1. Broadening the evidence base of mental health policy and practice.
- Author
-
Brophy, Lisa and Savy, Pauline
- Subjects
EVALUATION research ,MEDICAL care ,POLICY sciences -- Methodology ,ATTITUDE (Psychology) ,MEDICAL personnel ,HEALTH policy ,MENTAL health personnel ,MENTAL health services ,PHILOSOPHY ,SERIAL publications ,UNCERTAINTY ,EVIDENCE-based medicine ,PROFESSIONAL practice - Abstract
This concluding paper draws together the dominant themes across the papers published in this issue. The majority of the papers clearly point to disparities between the aims of policy-makers and mental health workers. Using a variety of perspectives and methods, the authors of these insightful papers argue that modernist, rational approaches to structuring and evaluating services are at odds with the professional needs of mental health workers. At one level this critique is self-evident given the messiness and uncertainties inherent in working with service users whose individual problems require flexible approaches tailored from a broad and evolving practice-base. For some authors, the focus is epistemological and methodological; they offer much needed examples of analysing policy construction, interpreting statistics and the concurrent application of the widely used concepts of medicalisation and structural inequality. Together, the papers indicate that the progress of mental health reform in many western countries remains inconsistent and, in some cases, obstructive to effective professional practice. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2011
- Full Text
- View/download PDF