Search

Chlorophyll-a (Chl-a) is a direct indicator used to evaluate the ecological state of a waterbody, such as algal blooms that degrade the water quality in lakes, reservoirs and estuaries. In this study, artificial neural network (ANN) and support vector machine (SVM) were used to predict Chl-a concentration for the early warning in the Juam Reservoir and Yeongsan Reservoir, which are located in an upstream region (freshwater reservoir) and downstream region (estuarine reservoir), respectively. Weekly water quality data and meteorological data for a 7-year period were used to train and validate both the ANN and SVM models. The Latin-hypercube one-factor-at-a-time (LH-OAT) method and a pattern search algorithm were applied to perform sensitivity analyses for the input variables and to optimize the parameters of the two models, respectively. Results revealed that the two models well-reproduced the temporal variation of Chl-a based on the weekly input variables. In particular, the SVM model showed better performance than the ANN model, displaying a higher prediction accuracy in the validation step. The Williams-Kloot test and sensitivity analysis demonstrated that the SVM model was superior for predicting Chl-a in terms of prediction accuracy and description of the cause-and-effect relationship between Chl-a concentration and environmental variables in both the Juam Reservoir and Yeongsan Reservoir. Furthermore, a 7-day interval was determined as an efficient early warning interval in the two reservoirs. As such, this study suggested an effective early-warning prediction method for Chl-a concentration and improved the eutrophication management scheme for reservoirs.

Statistical regression models involve linear equations, which often lead to significant prediction errors due to poor statistical stability and accuracy. This concern arises from multicollinearity in the models, which may drastically affect model performance in terms of a trade-off scenario for effective water resource management logistics. In this paper, we propose a new methodology for improving the statistical stability and accuracy of regression models, and then show how to cope with pitfalls in the models and determine optimal parameters with a decreased number of predictive variables. Here, a comparison of the predictive performance was made using four types of multiple linear regression (MLR) and principal component regression (PCR) models in the prediction of chlorophyll-a (chl-a) concentration in the Yeongsan (YS) Reservoir, Korea, an estuarine reservoir that historically suffers from high levels of nutrient input. During a 3-year water quality monitoring period, results showed that PCRs could be a compact solution for improving the accuracy of the models, as in each case MLR could not accurately produce reliable predictions due to a persistent collinearity problem. Furthermore, based on R2 (goodness of fit) and F-overall number (confidence of regression), and the number of explanatory variables (R-F-N) curve, it was revealed that PCR-F(7) was the best model among the four regression models in predicting chl-a, having the fewest explanatory variables (seven) and the lowest uncertainty. Seven PCs were identified as significant variables, related to eight water quality parameters: pH, 5-day biochemical oxygen demand, total coliform, fecal indicator bacteria, chemical oxygen demand, ammonia–nitrogen, total nitrogen, and dissolved oxygen. Overall, the results not only demonstrated that the models employed successfully simulated chl-a in a reservoir in both the test and validation periods, but also suggested that the optimal parameters should cautiously be considered in the design of regression models.