Search

• Study analyzes 1374 papers on sensitivity analysis in Scopus. • RStudio, CiteSpace, and VOSviewer are used. • China has most articles published; India leads in international cooperation. • Top three cited journals: J. Clean. Prod., Expert Syst. Appl., and Comput. Ind. Eng. • Most cited authors are Pamučar D, Kahraman C, and Zavadskas EK. In the present era, the implementation of scientifically grounded Multi-Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) has emerged as a pivotal solution to diverse decision-making challenges across various domains. Although a substantial body of exploratory, conceptual, and experimental studies exists, only 9.457% studies have incorporated sensitivity analyses to assess the robustness of MCDM methods. An exhaustive scientific exploration of sensitivity analysis within the scope of MCDM is thus lacking. This research aims to address this gap through Bibliometric Analysis while examining 1374 articles published between January 2000 and March 2023 from the Scopus database. Using RStudio (Biblioshiny), CiteSpace, and VOSviewer software, the study constructs a visual representation of the most prolific countries, institutions, and authors. Impressively, China takes the lead in article publications, while India excels in international collaboration. "An extended TODIM multi-criteria group decision-making method for green supplier selection in an interval type-2 fuzzy environment," featured in the Journal of Environmental Management, emerges as the most cited paper with a total citation of 455. The study also identifies the top three most cited journals, namely "Journal of Cleaner Production," "Expert Systems With Applications," and "Computers and Industrial Engineering." "North China Electric Power University" is the leading institute with the highest research outputs. "Pamučar D" is the most cited author, with 2594 citations and 39 articles, followed by "Kahraman C" and "Zavadskas EK. This study sheds light on trends in scientific developments and collaborations, providing a model for the application of sensitivity analysis in MCDM research and highlighting global trends. An understanding of the current state of sensitivity analysis research can assist researchers working in the entire domain of MCDM. Additionally, the visualization provides prescriptive data for future work and applications related to sensitivity analysis. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

• The centroid distance of PFNs is proposed and its properties are discussed. • Propose a score function based on the centroid distance and discuss its properties. • Applications of Pythagorean fuzzy clustering, ranking and MCDM are developed. • Some advantages of the proposed methods are showed through comparative analysis. By using Pythagorean fuzzy set (PFS), people can quantitatively describe and process information with fuzziness, and then make reasonable and effective judgments or decisions. In this process, distance measure often serves as a useful and important tool. The purpose of this paper is to explore some information processing methods and techniques in Pythagorean fuzzy environment. Firstly, the research progress of PFS is reviewed, and the main research directions and some hot issues in relevant research fields are discussed. Secondly, by analyzing the information of hesitation degree of Pythagorean fuzzy number (PFN), definitions of hesitation factor and centroid distance measure based on the representation of centroid coordinates of the hesitation regions are proposed, and properties of hesitation factor and centroid distance measure are discussed. Finally, the novel clustering algorithm, ranking method and multi criteria decision making (MCDM) method are developed in Pythagorean fuzzy environment, which are based on the new centroid distance measure. The effectiveness of the proposed algorithm and methods are verified through numerical examples and comparative analysis. The research results indicate that the centroid distance measure proposed in this paper can effectively characterize the distance between PFNs, thus making the clustering algorithm of PFNs, the ranking method of PFNs, and the Pythagorean fuzzy MCDM method have obvious superiorities and advantages. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The purpose of this paper is to propose a novel hybrid framework for evaluating and benchmarking trustworthy artificial intelligence (AI) applications in healthcare by using multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) techniques under a new fuzzy environment. To develop such a framework, a new decision matrix has been built, and then integrated with q-ROF2TL-FWZIC (q‐Rung Orthopair Fuzzy 2‐Tuple Linguistic Fuzzy-Weighted Zero-Inconsistency) and q-ROF2TL-CODAS (q‐Rung Orthopair Fuzzy 2‐Tuple Linguistic Combinative Distance-Based Assessment). In this integration, q-ROF2TL-FWZIC is utilized for assigning the weights of evaluation attributes of trustworthy AI, while q-ROF2TL-CODAS is employed for benchmarking trustworthy AI applications. Findings show that the q-ROF2TL-FWZIC method effectively weights the evaluation attributes. The transparency attribute receives the highest importance weight (0.173566825), whereas the human agency and oversight criterion has the lowest weight (0.105741901). The remaining attributes are distributed in between. Moreover, alternative_4 receives the highest rank order (score of 7.370410417), while alternative_13 receives the lowest rank order (score of −4.759794397). To evaluate the validity of the proposed framework, systematic ranking and sensitivity analysis assessments were employed. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

With the constant changes in the decision-making environment, various limitations have emerged in traditional decision-making methods, such as the inability to simultaneously consider multiple factors such as randomness, hesitation, and ambiguity, thus limiting a comprehensive grasp of the decision-maker's cognitive inputs. To address the above problems, we propose a multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) model based on a new fuzzy set (FS). Firstly, we define a new Z hesitant fuzzy linguistic term set (ZHFLTS) and propose a visualization metric for mapping ZHFLTS into T-spherical fuzzy (T-SF) space to simplify the computation. The relevant properties of ZHFLTS are further investigated. In order to accurately measure the uncertainty of FSs, we propose the probabilistic-hesitation-fuzzy (PHF) entropy and use it as a basis to derive the potential probability distribution using the fruit fly optimization algorithm (FOA). Subsequently, an MCDM model is established based on the proposed ZHFLTS, visualization metric, and PHF entropy. The model can better solve complex decision-making problems such as TCM through example studies and comparative analyses. The research in this paper aims to cope with today's increasingly complex decision-making environments, and the introduced ZHFLTS framework and the corresponding methodology provide new ways to solve complex decision problems. • ZHFLTS is defined and a mapping method to visualize ZHFLTS in T-SF space is studied. • PHF entropy is proposed based on FOA for obtaining potential probability distribution. • A Novel MCDM model based on ZHFLTS is presented. • It proves the effectiveness of the model through instances and comparative analysis. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) is a popular branch of decision theory in which many methods have been proposed to solve MCDM real-world problems. However, in spite of the multiple methods, it is common that different of them provide the same solutions. Therefore, this paper analyzes the causes of the same solutions from different MCDM methods, studies why different normalization methods can achieve the same solutions in MCDM methods through the theory of MCDM methods, and discusses the relationship between different MCDM methods by category. To achieve such goals, MCDM methods are classified into three categories according to their ranking methods. Some traditional MCDM methods are then extended by considering general normalization methods and distance measures. Finally, the characteristics of various MCDM methods are discussed by category and their evaluation indexes are also compared. The comparison results are represented by tables and flowchart models. The relationship between different categories of MCDM methods is shown through the comparison of the evaluation indexes. The aim of the proposed method is not to replace existing MCDM methods, but to fill some present research gaps about MCDM methods. • General normalization methods and distance measures are considered in MCDM methods. • The causes of the same solutions from different MCDM methods are examined. • The characteristics of various MCDM methods are discussed by category. • The relationship between different MCDM methods is summarized. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Fifth-generation (5G) technology provides new possibilities for a variety of applications, but it also comes with challenges influenced by distinct aspects, such as the size of organizations that use such technology. Therefore, it is important to understand which architecture of 5G-radio access networks (RANs) is best for a given purpose; this requires an evaluation platform for assessment. This paper tackles this problem by presenting a novel multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) solution based on a new integrated fuzzy set. The proposed integrated approach, which is based on a Type-2 neutrosophic fuzzy environment, is developed to address the application challenges of 5G-RANs architecture evaluation, as also to face the MCDM theoretical challenge represented by ambiguities and inconsistencies among decision makers within the decision making context of the presented case study. Many MCDM techniques for weighting and selection were presented from the literature, yet many of them still suffer from inconsistencies and uncertainty. Therefore, the chosen methods in this research are unique in a way that previous issues are addressed, making them suitable for integration with Type-2 neutrosophic fuzzy environment, and therefore creating a more robust decision platform for the presented challenge in this research, as a theoretical contribution. First, a new "Type-2 Neutrosophic Fuzzy-Weighted Zero-Inconsistency" (T2NN-FWZIC) technique is formulated for weighting the evaluation criteria of RAN architectures. Second, another new method, namely, "Type-2 Neutrosophic Fuzzy Decision by Opinion Score Method" (T2NN-FDOSM), was formulated to select the optimal RAN architecture using the obtained weights. The weighting results by T2NN-FWZIC for the (n = 25) evaluation criteria revealed that (C 21 latency and C 22 reliability) as the most important criteria, with 0.06 value for each as opposed to (C 15 Data Processing) as the lowest weighted criteria with 0.0186 value. As for T2NN-FDOSM, a total of four 5G-RAN architectures were evaluated, including "virtualized cloud RAN" coming as the optimal one, followed by "fog RAN," "cloud RAN," and finally "heterogeneous cloud RAN." The results were confirmed by carrying out a sensitivity analysis. The outcome of this study can be used to assist future 5G-RAN developments according to business needs and to establish an assessment platform for 5G technology in different domains and applications. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]