Search

We conducted reactor performance calculations to assess the potential design basis accident performance of HTGR fuel designs. Three Fully Ceramic Microencapsulated (FCM) fueled HTGR designs were developed in a previous work (Lu et al., 2018). The maximum fuel temperature in the cores fueled by these three FCM fuels was predicted to be higher than that in the reference 350-MWt mHTGR core in both normal operating conditions and during representative design basis accidents (Lu and Brown, 2019). To better understand the potential safety margins in mHTGR design basis accidents, we performed thermal-hydraulics sensitivity studies to investigate how maximum fuel temperature varies considering various parameters, e.g. thermal properties, within the ranges corresponding to the differences between the FCM-fueled prismatic mHTGR cores and the reference core with conventional fuel compacts. We found that the difference in the steady-state axial power distribution contributed the most to the difference in the maximum fuel temperature, in both normal operation and design basis accidents. Experimental data suggested that the annealing process of irradiation defects in SiC would be rapid at mHTGR relevant fuel temperatures. The bounding potential impact of the SiC annealing on the maximum fuel temperature was analyzed considering both the thermal conductivity recovery and the Wigner energy release due to the annealing of SiC. We found that the defect annealing process in SiC would at most increase the peak maximum fuel temperature of an FCM-fueled core by 40 K in loss of forced cooling accidents and by 10 K in a control rod withdrawal accident. Additional experiments on the SiC defect annealing kinetics and Wigner energy release in more relevant conditions are needed.

Surface wettability analysis, including measurements of static (θ) advance (θ A ), and receding (θ r ) contact angles, and surface roughness, Ra, are effective parameters used in the literature to predict changes in the pool boiling Critical Heat Flux (CHF). The CHF is an important aspect of the thermal hydraulic performance that needs to be investigated for new Accident Tolerant Fuel (ATF) cladding materials, such as iron-chromium-aluminum alloys (FeCrAl). Surface wettability of FeCrAl samples oxidized under different simulated Light Water Reactor (LWR) water chemistry conditions was measured. These measurements were compared to as-machined and oxidized Zircaloy-4 (Zirc-4), the reference cladding material in LWRs, under the same conditions. Theoretical models were used to predict the pool boiling CHF using surface wettability measurements. Pool boiling experiments were conducted using the same samples to measure the CHF. The measured and predicted CHF data were compared for model validation. The obtained results showed no significant difference in the measured static contact angle and hence the predicted CHF between the as-machined samples of FeCrAl, 310 SS, and Zirc-4. The contact angles (static, advance, and receding angles) for corroded FeCrAl samples under different LWR water chemistry conditions are lower, and the measured surface roughness values are higher than Zirc-4 corroded under the same conditions. Existing models in the literature predicted higher pool boiling CHF of corroded FeCrAl compared to 310 stainless steel (SS), and Zirc-4. The measured pool boiling CHF for oxidized FeCrAl samples was higher than Zirc-4 samples. The measured and predicted CHF values are in good agreement. The CHF and the Departure from Nucleate Boiling Ratio (DNBR) were calculated using the Consortium for Advanced Simulation of Light Water Reactors (CASL) subchannel code COBRA-TF (CTF) for a one-eighth model of a 17 × 17 Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR) fuel assembly. The inlet conditions are consistent with typical PWR values except for the power, which was set 50% higher than is typical to represent possible accident conditions more accurately. The calculated distributions for the CHF and DNBR for oxidized FeCrAl showed significantly higher values throughout the fuel assembly octant compared to as machined Zirc-4 and as machined FeCrAl. These preliminary results show that oxidized FeCrAl may be able to withstand the proposed accident conditions without leading to a boiling crisis.

Fully ceramic microencapsulated (FCM) fuel is a proposed fuel type for improved accident performance in LWRs (Light Water Reactors) that involves TRISO (TRistructural-ISOtropic) particles embedded in a nano-powder sintered silicon carbide (SiC) matrix. The TRISO particles contain a spherical fuel kernel ranging from 500 to 800 µm in diameter. The kernel and buffer layer are then coated with three layers, each of which is 30–40 µm thick, composed of dense inner pyrolytic carbon (IPyC), chemically vapor deposited silicon carbide (SiC) layer, and an outer pyrolytic carbon (OPyC) layer. These TRISO particles are then embedded in a fully dense sintered SiC matrix with an expected particle packing fraction of about 35–40% by volume. As is the case for gas reactor applications, the release of radioactivity into the coolant is dependent on the integrity of the silicon carbide layer of the TRISO particles, in addition to the SiC matrix. In this work, we report on fuel performance modeling of TRISO-bearing FCM fuel using the BISON code to simulate the thermo-mechanical behavior of this fuel in a prototypic LWR environment. This paper considers the effects of embedding a TRISO particle in the SiC pellet matrix and includes a discussion of the irradiation-induced dimensional change in the pyrolytic carbon (PyC) layers of the TRISO particle. Additionally, methods were developed to simulate a FCM pellet containing a large number of discrete and independent particles. Future work will report on developing an interface debonding model, a fracture model, and a radionuclide transport model.

Alternative cladding materials have been proposed to replace the currently used zirconium (Zr)-based alloys, in order to improve the accident tolerance of light water reactor (LWR) fuel. Of these materials, there is a particular focus on iron-chromium-aluminum (FeCrAl) alloys that exhibit much slower oxidation kinetics in high-temperature steam than Zr-alloys. This behavior should decrease the energy release due to oxidation and allow the cladding to remain integral longer in the presence of high temperature steam, making accident mitigation more likely. Within the development of these alloys, suitability for normal operation must also be demonstrated. This article is focused on modeling the integral thermo-mechanical performance of FeCrAl clad UO 2 fuel during normal reactor operation. Finite element analysis has been performed to assess commercially available FeCrAl alloys (namely Alkrothal 720 and APMT) as a candidate fuel cladding replacement for Zr-alloys, using the MOOSE-based fuel performance code BISON. These simulations identify the effects of the mechanical-stress and irradiation responses of FeCrAl and provide a comparison with Zr-alloys. In comparing these cladding materials, fuel rods have been simulated for normal reactor operation and simple steady-state operation. Normal reactor operating conditions target the cladding performance over the rod lifetime (∼4 cycles) for the highest-power rod in the highest-power fuel assembly under reactor power maneuvering. These power histories and axial temperature profiles input into BISON were generated from a neutronics study on full-core reactivity equivalence for FeCrAl using the 3D full core simulator NESTLE. The fuel rod designs and operating conditions used here are based on the Peach Bottom BWR with representative GE-12/14 fuel geometries, and design consideration was given to minimize the neutronic penalty of the FeCrAl cladding by changing fuel enrichment and cladding thickness. Individual sensitivity analyses of the fuel and cladding creep responses were also performed, which indicated the influence of compliance for each material, separately, on the stress state of the fuel cladding. These parametric analyses are performed using steady-state operating conditions such as a simple axial power profile, a constant cladding surface temperature, and a constant fuel power history.

The present work aims to provide a complete engineering solution, an appropriate experimental database, and a brief physical background on designing a miniature specimen geometry suitable for irradiation in materials test reactors such as the High Flux Isotope Reactor and post-irradiation out-of-hot cell testing. The physical limits of specimen miniaturization and a background of the scale factor effect are discussed, and principal limitations are defined. The advantages of modern test methods like digital image correlation, as well as some limitations connected to small specimen size, are analyzed. A sub-sized specimen geometry, “SS-Mini,” is designed; the geometry employs existing irradiation capsules leading to the reduced cost of any irradiation campaign. The new geometry performance is evaluated using a commercial 304 L stainless steel, an aluminum alloy including advanced 3D-printed material, a high nickel 718-alloy, tungsten, and an advanced fuel cladding FeCrAl alloy. Mechanical tests are conducted to compare the engineering mechanical properties (yield and ultimate tensile stress, uniform and total elongation values) and plastic behavior of the proposed miniature specimen with common specimen types for irradiation testing.

Increasing the fuel burnup limit in light water reactors is sought to enhance fuel cycle economics and requires establishing a technical basis. Experimental observations of severe fuel fragmentation under loss-of-coolant-accident conditions at Halden and Studsvik had raised the need for additional considerations during the development of this technical basis. These test data suggested that the burnup threshold for high burnup fuel fragmentation may be influenced by pre-transient power. Additional loss-of-coolant-accident test data is therefore valuable to complement these tests and enhance the current state of understating. Oak Ridge National Lab has developed the Severe Accident Test Station capable of examining the oxidation kinetics and accident response of irradiated fuel and cladding materials for design basis accident and beyond design basis accident scenarios. Severe Accident Test Station provides various temperature profiles, steam, and the thermal shock conditions necessary for integral loss of coolant accident testing, defueled oxidation quench testing, and high-temperature beyond design basis accident testing. Severe Accident Test Station has been successfully installed and demonstrated in the Irradiated Fuels Examination Laboratory at Oak Ridge National Lab. Furthermore, descriptions of the in-cell re-fabrication capabilities and assembly of the loss-of-coolant-accident test train are provided. Installation of the Severe Accident Test Station system and in-cell re-fabrication restores United States capability to examine postulated and extended loss-of-coolant-accident conditions on spent fuel and cladding and provides a platform for evaluating advanced fuel and accident-tolerant fuel cladding concepts. Lastly, three in-cell integral loss-of-coolant-accident test were performed in the Severe Accident Test Station and compared to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission sponsored loss-of-coolant-accident test as well as the original loss-of-coolant-accident test performed at Argonne National Lab. The results of these tests as well as all publicly available integral loss-of-coolant-accident test were used to validate a threshold for high burnup fuel fragmentation.

In the nuclear industry, a manufacturing-informed design approach has the potential to yield the most benefit from advanced manufacturing. By leveraging advanced materials, data science, and rapid testing and deployment, manufacturing-informed design can drive down costs and development times, ultimately improving future commercial viability. This approach is being demonstrated in the US Department of Energy Office of Nuclear Energy (DOE-NE) Transformational Challenge Reactor (TCR) program. Preconceptual design activities for TCR have been focused on analyzing and maturing four reactor core design concepts: two fast-spectrum and two thermal-spectrum systems. The designs were iteratively modified and analyzed, and subcomponents were manufactured in parallel over weeks instead of months or years. To meet key program initiatives (e.g., timeline and material use), several constraints—including fissile material availability, component availability, materials compatibility, and additive manufacturing capabilities—were factored into the design effort, yielding small cores less than one cubic meter in volume with near-term viability. The TCR program has made significant progress on development of advanced moderator materials such as yttrium hydride, advancing the feasibility of gas-cooled thermal spectrum systems using less than 250 kg of high-assay low enriched uranium (HALEU) and occupying less than 1 m3. Each of the two resulting thermal designs uses a different fuel form: traditional UO2 ceramic fuel and tristructural isotropic (advanced TRISO) fuel particles embedded inside a SiC matrix. Core neutronics and thermal performance for these systems were assessed and summarized. Evaluation of the performance metrics for these two moderated designs has yielded the downselected TCR design: a TRISO-fueled and yttrium hydride moderated gas-cooled reactor.

For economic reasons, the US nuclear industry is renewing efforts to build a technical basis to extend rod average burnup limits above the current regulatory burnup limit of 62 GWd/MTU. The primary driver is to increase pressurized water reactor cycle lengths to 24 months, reducing the number of fresh fuel assemblies and core design constraints, thereby making core energy utilization more efficient. However, fuel pellet fragmentation and pulverization, termed high burnup fuel fragmentation (HBFF), has been observed in the high burnup (>90 GWd/MTU) Halden loss-of-coolant-accident (LOCA) integral test series. The issue gained attention when fuel fragmentation and pulverization were also observed closer to the current US regulatory limit during the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) sponsored out-of-core integral test at Studsvik Nuclear in early 2011. This led to NRC concerns with potential changes to fuel and core designs relative to fuel pellet pulverization. In a letter to the NRC Commissioners, the staff specifically identified a need to “…define the boundary of safe operation for key fuel design and operating parameters,” stating that “the staff is challenged to evaluate the acceptability of future fuel design advancements and fuel utilization changes.” As such, it can be concluded that HBFF and potential dispersal into the reactor coolant system introduces additional complications in light-water reactor (LWR) fuel safety evaluations. However, it is not clear how much fuel will be susceptible to HBFF; nor has there been a methodology developed to evaluate fuel susceptibility to HBFF. To that end, this paper proposes an analysis methodology to assess fuel susceptibility to HBFF during LOCA scenarios. The work presented here uses the BISON fuel performance code to evaluate a representative pressurized water reactor fuel rod exposed to a rod average burnup of 75 GWd/MTU. Sensitivity studies investigated the impact of the peak cladding temperature, transient fission gas released, and pre-transient fission gas release on cladding ballooning and burst timing. Subsequently, a methodology to assess fuel susceptibility to HBFF will be developed based on experimental data published in the open literature. The methodology will then be demonstrated by calculating the mass of fuel susceptibility to HBFF. The BISON results conclude that increasing peak cladding temperature drastically decreased time to failure, and decreased balloon size both of which have been confirmed experimentally. Additionally, the effect of pre-transient and transient fission gas release affected cladding balloon size and burst timing. Lastly, fuel susceptibility to HBFF significantly decreased as a function of peak cladding temperature.

This article presents calculated radionuclide release fractions from TRISO fuel during post-irradiation annealing and comparison with AGR-1 irradiated TRISO compacts using the BISON fuel performance code. The BISON code was found to produce good agreement in an analytical comparison and with legacy German TRISO compact irradiation data. However, the recommended IAEA fission product diffusion coefficients did not produce good agreement with the 2014 AGR-1 data (Demkowicz et al., 2015). Thus, the diffusion coefficients prefactors and activation energies were modified to obtain best agreement with the recent AGR data. Future work involves investigating the release behavior of silver from silicon carbide and implementing methods to provide predictive capability for the silver release behavior.