1. Artifacts by marker enzyme adsorption on nanomaterials in cytotoxicity assays with tissue cultures
- Author
-
Alexander Böser, Sandra Vogel, Ben van Ravenzwaay, Laura-Carolin Hasenkamp, Robert Landsiedel, Bernhard von Vacano, Susanne N. Kolle, and Wendel Wohlleben
- Subjects
chemistry.chemical_classification ,History ,Materials science ,biology ,Protein Corona ,Computer Science Applications ,Education ,Nanomaterials ,chemistry.chemical_compound ,Enzyme ,Adsorption ,chemistry ,Biochemistry ,Lactate dehydrogenase ,biology.protein ,Bovine serum albumin ,Cytotoxicity ,Intracellular - Abstract
We used precision cut lung slices (PCLS) to study the cytotoxicity of cobalt ferrite nanomaterials with and without bovine serum albumin (BSA) stabilization. Using mitochondrial activity as an indicator of cytotoxicity (WST-1 assay) increasing concentrations of cobalt ferrite nanomaterial caused increasing levels of cytotoxicity in PCLS irrespective of BSA stabilization. However, there was no increase in released lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) levels caused by BSA stabilized nanomaterial indicating concentration depended cytotoxictiy. Moreover, non-stabilized nanomaterial caused a decrease of background LDH levels in the PCLS culture supernatant confirmed by complementary methods. Direct characterization of the protein corona of extracted nanomaterial shows that the LDH decrease is due to adsorption of LDH onto the surface of the non-stabilized nanomaterial, correlated with strong agglomeration. Preincubation with serum protein blocks the adsorption of LDH and stabilizes the nanomaterial at low agglomeration. We have thus demonstrated the cytotoxicity of nanomaterials in PCLS does not correlate with disrupted membrane integrity followed by LDH release. Furthermore, we found that intracellular enzymes such as the marker enzyme LDH are able to bind onto surfaces of nanomaterial and thereby adulterate the detection of toxic effects. A replacement of BSA by LDH or a secondary LDH-on-BSA-corona were not observed, confirming earlier indications that the protein corona exchange rate are slow or vanishing on inorganic nanomaterial. Thus, the method(s) to assess nanomaterial-mediated effects have to be carefully chosen based on the cellular effect and possible nano-specific artifacts.
- Published
- 2011
- Full Text
- View/download PDF