Search

In the spirit that a picture is worth a thousand words, the Pathways Commission Vision’s “perception” of accounting is a simplistic caricature of a practice epitomized by bookkeeping and governed by a “black letter” tradition whereby hard-and-fast rules exist for distilling the vast number of data business generates into a meaningful narrative about the financial state and performance of a firm. The “Reality” Vision is a rather heroic self-perception the profession has for the role it will play in producing a prosperous society. The problematic ambiguity with the “Reality” obviously revolves around the concept of “prosperous society” and what implications different notions of prosperous have for accounting’s role in society, given accounting’s (and accountants’) limitations. We propose a vision for a prosperous society based on the 17 UN goals, specifically focusing on the two which relate to income distribution and sustainability. We consider how accounting can play a role in helping achieve this view of a prosperous society.

Proponents tout plain English as a solution for improving communication of complex information to users in various areas of business, medicine, and law. The SEC’s mandate to public companies to use Plain English in their Item 1a risk factor disclosures to make them more readable is one example. Using 365 responses from an experimental survey of nonprofessional US investors, we find that readability significantly influences investors’ perceptions of probability and size of loss, economic worry, and overall risk. Further, these effects interact with type of risk factor. Readability does not appear to influence investment decisions or perception of management credibility. Finally, we find that investors report that they do not use item 1a risk factors in their investment analyses in practice. Results suggest that this area needs further research before future mandates for plain English and risk factor disclosures are enacted.