Search

The functions of 17β-estradiol (E2) are mediated by estrogen receptor (ER) α and β. ERs display similar DNA- and ligand-binding properties in vitro. However, ERβ shows lower transcriptional activity than ERα from the estrogen response element (ERE)-dependent signaling. We predicted that distinct amino termini contribute to differences in transcription efficacies of ERs by affecting in situ ER-ERE interactions. We used chromatin immunoprecipitation and a novel in situ ERE competition assay, which is based on the ability of ER to compete for ERE binding with a designer activator that constitutively induces transcription from an ERE-driven reporter construct. Interference of activator-mediated transcription by unliganded or liganded ERs was taken as an indication of ER-ERE interaction. Results revealed that ERs interacted with ERE similarly in the absence of E2. However, E2 enhanced the ERE binding of ERα but not that of ERβ. The removal of the amino terminus increased the ERβ-ERE interaction independent of E2. The ERβ amino terminus also prevented E2-mediated enhancement of the chimeric ERα-ERE interaction. Thus, the amino terminus of ERβ impairs the binding of ERβ to ERE. The abrogation of ligand-dependent activation function 2 of the amino-terminally truncated ERβ resulted in the manifestation of E2 effect on ERβ-ERE interaction. This implies that E2-mediated enhancement of ERβ-ERE interaction is masked by the activation function 2, whereas the intact amino terminus is a dominant region that decreases the binding of ERβ to ERE. Thus, ERβ-ERE interaction is independent of E2 and is impaired by its amino terminus. These findings provide an additional explanation for differences between ERα and ERβ functions that could differentially affect the physiology and pathophysiology of E2 signaling.

Estrogen receptors (ER) alpha and beta are members of a superfamily of nuclear receptors and mediate estrogen [17beta-estradiol (E2)] signaling. ERbeta has considerably less transcription potency than ERalpha in heterologous expression systems that use E2 response elements (ERE) in tandem as the trans-acting unit. We show here that despite similar intracellular characteristics, ERbeta, in contrast to ERalpha, fails to induce gene transcription synergistically in response to E2 from tandem EREs. Moreover, our results indicate that ERalpha-specific partial agonistic activity of antagonists occurs additively. Although synergy contributes, it is not sufficient for differences in the transcription potencies between the ER subtypes. We demonstrate here that differences in the abilities of ERs to integrate activation functions through functional interactions between amino and carboxyl termini are critical for the transcriptional strength of ER subtypes.

Estrogen-inducible genes contain an enhancer called the estrogen response element (ERE), a double-stranded inverted repeat. The estrogen receptor (ER) is generally thought to bind to the double-stranded ERE. However, some reports provide evidence that an ER homodimer can bind a single strand of the ERE and suggest that single-stranded ERE binding is the preferred binding mode for ER. Since these two models describe quite different mechanisms of receptor action, we have attempted to reconcile the observations. Analyzing DNA structure by nuclease sensitivity, we found that two identical molecules of a single strand of DNA containing the ERE sequence can partially anneal in an antiparallel manner. Bimolecular annealing produces double-stranded inverted repeats, with adjacent unannealed tails. The amount of annealing correlates exactly with the ability of ER to bind bimolecular EREs. Either strand of an ERE could anneal to itself in a way that would bind ER. We conclude that ER binds only the annealed double-stranded ERE both in vitro and in vivo.

Reproducible, rapid measurement of estrogen receptor (ER) binding to DNA was accomplished in microtiter wells treated so that ER-DNA complexes or DNA bound in preference to free ER. Mixtures of 35S-labeled DNA and [3H]estrogen-charged ER ([3H]ER), incubated to equilibrium in microfuge tubes, were transferred to microtiter wells previously treated with histone followed by gelatin. After binding of the DNA or ER-DNA complex to the treated wells, free ER was removed by washing. Radioactivity retained in each well was measured by placing individual wells from snap-apart microtiter plates directly in scintillation fluid. Binding of DNA was saturable, and ER-DNA complex binding was complete within 2 h at 4 C. The use of 35S-labeled DNA and [3H]ER allowed stoichiometric determination of ER bound to DNA. The amount of ER specifically bound to a consensus estrogen-responsive element (ERE) containing the inverted repeat GGTCAgagTGACC was determined by comparing ER bound to plasmid containing or lacking the ERE. At saturating concentrations of ER, plasmids bearing one, two, and four EREs in tandem bound approximately one, two, and four dimeric ER molecules, respectively. Scatchard analysis of saturation binding data revealed a Kd of 0.15 nM for specific ER binding to a single ERE site. Thus, the assay detects ER retaining both DNA-binding and estrogen-binding functions. ER complexed with DNA in the well was also detected using a monoclonal antibody specific for the receptor. Simple modifications of this method would allow study of other DNA-protein interactions.