgan changes. As the mean age of the population increases, an increase of diverse pathologies associated with immunosenescence has been observed in the developed countries. Age-related changes in the immune system contribute to the increased incidence and severity of infectious diseases and possibly cancer in the elderly. Moreover, in young individuals chronic activation of the immune system (as occurs in autoimmune diseases, cancer, HIV infection and other chronic infections) induces changes in the immune response that parallel those observed in elderly individuals. An interdisciplinary approach to immunosenescence including investigation of the molecular and cellular mechanisms and clinical aspects is being utilised by the EU program "Immunology and Ageing in Europe" (ImAginE, QLK6-CT-1999-02031), the second major international conference of which took place in Córdoba, Spain, 22-26th March, 2001). We briefly summarise some of the highlights of the meeting here, and bring together in this special issue a collection of peer-reviewed papers reflecting the broad approach to immunosenescence currently being applied.

The meeting focussed on age-associated alterations in immunity in vivo and in vitro, but also considered other ageing models and other tissues in an interdisciplinary approach to this problem. Because the ImAginE program has been set up to examine how best to take advantage of in vitro models for the analysis of immunosenescence and how the information acquired can be extrapolated to the in vivo situation, the first part of the meeting dealt with manifestations of immunosenescence in vivo and in vitro. Next, the possible mechanisms underlying these changes were discussed, and how this knowledge might be exploited to prevent such alterations or minimise their detrimental effects. Finally, age-associated changes in immunity in vivo, their physiological impact and their possible remediation were considered.

Aging is associated with alterations of the immune system, thought to be related to an increased susceptibility to infectious diseases, and possibly to cancer and autoimmunity in the elderly. In the present paper we report data obtained on freshly collected blood from 148 healthy subjects of different ages (from cord blood to 102 years old). The subjects were divided into seven age classes (cord blood, 3–11 years, 15–39 years, 41–60 years, 61–74 years, 75–84 years, 85–102 years) and their lymphocyte subsets and the expression of the apoptosis-related molecule CD95 were evaluated. In respect of lymphocyte subsets, the major differences were found in the cord-blood samples compared with the oldest old groups. In the cord-blood group, the absolute number of all the lymphocyte subsets was enhanced, but in the oldest group, an increase of CD16+ lymphocytes was observed, whereas CD19+ lymphocytes, which progressively decrease with age, continue to decrease further in the very old. The data show that the expression of CD95 increases until age 74 years, whereas in the oldest old it tends to decrease again. The trend of CD95 expression seems to be related to the change of expression of CD95 on CD4+ lymphocytes, because the CD8+/CD95+ population rose steadily throughout the entire age range. The evaluation of CD95+/CD45R0+ lymphocytes shows similar results to those observed analyzing CD95 on total lymphocytes. Furthermore, a constant increase of CD95+/CD28+ and a related decline of CD28+ lymphocytes was observed in all age groups. These data suggest that the expression of CD95 on the different subsets of lymphocytes can be considered a good marker for studies of immunosenescence, because it may be predictive of successful aging, and can partially explain the change in lymphocytes subsets in elderly.

Several studies have documented finite lifespans of at least the vast majority of cultured human T cell lines and clones. However, there is a great deal of variation among the different preparations, ranging from25 PD up to100 PD. The cultured T cells in all these studies originated from mature T cells isolated from peripheral blood of adult donors. It was, therefore, impossible to assess the contribution of differences in in vivo age to the subsequent differences between clones in in vitro aging. In an attempt to circumvent this difficulty, we have developed a culture system that supports the differentiation of highly purified human CD34+ cells into CD3+ T cells in vitro. This features the use of a serum-free medium supplemented with the cytokines flt-3 ligand, IL 3, stem cell factor (c-kit ligand) and IL 2, together with IL 7 or oncostatin M (OM). In this way it is possible to perform "longitudinal" studies on T cells derived de novo in vitro. We show here that T cell clones derived under these circumstances also manifest variable finite life expectancies, for which the only uncontrolled (nonstochastic) effects of aging must already have occurred at the stem cell level.

“Immunosenescence” is a loosely descriptive designation for age-associated alterations to most measures of immunity, which can be seen in all mammals examined in any detail. Both innate and adaptive immunity are affected in a manner assumed to be deleterious, but often the clinical consequences of the assessed changes are unclear or not even investigated. The mechanisms accounting for these changes, and biomarkers of immunosenescence, are currently the subject of intensive research. Cross-sectional studies have established hallmark age-associated differences between adaptive immune factors in young and old people, particularly a lower number and percentage of naive T cells, especially CD8 + T cells, and accumulations of late-differentiated CD8 + T cells. The latter but not the former is strongly affected by infection with the persistent s-herpesvirus HHV5 (cytomegalovirus, CMV). Only limited longitudinal studies have so far investigated whether these differences actually reflect age-associated changes at the individual level. The Swedish OCTO/NONA-Immune studies identified a set of immune parameters including infection with CMV which predicted survival in people over 85 at baseline. Moreover, the Leiden 85 + study showed that T cell-mediated pro-inflammatory specific for CMV antigens was enriched in very old survivors, suggesting the overarching necessity of maintaining effective immunosurveillance of this virus. Here, the disparate impact of CMV on “immunosenescence” and survival in human populations under different condition is reviewed.

The growth characteristics in vitro of interleukin 2 (IL 2)-dependent human CD4+ alpha beta-T cell receptor-positive helper T cell clones (TCC) were studied in relation to alterations in surface phenotype, cytokine responsiveness, and susceptibility to activation-induced cell death (AICD). TCC derived from peripheral blood T cells had finite lifespans averaging 33 population doublings (PD) with a recorded maximum lifespan of 80 PD (n = 208). First analyses of the TCC were undertaken at ca. 25 PD, at which time all cells of all TCC expressed high intensity CD45RO and low intensity CD45RA, as well as high intensity CD95 (fas) and MHC class II antigens. The expression of these molecules remained elevated throughout the proliferative lifespan of the clones, but for those TCC which were initially CD28+ (the majority), the density of expression of the latter was diminished in most late-passage clones. Concomitant with this, late-passage cells showed reduced responsiveness to CD28-mediated costimulation by CHO transfectants expressing human CD80 compared to early-passage cells. Additionally, the level of expression of IL 2R gamma c and IL 7R chains was commonly reduced, as was the response to IL 2 and IL 7. Despite unchanged levels of fas expression on TCC with time, late-passage cells were more susceptible to AICD than early, passage cells. These observations further document functional and phenotypic alterations in long-term cultured human T helper cells, which may be considered as biomarkers of immunosenescence. This may contribute to an improved understanding of the mechanisms underlying depressed T cell function in old age.

Immunosenescence contributes materially to the decreased ability of the elderly to control infectious disease, which is also reflected in their generally poor response to vaccination. This state is influenced by many genetic and environmental factors, but it has become increasingly clear over the past year that the pathogen load to which individuals are exposed throughout life impacts greatly on immune performance in late life. The link to accelerated immunosenescence in this respect may be via the enhanced pro-inflammatory status observed in the elderly and in chronic disease at any age. Here, we summarise some of the developments in this area and in other important areas of immunosenescence research over the past year.

Herpes viruses (particularly CMV and to some extent EBV) might play a role in accelerating the deterioration of immune functions with age. Indeed, it has been demonstrated that chronic infection with CMV causes an expansion of specific CD8 T lymphocytes and that this is related to a shrinkage of the T cell repertoire in very elderly people, predicting mortality. We have analysed CD8 T cells in young and old healthy Sicilians who were both CMV- and EBV-seropositive. Our data confirm expansions of T cells specific for the HLA-A2-restricted pp65 (495–503) CMV epitope up to nearly 14% of total peripheral CD8 cells in certain elderly individuals (range 0–14%). However, the mean percentage of CMV-specific cells in the elderly was not greater than the young (range 0.2–3%). The CMV-specific CD8 cells in the elderly were predominantly CD45RA+, but in the young they were mostly CD45RO+. Our findings are somewhat different from published reports from Northern European populations, both in terms of mean numbers and surface phenotypes. These findings may reflect disparate hygienic and nutritional conditions 70–90 yr ago, which were very different in Northern and Southern Europe at that time, as well as a different genetic background.

In the present NONA immune longitudinal study, we investigate the previously identified Immune Risk Profile (IRP), defined by an inverted CD4/CD8 ratio and associated with persistent cytomegalovirus infection and increased numbers of CD8+CD28− cells, relative 6-year survival and age in NONA individuals. These subjects have now reached age 92, 96, and for the first time in this study, 100 years at follow-up. A 55 year old middle-aged group was used for comparison. Immunological monitoring included the analysis of numbers of lymphocytes and neutrophils, the T-cell subsets CD3+CD4+, CD3+CD8+, CD8+CD28+, CD8+CD28−, and the CD4/CD8 ratio. Longitudinal data were analysed by multivariate analyses of variance (MANOVA) from four measurement occasions at 2-year inter-intervals. One-way ANOVA was used for cross-sectional comparisons at baseline and the 6-year follow-up. The results confirmed the importance of the IRP as a major predictor of mortality in this population of very old. Moreover, the results suggested that survival to the age of 100 years is associated with selection of individuals with an “inverted” IRP that was stable across time, i.e., maintenance of a high CD4/CD8 ratio and low numbers of CD8+CD28− cells. The results underlines the importance of a longitudinal study design in dissecting immune parameters predictive of survival and show for the first time that centenarian status is associated with avoidance of the IRP over at least the previous 6 years and probably throughout life.

Large clonal expansions of peripheral CD8+ T cells carrying receptors for single epitopes of CMV and EBV are common in the elderly and may be associated with an immune risk phenotype predicting mortality. Here we show that the frequency of CD8+ T cells expressing the inhibitory killer cell lectin-like receptor G1 (KLRG1), a marker of cells unable to undergo further clonal expansion, was markedly elevated in CD8+ T cells from old donors. Moreover, tetramer staining revealed that the elevated frequency of CMV-specific CD8+ T cells in the elderly was due to an accumulation of cells bearing this dominant negative receptor. The fraction of CMV-specific T cells able to secrete interferon-gamma after specific antigenic stimulation was significantly lower in the elderly than in the young, although the total number of functional cells was comparable. Therefore, the majority of the clonally expanded virus-specific CD8+ cells in the elderly was dysfunctional. Thus, T cell responses are altered in the aged by an accumulation of replicatively senescent dysfunctional T cells carrying receptors for persistent herpes viruses. The presence of clonal expansions of such virus-specific cells may shrink the available repertoire for other antigens and contribute to the increased incidence of infectious disease in the elderly.

Oxidative DNA damage has been suggested to contribute to the decline in T cell clone (TCC) function with increased age in vitro. To test this hypothesis the effect of a reduced oxygen tension culture system (6% O2) on TCCs was examined. Specifically, the effects of the altered culture conditions on DNA damage levels, in vitro lifespan and proliferative capacity were assessed in five independently derived human CD4+ TCCs. DNA damage levels over the entire lifespan were significantly lowered by reducing oxygen tension. Lifespan (total population doublings (PDs) achieved) and proliferative capacity (PDs/week) were reduced for all clones under reduced oxygen tension when compared to standard culture conditions. This observed tendency warrants further investigation using a greater number of clones from donors of all age groups before definitive conclusions regarding the effect of low oxygen tension on the lifespan and proliferative capacity of TCC can be made. However, these results may suggest that the reduced oxygen tension culture system has interfered with some aspect of T cell biology not yet examined within the remit of this study.

Many immune functions decline with age and may jeopardize the elderly, as illustrated, for example by the significantly higher mortality rate from influenza in old age. Although innate and humoral immunity are affected by aging, it is the T cell compartment, which manifests most alterations. The mechanisms behind these alterations are still unclear, and several explanations have been offered including thymic involution and Telomere attrition leading to cell senescence. Age related accumulation of mutations has been documented and could serve as an additional mechanism of T cell dysfunction. One effective repair mechanism capable of rectifying errors in DNA replications is the mismatch repair (MMR) system. We previously reported a comparative examination of individual DNA samples from blood cells obtained at 10 year intervals from young and old subjects. We showed significantly higher rates of microsatellite instability (MSI), an indicator of MMR dysfunction in older subjects, compared to young. In the present study we confirm this result, using direct automated sequencing and in addition, we demonstrate that as CD8 lymphocytes from aged individuals, undergo repeated population doublings (PDs) in culture, they develop MSI. CD4 clones that also undergo repeated PDs in culture develop significant MSI as well. Elucidation of this previously unexplored facet of lymphocyte dynamics in relation to aging may help identify novel mechanisms of immunosenescence and pathways that could serve as targets for interventions to restore immune function.

CD4+ human T cell clones were derived from activated peripheral blood lymphocytes of healthy young adults to establish cloning efficiencies (CE) and clonal longevities. These results were compared with those obtained using cells from the very elderly, also in excellent health. CE and both maximal and average longevities under appropriate culture conditions were very similar in the two groups. Moreover, CE of CD34+ hematopoietic progenitor cells and longevities of clones derived from them were also similar. Finally, CE and longevities of clones derived from a patient with chronic myelogenous leukaemia were found to be comparable as well. Hence, T cells with absolutely no antigenic exposure in vivo prior to cloning (i.e. CD34-derived) and those potentially exposed to chronic antigenic stimulation (CML-derived) and those from young or old donors all had similar cloning and propagation properties in vitro. These results imply that the longevity of T cells in culture is more likely to be dictated by cloning conditions than any intrinsic differences between the cells studied.

An age-related increase of DNA damage/mutation has been previously reported in human lymphocytes. The high copy number and mutation rate make the mtDNA genome an ideal candidate for assessing damage and to act as a potential biomarker of ageing. In the present study, two assays were developed to evaluate the level of mtDNA 4977 and the accumulation of point mutations with age. A competitive polymerase chain reaction (PCR) methodology incorporating three primers was used to detect and quantify the levels of mtDNA 4977 and a novel heteroduplex reference strand conformational analysis (RSCA) technique was used to analyse the accumulation of point mutations. The assays were applied to an in vitro model of T cell ageing and ex vivo DNA samples from an elderly cohort of subjects and a younger control group. The mtDNA 4977 was detected in all the DNA samples examined but only a very low concentration was observed and no age-related increase or accumulation was observed. No accumulation of point mutations was identified using RSCA within the T cell clones as they were aged or the ex vivo lymphocytes from the elderly cohort. A higher level of variation was observed within the ex vivo DNA samples, verifying the high resolution of RSCA and its ability to identify different mtDNA species, although no correlation with age was observed. The low level of mtDNA damage observed with respect to the ex vivo lymphocyte DNA samples within this study may be due in part to the high turnover of blood cells/mtDNA, which may inhibit the accumulation of genetically abnormal mtDNA that may play a role in immunosenescence. A similar explanation may also apply to the in vitro model of T cell ageing if the vast majority of the cells are replicating rather than entering senescence.

The term "immunosenescence" refers to an age-associated dysregulation of immune function which contributes to the increased susceptibility of the elderly to infectious disease. Although there are age-associated changes measurable in the innate immune system (Pawelec et al., 1998c), it is the adaptive, particularly T cell, system which is most susceptible to the deleterious effects of aging. In this minireview, characteristics of aging in long-term human T cell cultures will be summarized, and the parallels between the in vitro model and in vivo immunosenescence will be documented. The use of culture models to screen for ways of manipulating immunosenescence in vitro may provide a basis for intervention to ameliorate immunosenescence in vivo.