Patricia A, Sirois, Yanling, Huo, Paige L, Williams, Kathleen, Malee, Patricia A, Garvie, Betsy, Kammerer, Kenneth, Rich, Russell B, Van Dyke, Molly L, Nozyce, and Nydia Scalley, Trifilio
Use of antiretroviral (ARV) medications during pregnancy has led to a dramatic decline in mother-to-child transmission of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)1 while increasing the number of HIV-exposed, uninfected children worldwide.2,3 ARVs may have a negative effect on infant and child health and development.2,4-6 Currently, most pregnant women with HIV in the U.S. receive combination ARV (cARV) therapy to prevent mother-to-child transmission.2,4,7-9 Investigators conducting human and animal studies of prenatal ARV exposure have noted structural and functional changes in the central nervous system (CNS),10-13 suggesting the CNS may be an important target of these agents. In utero exposure to NRTIs such as zidovudine (Retrovir; GlaxoSmithKline, Brentford, Middlesex, UK) has been associated with mitochondrial toxicities in animal and human studies.14-23 Mitochondrial defects adversely affect high-energy organ systems including the brain and peripheral nervous system.24 Conflicting information exists regarding effects of ARV exposure on neurologic and neurodevelopmental functioning. The French Perinatal Cohort study25 examined approximately 1800 children exposed to ARVs and reported 8 with findings compatible with mitochondrial dysfunction, higher than expected in the general population. The European Collaborative Study26 and the Petra study27 found no increase in the rate of severe adverse events in children with perinatal ARV exposure. Among 1037 HIV-exposed, uninfected children, Brogly and colleagues28 identified 20 (1.9%) with possible mitochondrial dysfunction, including 19 with neurological or developmental abnormalities. No clear-cut association with in utero NRTI exposure emerged, but results suggested that first exposure to lamivudine (Epivir; GlaxoSmithKline, Brentford, Middlesex, UK) or zidovudine/lamivudine (Combivir; GlaxoSmithKline, Brentford, Middlesex, UK) in third trimester might be associated with clinical findings of mitochondrial dysfunction. Children with clinical abnormalities in this study tended to have laboratory evidence of mitochondrial abnormalities compared to ARV-exposed and ARV-unexposed children without clinical findings.29 A risk-benefit analysis of ARV use in pregnancy30 found the three least effective regimens demonstrated low toxicity, while three-drug ARV regimens initiated in first trimester resulted in fewer HIV infections but slightly more cases of suspected mitochondrial toxicity. Risk for lowered cognitive performance or increased behavior problems in ARV- and HIV-exposed children is not firmly established.31-35 The French Perinatal Cohort study25 found evidence of developmental delay in children with prenatal ARV exposure, but other investigators26,27,31,32 reported no such association. Some studies did not control adequately for maternal/caregiver and environmental characteristics associated with developmental delays in infants and children, including prenatal exposure to alcohol, drugs, and infections; environmental factors such as poverty, lead exposure, maternal education, and parental medical and psychiatric illness; and, for infants with HIV exposure, severity of maternal HIV disease and pre- and postnatal ARV exposure.28,30,36-41 The primary objective of this analysis was to evaluate safety of in utero and neonatal ARV exposure with respect to development in HIV-exposed, uninfected infants during the first year of life. Specific aims were: (1) describe infant development across developmental domains, (2) evaluate prenatal and postnatal factors confounding the relationship between in utero ARV exposure and infant development, (3) evaluate effects of type and timing of prenatal ARV exposure on development, and (4) evaluate effects of neonatal ARV exposure on development.