Search

Previous studies have shown that geostatistics-based transient hydraulic tomography (THT) is robust for subsurface heterogeneity characterization through the joint inverse modeling of multiple pumping tests. However, the hydraulic conductivity ( K ) and specific storage ( S s ) estimates can be smooth or even erroneous for areas where pumping/observation densities are low. This renders the imaging of interlayer and intralayer heterogeneity of highly contrasting materials including their unit boundaries difficult. In this study, we further test the performance of THT by utilizing existing and newly collected pumping test data of longer durations that showed drawdown responses in both aquifer and aquitard units at a field site underlain by a highly heterogeneous glaciofluvial deposit. The robust performance of the THT is highlighted through the comparison of different degrees of model parameterization including: (1) the effective parameter approach; (2) the geological zonation approach relying on borehole logs; and (3) the geostatistical inversion approach considering different prior information (with/without geological data). Results reveal that the simultaneous analysis of eight pumping tests with the geostatistical inverse model yields the best results in terms of model calibration and validation. We also find that the joint interpretation of long-term drawdown data from aquifer and aquitard units is necessary in mapping their full heterogeneous patterns including intralayer variabilities. Moreover, as geological data are included as prior information in the geostatistics-based THT analysis, the estimated K values increasingly reflect the vertical distribution patterns of permeameter-estimated K in both aquifer and aquitard units. Finally, the comparison of various THT approaches reveals that differences in the estimated K and S s tomograms result in significantly different transient drawdown predictions at observation ports. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Transient hydraulic tomography (THT) is a robust method of aquifer characterization to estimate the spatial distributions (or tomograms) of both hydraulic conductivity ( K ) and specific storage ( S s ). However, the highly-parameterized nature of the geostatistical inversion approach renders it computationally intensive for large-scale investigations. In addition, geostatistics-based THT may produce overly smooth tomograms when head data used to constrain the inversion is limited. Therefore, alternative model conceptualizations for THT need to be examined. To investigate this, we simultaneously calibrated different groundwater models with varying parameterizations and zonations using two cases of different pumping and monitoring data densities from a laboratory sandbox. Specifically, one effective parameter model, four geology-based zonation models with varying accuracy and resolution, and five geostatistical models with different prior information are calibrated. Model performance is quantitatively assessed by examining the calibration and validation results. Our study reveals that highly parameterized geostatistical models perform the best among the models compared, while the zonation model with excellent knowledge of stratigraphy also yields comparable results. When few pumping tests with sparse monitoring intervals are available, the incorporation of accurate or simplified geological information into geostatistical models reveals more details in heterogeneity and yields more robust validation results. However, results deteriorate when inaccurate geological information are incorporated. Finally, our study reveals that transient inversions are necessary to obtain reliable K and S s estimates for making accurate predictions of transient drawdown events. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

• HPT surveys at a site with K spanning nearly-seven orders of magnitude. • HPT reveals both sharp and gradual changes in K values across layer boundaries. • Integration of HPT-inverted K into HT yields better matches with permeameter K. • HPT K can help HT refine layer boundaries and capture intralayer K variability. Hydraulic profiling tool (HPT) and hydraulic tomography (HT) have been developed as promising techniques for the high-resolution characterization of surficial aquifer systems. HPT surveys can be rapidly conducted at a resolution of 1.5-cm, but provide only one-dimensional vertical profiles and require site-specific formulae to relate HPT measurements to K. Geostatistics-based HT can estimate three-dimensional distributions of hydraulic parameters, but may fail to provide detailed information and can be smooth when pumping/observation data density is sparse and usually are constrained to the area enclosed by the pumping and observation network. In this study, HPT and HT surveys were conducted at the North Campus Research Site (NCRS) in Waterloo, Ontario, Canada to characterize a glaciofluvial multi-aquifer-aquitard system with permeameter K values spanning nearly seven orders of magnitude. We first performed the geostatistical analysis of K values derived from 11 HPT surveys using the power-law model developed for the NCRS by Zhao and Illman (2022b). Then, the benefits of incorporating HPT K profiles into HT were evaluated for the reconstruction of hydraulic parameter fields. Results showed that the arithmetic mean of 11 HPT K profiles was nearly one order of magnitude higher than that of the 544 permeameter test K measurements. The K fields interpolated by ordinary kriging captured the vertical alternating layering patterns of aquifer and aquitard layers, while they over-predicted the values by nearly one order of magnitude than permeameter K for the top part of the aquifer system. By incorporating the kriged K values as prior means for the geostatistics-based HT, improvements were found in capturing spatial heterogeneity of K fields for areas both inside and outside the well cluster and in drawdown predictions than the inversion case using only pressure head data. The inclusion of vertical variation information of K derived from HPT into HT was also helpful in refining the vertical locations of estimated layer boundaries and introducing intralayer variation patterns of K for both aquifer and aquitard layers. This study demonstrates the potential ability of HT and HPT and advocates the joint use of both techniques for the characterization of subsurface heterogeneity at highly heterogeneous sites such as the NCRS. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Hydraulic tomography (HT) has been shown to map subsurface heterogeneity accurately through the joint interpretation of multiple pumping tests. Previous research has shown that smooth hydraulic conductivity ( K ) estimates are obtained beyond where pumping/observation data are available using the geostatistical inversion approach, when the inversion begins with a homogeneous K and when data densities are not high. However, geological data are typically available through outcrops and borehole logs to provide geological variability. Therefore, we investigate the usefulness of geological data for HT analysis at a highly heterogeneous field site by: (1) comparing calibrated geological models of two different resolutions to two homogeneous and four highly parameterized geostatistical inverse models, in terms of both model calibration and validation performances as well as correspondence of estimated K values with permeameter-estimated K profiles along boreholes; and (2) using geological models as prior information for the geostatistical inversion approach. Results reveal that the simultaneous calibration of geological models to seven pumping test data yields K values that correctly reflect the general patterns of vertical distributions of permeameter-estimated K . We also find that the geostatistical inversion approach using a geological model as prior information performs better for both model calibration and validation than using a homogenous K as a prior, and more importantly, improves the correspondence of K estimates to permeameter test results along wells, as well as in preserving geological features where drawdown measurements are lacking. Overall, our results suggest the joint use of both geological and pumping test data for HT analysis when accurate geological data are available. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

This paper investigates the importance of geological data in Hydraulic Tomography (HT) through sandbox experiments. In particular, four groundwater models with homogeneous geological units constructed with borehole data of varying accuracy are jointly calibrated with multiple pumping test data of two different pumping and observation densities. The results are compared to those from a geostatistical inverse model. Model calibration and validation performances are quantitatively assessed using drawdown scatterplots. We find that accurate and inaccurate geological models can be well calibrated, despite the estimated K values for the poor geological models being quite different from the actual values. Model validation results reveal that inaccurate geological models yield poor drawdown predictions, but using more calibration data improves its predictive capability. Moreover, model comparisons among a highly parameterized geostatistical and layer-based geological models show that, (1) as the number of pumping tests and monitoring locations are reduced, the performance gap between the approaches decreases, and (2) a simplified geological model with a fewer number of layers is more reliable than the one based on the wrong description of stratigraphy. Finally, using a geological model as prior information in geostatistical inverse models results in the preservation of geological features, especially in areas where drawdown data are not available. Overall, our sandbox results emphasize the importance of incorporating geological data in HT surveys when data from pumping tests is sparse. These findings have important implications for field applications of HT where well distances are large. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

• A calibrated perfect-geological model yields better flow and transport predictions. • With HT-inverted K fields, the ADE can reasonably simulate tracer plumes and BTCs. • Fusing geology into geostatistics-based HT reveals inter- and intra-layer K changes. • High-resolution K fields with geological features reproduce plume fingering vividly. Hydraulic tomography (HT) has been developed over the last two decades to image subsurface heterogeneity at high resolution that is critically important to robust solute transport predictions. In this study, HT based on two concepts (i.e., geological zonation and geostatistical inversion models) was utilized to characterize the K distribution of a laboratory sandbox aquifer at different parameter resolutions. We compared the estimated K fields for predicting independent pumping tests and solute transport using the classical advection–dispersion equation (ADE). The impact of using geological zonation models of varying accuracy for HT analyses was investigated. Results revealed that, when being calibrated to datasets from multiple pumping tests, geological zonation models that faithfully represented the true stratigraphy predicted groundwater flow satisfactorily. The deterministic K field of the calibrated reliable geological zonation models satisfactorily reproduced the preferential migration path of the observed tracer plume, and the breakthrough curves (BTCs) at sampling ports. With further resolving the inter- and intra-layer heterogeneity, the reconstructed K fields by HT better predicted both migrating plumes and BTCs for two conservative tracer tests. The estimated dispersivity values for ADE only resulted in slight improvements in the fitting between observed and simulated solute tracer data. It also demonstrated the need of integrating reliable geological information into the geostatistical inversion approach to reproduce geological structures in K fields. Our study suggested the proper consideration of geological zonation between boreholes during field implementation of HT to yield improved solute transport results. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

• Inverse modeling approach proposed to invert cm-scale K from HPT surveys. • Based on inverted K , a new power-law model was developed for HPT surveys at NCRS. • The site-specific model predicted K values that correspond well with permeameter K. • Integrating HPT-inverted K into SSHT better defined sharp boundaries of a K field. Direct-push based hydraulic profiling tool (HPT) and geostatistically-based hydraulic tomography (HT) are two promising techniques for the high-resolution estimation of hydraulic conductivity (K) for unconsolidated sediments. Although HPT surveys could be conducted rapidly, relating the 1.5-cm resolution injection logging profiles to K always involve the upscaling of centimeter-scale measurements to coarser intervals for the development of site-specific formulae. On the other hand, K fields reconstructed by HT could be smooth when pumping test data are sparse. In this study, an inverse modeling approach was firstly utilized to estimate K values directly from HPT survey data for the glaciofluvial deposits at the North Campus Research Site (NCRS) in Waterloo, Ontario, Canada. A site-specific power-law relationship was generated for the NCRS to relate HPT profiles to the vertical distributions of K. Then, the proposed inverse modeling approach was evaluated with a two-dimensional synthetic aquifer under controlled conditions, and the estimated K profiles from inverse analysis of synthetic HPT surveys were incorporated into the steady-state HT. Results of the field study showed that K estimates from the developed formula corresponded better with K values from permeameter tests, than those estimated from the empirical model of McCall and Christy (2010) for HPT surveys. Moreover, through synthetic experiments, we demonstrated that integration of K values inverted from HPT into steady-state HT analyses yielded K tomograms that were significantly better than the geostatistical inversion results relying on pumping test data alone. Overall, this study highlights the need in developing site-specific formulae for the HPT and the joint implementation of HPT and HT techniques for the more cost-effective high-resolution characterization of subsurface heterogeneity. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

• HPT pressure logs (P c) can be rapidly collected in unconsolidated deposits. • P c data provide information on sharp and gradually-varying layer boundaries. • Integrating HPT-derived hydrostratigraphy and HT yields a K field with sharp boundaries. • HPT K estimates require additional evaluations for highly heterogeneous deposits. Hydraulic tomography (HT) has been developed as a robust technique in characterizing subsurface heterogeneity over the last two decades. Hydraulic conductivity (K) and specific storage (S s) estimated by geostatistically-based HT inversion approaches are typically smooth and lack geological features when observation data density is sparse. Although integrating geological information can be helpful in adding structural features into parameter fields, costly efforts are required to obtain borehole logging through conventional coring and sampling. Also, identification of geological features such as layer boundaries from sampled materials can be a subjective process. In this study, corrected pressure (P c) logs collected during hydraulic profiling tool (HPT) surveys are utilized to derive the local hydrostratigraphic layers of the glaciofluvial deposit at the North Campus Research Site (NCRS) in Waterloo, Ontario, Canada. Site-specific geological models representing aquifer and aquitard layers are developed and calibrated to drawdown data of multiple pumping tests. Results show that estimated K fields correctly reflect the variation features of permeameter-estimated K profiles, as well as the spatial distribution of high and low K sediments. The calibrated geological models performed better than the geostatistically-based inversion approach in predicting independent pumping tests used for model validation. Moreover, by including K estimates of geological models as prior means, the estimated K fields reveal both intra- and interlayer heterogeneity, and the performances of drawdown prediction are further improved for the geostatistical inversion approach. Overall, our study suggests that, integration of stratigraphic information derived from HPT P c logs is useful for HT to capture the sharp boundaries in K fields, especially when the pumping test data is sparse. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

• THT analysis treating S s to be homogeneous yields less accurate results. • S s heterogeneity should be considered in THT for improved mapping of K and S s fields. • Reliable geological data helps THT to improve not only K , but also S s estimates. Over the last two decades, various studies on Transient Hydraulic Tomography (THT) have shown that it is an effective approach to characterize subsurface heterogeneity. Typically, high-resolution hydraulic conductivity (K) distributions were recovered, while the spatial variability of specific storage (S s) was found to be smooth. In some studies, S s heterogeneity has been intentionally ignored due to the belief that S s is less variable than K. Therefore, one may question the importance of considering S s heterogeneity during THT and its impact on the reliability of estimated hydraulic parameters. To investigate these issues, three modeling approaches (i.e., effective parameters, geological, and geostatistics-based) were used to obtain K and S s estimates of varying spatial resolutions. The reliability of K and S s estimates were evaluated by comparing their drawdown prediction performances. The values of using different prior K and S s information for THT analyses were investigated. Our results revealed that: (1) the K distribution estimated from the geostatistics-based steady-state HT analysis accurately predicted the late time drawdowns, while further improvements in transient drawdowns were obtained only after jointly treating the S s field as heterogeneous; (2) S s heterogeneity should be considered in addition to K for THT inversions, even when the estimated S s field is smooth; and (3) using K and S s estimates from the calibrated geological model as initial mean distributions for the geostatistical inversion approach were helpful in capturing both interlayer and intralayer heterogeneity of K and S s. These findings suggested that S s heterogeneity should be properly considered during the implementation of THT. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Summary: Environmental tracers CFCs, 18O, 2H and tritium were used to determine the natural groundwater recharge and the impact of irrigation activity on the groundwater system in the semi-arid Zhangye Basin of China. Groundwaters in the irrigated areas have been identified as mixtures containing fractions recharged in different periods of time. The CFC and 3H data show that the oldest fraction in the groundwater was recharged before 1950, whereas the younger fractions were recharged in different periods of time since 1950. Stable isotope (18O, 2H), CFC and electrical conductivity data show that most of the samples can be regarded as binary mixtures with the river/irrigation water presents the younger fraction and the regional groundwater presents the older fraction. Binary mixing model is used to estimate the age and fraction of the younger component. Most of the younger fraction was recharged after 1980s, in response to the increasing irrigation activities. Compared to local precipitation surface water plays a major role in recharging the aquifer in the irrigated area. The irrigation activity had more impact on the aquifer under thin unsaturated zone (<10m), due to short travel times and high amounts of recharge, whereas it had less impact on the aquifer under thick unsaturated zone (tens of meters). CFCs are useful in identifying regions of different impact of irrigation return flow. The positive correlation between nitrate and CFC data show that contaminants are transported to the saturated zone by irrigation water. This study shows that in this semi-arid basin due to strong evaporation of infiltrating surface water and regional groundwater, δ18O and EC values, in contrast to CFCs, do not show simple relationship with concentration in groundwater. Combined with a proper mixing model, however, they can provide evidences that the CFCs found in groundwater were introduced by infiltrating irrigation return flow and, therefore, reveal that human activities can produce a much localized water circulation and influence groundwater vulnerability. [Copyright &y& Elsevier]