Search

In their paper, Bellwald et al. (2019) present a frequency curve of mass movements from a total of 22 fjords and 6 lakes in west and mid-Norway. However, the time-series analysis that is used to create this frequency curve is somewhat flawed, as mass-transport deposits (MTDs) receive a weight that is positively correlated to their age uncertainty, instead of an equal weight. Here, I propose an alternative frequency curve in which the weight of each MTD is equal, independent of its age uncertainty. I conclude that this error in the frequency curve does not significantly impact the interpretations made by the authors, but that similar errors may lead to wrong interpretations when such a frequency curve would be used in a quantitative manner.

The flux of low-salinity Pacific Water (PW) through Bering Strait (BS) weights on the freshwater budget of the Arctic Ocean, which, in turn, impacts the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC). Through time, this PW flux has been tightly controlled by the bathymetry of the Strait (~ 50 m water depth at present), thus by sea-level (SL) changes and documented in several papers based on a large array of sedimentological and geochemical tracers. The present study aimed at reassessing the robustness of these tracers of the PW-flux, based on five surface samples collected along a south-north transect from BS to Chukchi Plateau, within the bathymetric range of the PW-mass dispersal. We also estimated their variation in relation to the post-glacial SL-rise in a sedimentary core (ARC4-R09), from the Chukchi shelf, spanning the last ~10 kyr. Potential indicators of PW-flux include sortable silt, clay minerals, and the particulate and exchangeable Nd-isotope composition of specific grain-size fractions. The results indicate that ɛNd-values in leachates, and to a lesser extent, the smectite abundance, both relating to volcanic rocks of the Bering Sea, are sensitive indicators of the PW-flux, whereas sortable silts and other clay minerals relative abundances are also influenced by other processes (e.g., west-east shelf currents, sea-ice rafting). The modern distributions of ɛNd-value and smectite abundance illustrate mixing between two endmembers: i) a northern Bering Sea endmember, characterized by ~14% of smectite (vs all clay minerals) and a ɛNd-value of the exchangeable fraction of ~ −2; ii) a Chukchi Sea endmember, characterized by ~8% of smectite and a ɛNd-value ranging from −7 to −8. The Holocene sedimentary record from the study core indicates a progressive increase in Bering Sea supplies through time, linked to an enhanced inflow of PW, which we associate with the deepening of the Strait due to the rising SL. Following a major reorganization of the Arctic Ocean circulation at ~8 ka BP, a steady increase in PW flux prevailed until ~4 cal. kyr BP. A tenuous but continuous positive trend towards modern eNd values followed during the late Holocene. The middle Holocene steep increase of warm, low salinity PW-flux through BS, led to important changes in the Arctic Ocean, in particular of its salinity budget. Assuming that the BS bathymetry is the main parameter governing the PW-flux towards the Arctic Ocean, a first-order estimate of PW-flux under a higher than modern SL can be made using the SL-elevation-ɛNd relationship of the major middle Holocene shift.

Refined records of Holocene sea level and coastal evolution are needed to forecast changes in the Anthropocene. Beach ridge strandplains and other prograded barriers preserve an exceptional (and relatively untapped) archive of past sea level within their stratigraphy. Extracting these records using high-resolution geophysics can unearth sea-level indicators with the potential to resolve small fluctuations over large spatial- and temporal-scales. Brooke et al. (2019) construct a sea-level curve from Cowley strandplain and performs interesting modelling/analyses; but does so based on the beach ridge topography. Unfortunately, this methodological approach contradicts a long-held understanding that it is not appropriate to use ridge morphology or sediment analysis from cores/augers/pits to indicate sea level. This sets a misleading precedent if perpetuated in future research and does so at a critical time when extracting sea-level reconstructions from prograded barriers is becoming more established. While the Brooke et al. (2019) curve appears to correlate with data from this region, it is not precisely clear how it was constructed. Particularly perplexing is the most recent half of the curve, starting with the peculiar location of the modern analogue below mean sea level. Simply adjusting the existing curve to zero on the y-axis removes it from the tenuous correlation. This comment paper uses the geophysical and topographic data published in Brooke et al. (2019), as well as the protocol referenced, to construct relative sea-level curves. The results accentuate the difference between the reconstructions from the berm stratigraphy and the ridge morphology. Furthermore, despite the cursory nature of this analysis and the complexity of this barrier's stratigraphy, the berm heights demonstrate remarkable correlation with the modelled sea-level curve for the region as well as the more traditional sea-level indicators. Ultimately, this glimpse provides insight on the possible extent of information that lies buried not just at Cowley and the ~30 prograded barriers around Australia, but at 300+ sites worldwide.

This paper proposes a biostratigraphic framework for the last 50 kyr in the contourite depositional system (CDS) of the Gulf of Cadiz with a solid and independent age control, and tests the reliability of faunal-based analyses in a bottom current-dominated environment related to high current velocities. The distribution of planktonic foraminifera and pteropods has been studied in twenty-two piston cores of the Holocene and Late Pleistocene age from the Gulf of Cadiz. A detailed correlation between the cores has been made possible by a large radiocarbon and isotopic data set and a high degree of similarity of frequency changes within several species by coiling direction changes of Globorotalia truncatulinoides and Globorotalia hirsuta and by occurrences of the polar species Neogloboquadrina pachyderma and Limacina retroversa. Occurrences of these polar species are clearly related to paleoclimatic oscillations and reflect rapidly changing surface water conditions in the Gulf of Cadiz during the latest Pleistocene that have been observed regardless of sedimentation rates and sedimentary environments (contouritic drifts vs slope without bottom current influence).

This paper presents the geological and morphological evolution of the prograded Cassino barrier during the middle and late Holocene. A special focus is given on the presentation and discussion of records of environmental changes that occurred during barrier progradation. The results demonstrated that variable rates of progradation were produced by environmental changes that affected the coastal sediment budget, such as changes in the wave climate. The total progradation of 18 km recorded for the Cassino barrier is probably the highest extension of progradation registered for a ridge plain associated with a coastal barrier. Sea-level changes during barrier progradation were accessed by the high difference between the degree of compaction of the foredune and backshore/foreshore deposits detected by the drilling system applied in this study and were confirmed by the limit of those deposits, which were also revealed by GPR records. During most of the time of barrier progradation, an overall sea-level fall of approximately 2 ± 1 m occurred. Six sets of relict foredune ridges were identified, and the limits between them were well marked by ridge truncations and the formation of transgressive dune sheets (TDS). Optically stimulated luminescence ages show that the TDS were formed under the driest climate conditions, with age periods very close to 3.8, 3.5, 1.9, 1.5, 0.22 and 0.09 ka ago, interspersed with ages of known wetter conditions in southern Brazil. The modern phases of TDS formation, with ages varying from 0.25 to 0.22 ka ago, were coincident with the time period of the younger pulse of the Little Ice Age (LIA), which was characterized by arid and cold conditions in southern South America. A comparison with prograded barriers located 350 to 600 km to the north suggests the existence of teleconnections, with phases of TDS and parabolic dunes that formed with a time interval of approximately 405 to 583 years.

International audience; Beachrocks represent a significant paleo-environmental proxy because they can record both the vertical and the horizontal evolution of the shoreline. They have often been used to assess Holocene shoreline evolution and crustally induced Relative Sea-Level (RSL) changes in the Mediterranean Sea. In this paper, we used submerged beachrocks from Paros and Naxos Islands (Aegean Sea, Greece) to reconstruct the shoreline modification and provide new insights on the RSL evolution in central Cyclades. Paros and Naxos Islands are of great importance in terms of archaeological evidence of coastal occupation. However, the evolution of their coastlines was seldom explored. In this study, we coupled detailed underwater surveys, analysis of aerial photogrammetry, microstratigraphic analysis and luminescence dating to study beachrock outcrops found down to about 6 m below the present sea-level. We, then, spatially and chronologically constrained some major palaeogeographical changes of a number of coastal sectors of the two islands. Furthermore, the multiple analyses of beachrocks, sediment coring and archaeological data suggested that RSL rose by at least 3.8 m in the last 4.0 ka and that RSL variation in the last 2.0 ka did not exceed 2 m with respect to the present mean sea level.

Prograded barriers are depositional coastal landforms which preserve past shoreline locations and have been studied in order to understand the fundamental drivers of barrier formation. This paper reconstructs the Holocene history of the Seven Mile Beach, prograded barrier in Tasmania, Australia using optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) dating, ground penetrating radar (GPR), light detection and ranging (LiDAR) elevation models and sedimentological analyses. Shoreline progradation of the barrier commenced around 7300 years ago and continued to near present despite a ~ 3000 pause in deposition between 6700 and 3600 years ago indicative of substantial changes in sediment availability. GPR imaged subsurface structures contain a record of seaward dipping reflectors preserved as sediment supplied beaches and dunes leading to shoreline progradation. In the past 500 years a large transgressive dune has formed, built from reworked barrier sands, and now dominates the eastern portion of the barrier implying that shoreline progradation has ceased. This study reaffirms the notion that relict foredune ridges are strongly aligned with modal wave refraction patterns in planform and emphasises the importance of sediment delivery as a key driver of shoreline progradation through beachface and dune accretion. The substantial pause in shoreline progradation on this barrier system, as observed on others around the world, requires further explanation. Although changes in sediment delivery have been inferred, it may also be appropriate to reopen the debate on Holocene sea-level change in Tasmania.

The Eastern Mediterranean Transient (EMT) represents a recent (early 1990s to today) water circulation phenomenon, during which more arid climatic conditions in the Mediterranean lead to the production of very dense, surface water masses in the north Aegean Sea. The produced north Aegean dense water (NADW) sinks to seafloor, flows to the south Aegean Sea and, then, spills into the Eastern Mediterranean Sea through the Cretan Straits, contributing to the rejuvenation of the bottom water. A large dataset of vintage high-resolution seismic-reflection profiles indicates that the floors of the basins in the southwest Aegean Sea are characterised by late Quaternary erosional gullies, abraded surfaces, and channel-related sediment drifts. Such structures provide evidence for the presence of strong bottom currents, which originate from the southward propagation of NADW masses. The basins have depths of 300 m to 1000 m and are connected to each other by narrow (a few km) straits and sills. The dominance of abraded surfaces and erosional gullies on the northern flank of the basins and in the narrow straits/sills between them provides evidence that the southward propagation of the NADW occurs by the filling and flooding of each basin by dense water, which then spills and cascades into the next basin southward. Seismic stratigraphy suggests that the formation of the drifts started at marine isotope stage (MIS) 11 (420 ka BP). The coincidence of at least three erosional surfaces within the sediment drifts with interglacial MIS 11, 5, and 1, respectively, suggests that bottom currents were mostly active during high sea-level stands and sluggish during glacial low sea-level stands. A 90–100 m drop of the sea level below the current level would have resulted in the emergence of the eastern Cyclades Plateau and, thus, in the disconnection of the southwest Aegean Sea from the north Aegean Sea. Several (0.05–0.5 m thick) beds of gravelly sand with algal and mollusc debris, laminated to mottled sand, and mottled mud are observed in the sediment cores analysed in this paper; these beds can be confidently correlated from core to core, and are interpreted as bottom-current deposits. The separation of these beds by hemipelagic sediments indicates that bottom-current activity in the southwest Aegean is not permanently established but episodic. Six episodes of intense bottom-current activity are recorded in the MIS 2–4 (10–80 ka) sediments and they appear to correlate well with the cold and dry Younger Dryas and Heinrich 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7 events. In contrast, at least three episodes of intense bottom-current activity are recorded in the cores during the Holocene. The higher frequency of strong bottom-current episodes in the southwest Aegean Sea during the Holocene is attributed to the higher sea-level stand that makes the circulation of water masses in the Aegean Sea more sensitive to climatic changes.

This paper investigates the interplay between allocyclic controls and antecedent topography in the evolution of submerged coastal landforms, including a back-stepped delta. Using high-resolution tools, we examine the wave-dominated Thukela shelf, and define the major seismic units. Key features identified comprise incised valleys scoured into bedrock, that have overspilled to form lagoons at depths of 50 m. These are in turn overlain by two prograding and backstepped sandy delta systems at 40 m and 32 m depth respectively. The deltas interfinger with muddy prodelta deposits and are truncated by the Holocene ravinement, overlain by the contemporary prodelta of the Thukela River system. A bedrock high separates two physically separate strato-morphological zones; landward a sediment stripped, steep and shallow nearshore zone, and seaward a gentle zone downdip where the deltaic accumulations are sited. Delta development was favoured during sea-level stillstands at −40 m and −32 m respectively. The step-back of the deltas corresponds to sharp increases in the rate of sea-level rise associated with meltwater pulses. The overall gentle palaeo-bathymetric gradient has moderated erosion associated with rising sea level, preserving a sandy back-stepping delta and a draping mud clinoform. Submerged delta positioning relates to underlying incised valleys, suggesting a synchronous transgressive evolution of the drainage and the delta. Incised valley network positioning is further governed by Late Pliocene aged growth-faults in the basement rocks. The geological framework has acted as a recurring primary control to the geomorphic evolution of the area, partitioning accommodation for sediment accumulation and moderating the efficiency of ravinement.

Collectively, the modern Ayeyarwady (Irrawaddy) and Thanlwin (Salween) rivers deliver >600 Mt/yr of sediment to the sea. To understand the fate of Ayeyarwady and Thanlwin river-derived sediments to the sea, we conducted a 14-day geophysical and geological survey in the northern Andaman Sea and eastern Bay of Bengal in December 2017. Overall, ~1500-km of high-resolution Chirp-sonar profiles and 30 sediment cores from the shelf were acquired. This paper presents the results of the processed high-resolution profiles together with sediment analyses. Our findings indicate: 1) There is little modern sediment accumulating on the shelf immediately off the Ayeyarwady River mouths. In contrast, a major mud wedge with a distal depocenter, up to 60 m in thickness, has been deposited seaward in the Gulf of Martaban, extending to ~130 m water depth into the Martaban Depression. Further, 2) There is no evidence showing that modern sediment has accumulated or is transported into the Martaban Canyon; 3) There is a mud drape/blanket wrapping around the narrow western Myanmar Shelf in the eastern Bay of Bengal. The thickness of the mud deposit is up to 20 m nearshore and gradually thins to the slope at −300 m water depth, and likely escapes into the deep Andaman Trench; 4) The estimated total amount of Holocene sediments deposited offshore is ~1290 × 109 tons. If we assume this has mainly accumulated since the middle Holocene highstand (~6000 yr BP) like other major deltas, the historical annual mean depositional flux on the shelf would be 215 Mt/yr, which is equivalent to ~35% of the modern Ayeyarwady-Thanlwin rivers derived sediments; 5) Unlike other large river systems in Asia, such as the Yangtze and Mekong, this study indicates a bi-directional transport and depositional pattern controlled by the local currents that are influenced by tides, and seasonally varying monsoons winds and waves. Organic carbon biomarkers and isotope compositions show a gradual changing pattern with the along-shelf transport from the river to the Gulf of Martaban in the east and to the Bay of Bengal in the west.

The link between tropical cyclone (TC) activity in the South China Sea (SCS) and global climate change is commonly debated and there is a clear need for long-term geological records of TC activity if we are to clarify this connection. Multi-millennial, high-resolution paleo-storm records from the SCS are rare in the region and this causes difficulties for those exploring potential climate drivers of TC variability over centennial to millennial timescales and reduces our ability to fully assess the risks associated with future TC activity. This paper presents an age-constrained, mud-dominated sedimentary sequence from a coastal lagoon on Hainan Island, China. Multiproxy analyses incorporating chronological, lithological, sedimentological, and geochemical evidence were used to infer storm deposits preserved within the sequence and to reconstruct a time series of storm activity in the SCS during the mid-to-late Holocene. This long sedimentary record shows that TCs were highly active over the periods 5500 to 3500 and 1700 to 0 cal yrs. BP, and these periods contrast with a relatively quiet period 3500–1700 cal yrs. BP. An apparent inverse correlation between TC reconstructions from the SCS and those from the Korean Peninsula and Japan implies an oscillating pattern across the SCS and western North Pacific (WNP) over centennial to millennial timescales. A comparison between the sedimentary and paleoclimatic records implies that the El Nino–Southern Oscillation was not the only mechanism responsible for typhoon variability over the past 7500 cal yrs. BP, suggesting that other factors such as the thermal state of the western Pacific warm pool likely also had a strong influence on both SCS and WNP TC variability.