7 results
Search Results
2. Fitness issues in the context of judicial proceedings.
- Author
-
Samuels, Anthony, O'Driscoll, Colman, and Allnutt, Stephen
- Subjects
PHYSICAL fitness ,MENTAL health ,MENTAL illness ,PATHOLOGICAL psychology - Abstract
Objective: This paper provides a conceptual, historical and legislative overview of fitness issues. These include fitness to be interrogated or charged, to plead, to be tried and to be sentenced in the context of Australia and New Zealand. Conclusions: Legislation regarding fitness issues needs to strike a balance between protecting the rights of mentally impaired defendants to a fair trial process and recognizing that mental illness in itself does not absolutely preclude participation in a trial process or necessarily diminish criminal responsibility. Although the key determinants of fitness seem to be the ability to cope with court processes and communicate with counsel, the application of clinical judgement to legal criteria is not always straightforward. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2007
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
3. Restricted patients in New Zealand: A failed social experiment with a hybrid form of civil/forensic compulsory mental health treatment.
- Author
-
Every-Palmer, Susanna, Dunn, Alice, Foulds, James, Reuvecamp, Iris, and Dawson, John
- Subjects
- *
MENTAL health laws , *FORENSIC psychiatry , *PEOPLE with intellectual disabilities & crime , *MENTAL illness treatment , *MENTAL health , *INSANITY defense , *MENTAL health services - Abstract
Introduction: In 1992, New Zealand's mental health legislation created the distinct concept of a 'restricted patient' - effectively creating a pathway into forensic patient status, but via the civil committal process, without the patient passing through the criminal justice system en route. This regime was aimed at civilly committed patients who present "special difficulties" because of the danger they pose to others. It remains in force but has attracted little scrutiny.Objective: This paper traverses the background to restricted patient status, and the legal regime, before describing and analysing, in anonymous form, the circumstances of all those declared to be restricted patients, and their outcomes, since the regime began. It then considers the continuing appropriateness of this legal regime in light of contemporary human rights principles.Methods: We reviewed the records of every person placed under restricted patient status since the legislation came into force over a nearly 30-year-period.Results: New Zealand's restricted patient status is rarely used. Only eight people have been subject to such orders (seven male, median age 45 years at the making of the order). All had a history of violent offending and had previously been forensic patients. None re-offended after becoming a restricted patient, but they spent longer as compulsory inpatients than patients unfit to stand trial or not guilty by reason of insanity. There is no evidence they were uniquely dangerous. The legal criteria, namely, that the person presented with "special difficulties", are unclear and have been interpreted differently by the judiciary. They have sometimes included the risk of inadequate care being provided by mental health services.Conclusion: Given the rarity with which restricted patient status has been used in New Zealand, the subsequent evolution and development of forensic services providing alternative pathways through care, and its problematic human rights aspects, we would not recommend equivalent restricted patient provisions to other countries. We suggest this hybrid form of civil/forensic compulsory mental health treatment is a form of arbitrary detention and incompatible with human rights norms. It should be omitted from New Zealand's next Mental Health Act. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
4. Insanity acquittee outcomes in New Zealand.
- Author
-
Skipworth, Jeremy, Brinded, Phil, Chaplow, David, and Frampton, Chris
- Subjects
- *
INSANITY (Law) , *FORENSIC psychiatry , *MENTAL health , *INPATIENT care , *VIOLENT crimes , *REHABILITATION of people with mental illness , *COMMUNITY-based corrections - Abstract
Objective: This paper examines clinical and forensic outcomes for defendants found not guilty by reason of insanity in New Zealand, and explores the implications for policy development and clinical rehabilitation in this population. Method: All insanity acquittees disposed of by the courts as special patients after 1976 and released before 2004 are described. Their duration of inpatient care, rates of reconviction and rehospitalization following release are examined. The high resolution rate for violent crime reported to police suggests that reconviction rates are a reasonable proxy for violent reoffending. Factors predicting duration of inpatient care and reoffending are analysed. Results: Severity of Index Offence was the only variable predicting duration of inpatient care of the 135 special patients. Offenders of more serious offences were securely detained for longer periods – averaging 6 years in the case of those charged with murder. Most patients were readmitted over the decade following discharge. Only 6% had violently reoffended 2 years after release into the community. Prior offending, age at release, ethnicity and gender predicted reoffending, but not diagnosis or duration of inpatient admission. Conclusions: Following discharge into the community, insanity acquittees are reconvicted of violent crimes at a very low rate, although readmission to hospital is common. It may be that insanity acquittees are initially detained in hospital longer than is clinically indicated, and that safe forensic community treatment can occur at an earlier stage of recovery without compromising public safety. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2006
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
5. Prevalence of psychiatric disorders in New Zealand prisons: a national study.
- Author
-
Brinded, Philip M.J., Simpson, Alexander I.F., Laidlaw, Tannis M., Fairley, Nigel, and Malcolm, Fiona
- Subjects
- *
MENTAL illness , *PRISONERS , *SCHIZOPHRENIA , *MENTAL health - Abstract
Objective: The paper describes the methodologies and results obtained on a large cohort of prison inmates in New Zealand who were screened for psychiatric disorder. Method: All women and remanded male inmates in New Zealand prisons, and a randomly selected cohort of 18% of sentenced male inmates were interviewed. Interviewers used the Composite International Diagnostic Interview – Automated to establish DSM-IV diagnoses, and the Personality Disorders Questionnaire to identify personality disorder. All prisons in New Zealand were visited. Results: The results indicate markedly elevated prevalence rates for major mental disorder in the prison population when compared with community samples. This is especially the case for substance misuse, psychotic disorders, major depression, bipolar disorder, obsessive– compulsive disorder and posttraumatic stress disorder. Of particular concern is not only the increased prevalence rates for schizophrenia and related disorders but also the high level of comorbidity with substance misuse disorders demonstrated by this group. While 80.8% of inmates diagnosed with bipolar disorder were receiving psychiatric treatment in the prison, only 46.4% of depressed inmates and 37% of those suffering from psychosis were receiving treatment. Maori inmates were grossly overrepresented in the remand, female and male sentenced inmate population compared with the general population. Conclusions: A significant increase in provision of mental health services is required to cope with the high number of mentally ill inmates. The level of need demonstrated by this study requires a level of service provision that is quite beyond the capacity of current forensic psychiatry services, Department of Corrections Psychological Services or the prison nursing and medical officers. The elevated rates of common mental disorders argues for the use of improved psychiatric screening instruments, improved assessment and treatment capacities in the prison and an increased number of forensic psychiatric inpatient facilities to care for those psychotic inmates who are too unwell to be treated in the prison. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2001
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
6. Forensic Issues in Mental Health Displayed in Art.
- Author
-
Freckelton SC, Ian
- Subjects
PSYCHIATRY ,PSYCHOLOGY ,MENTAL health ,PUBLIC health ,FORENSIC psychiatry ,MENTAL illness ,ART - Abstract
This editorial marks the formal commencement of a collaboration between Psychiatry, Psychology and Law and the Cunningham Dax Collection from Victoria, Australia, one of the world's most significant collections of creative works generated by people who have experienced mental illness or psychological trauma. It traces the evolution of the Collection and identifies some of the significant therapeutic and legal issues encountered in its evolution. It sets out principles which will be utilised to select images for Psychiatry, Psychology and Law and the aspirations of the collaboration. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2009
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
7. Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) therapy for posttraumatic stress disorder in adults with serious mental illness within forensic and rehabilitation services: a study protocol for a randomized controlled trial.
- Author
-
Every-Palmer, Susanna, Flewett, Tom, Dean, Shaystah, Hansby, Oliver, Colman, Atalie, Weatherall, Mark, and Bell, Elliot
- Subjects
EMDR (Eye-movement desensitization & reprocessing) ,POST-traumatic stress disorder ,MENTAL health services ,MENTAL illness ,RANDOMIZED controlled trials ,SOCIAL stigma ,ADULT child abuse victims - Abstract
Background: Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) is an evidenced-based treatment for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Forensic mental health services provide assessment and treatment of people with mental illness and a history of criminal offending, or those who are at risk of offending. Forensic mental health services include high, medium, and low-security inpatient settings as well as prison in-reach and community outpatient services. There is a high prevalence of PTSD in forensic settings and posttraumatic experiences can arise in people who violently offend in the context of serious mental illness (SMI). Successful treatment of PTSD may reduce the risk of relapse and improve clinical outcomes for this population. This study aims to assess the efficacy, risk of harm, and acceptability of EMDR within forensic and rehabilitation mental health services, as compared to treatment as usual (routine care).Methods: This is a single-blind, randomized controlled trial comparing EMDR therapy to the waiting list (routine care). Adult forensic mental health service users (n = 46) with SMI and meeting the criteria for PTSD will be included in the study. Participants will be randomized after baseline assessment to either treatment as usual plus waiting list for EMDR or to treatment as usual plus EMDR. The EMDR condition comprises nine sessions, around 60 min in length delivered weekly, the first of which is a case conceptualization session. The primary outcomes are clinician and participant-rated symptoms of PTSD, and adverse events. Secondary outcomes include psychotic symptoms, social functioning, level of disability, self-esteem, depressive symptoms, post-trauma cognitions, and broad domains of complex posttraumatic difficulties. A trained assessor blinded to the treatment condition will assess outcomes at baseline, 10 weeks, and 6 months. Additionally, grounded theory qualitative methods will be used to explore participant experience of EMDR for a subset of participants.Discussion: This study will contribute to the currently limited evidence base for EMDR for PTSD in forensic settings. It is the first randomized clinical trial to assess the efficacy, risk of harm, and acceptability of EMDR for PTSD in people with SMI in either forensic, mental health inpatient, or custodial settings.Trial Registration: Australia and New Zealand Clinical Trials Network, ACTRN12618000683235. Registered prospectively on 24 April 2018. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]- Published
- 2019
- Full Text
- View/download PDF
Discovery Service for Jio Institute Digital Library
For full access to our library's resources, please sign in.