Search

Both quantitative coronary angiography (QCA) and intravascular ultrasound (IVUS) are currently used to assess in-stent restenosis. This study aimed to use standardized imaging and clinical follow-up to compare QCA parameters with several IVUS parameters to evaluate their strengths and weaknesses for detecting in-stent restenosis in a drug-eluting stent population. A subset of patients from the TAXUS IV, V, and VI studies was evaluated. The subset, which included 216 TAXUS-treated patients and 191 bare-metal stent-treated patients, had complete IVUS and QCA performed at baseline and follow-up. As expected, all QCA and IVUS parameters were consistent with less intimal hyperplasia in TAXUS patients than controls. The overall incidence of QCA binary restenosis was 14.0%, which was 9.3% in TAXUS-treated patients and 19% in bare-metal stent-treated patients (p = 0.0008). Regression analysis showed that QCA late lumen loss and percentage of diameter stenosis correlated only moderately with the various IVUS measures of neointimal hyperplasia for the combined group of patients (TAXUS + bare-metal stent), as well as for the TAXUS-treated and bare-metal stent-treated patients separately. However, in general, correlations within the control (bare-metal stent) group tended to be stronger than within the TAXUS group. The strongest correlation was between QCA percentage of diameter stenosis and IVUS percentage of intimal hyperplasia in the overall group and the control group. The strongest IVUS predictor of QCA binary restenosis at 9 months was maximum percentage of intimal hyperplasia, with an overall C = 0.91 and p

Late loss has been used as a reliable surrogate end point for evaluation and differentiation of short-term performance of drug-eluting stents. This study investigated the consistency between angiographic and intravascular ultrasound (IVUS) outcomes of late lumen loss (late loss) and neointimal growth to measure restenotic plaque load in TAXUS and bare metal stents. The randomized TAXUS II trial evaluates the polymer-based paclitaxel-eluting TAXUS stent in slow- and moderate-release formulations. Serial angiographic and IVUS analyses were available in 155 event-free patients (bare metal stent, 74; TAXUS stent, 81) after the procedure, at 6 months, and at 2 years. For this subanalysis, quantitative coronary angiographic (QCA) and IVUS measurements were used to derive late loss and neointimal volume. From after the procedure to 6 months, quantitative coronary angiography and IVUS showed matching results for the 2 groups with significant decreases in late loss and neointimal volume in the TAXUS versus the control group. From 6 months to 2 years, QCA and IVUS measurements also showed results similar to those in the control group, demonstrating neointimal compaction over time. However, in the TAXUS group, QCA late loss showed a nonsignificant decrease from 6 months to 2 years, whereas IVUS neointimal volume increased. In conclusion, although QCA and IVUS results were similar over the first 6 months, long-term assessment of changes in restenotic plaque load showed discrepant findings for the TAXUS. These findings suggest the need for critical reevaluation of current end points and the use of more precise techniques to detect lumen and stent boundaries.