1. Comment: John H. Schuenemeyer.
- Author
-
Schuenemeyer, John H.
- Subjects
- *
ESTIMATION theory , *NATURAL resources , *PETROLEUM products , *NATURAL gas , *PETROLEUM , *PETROLEUM engineering , *STATISTICS - Abstract
In this article, the author comments on the research paper of John J. Wiorkowski titled "Estimating Volumes of Remaining Fossil Fuel Resources: A Critical Review," published in the September 1981 issue of "Journal of the American Statistical Association." According to the author, the strength of Wiorkowski's paper is in bringing the important problem of petroleum resource estimation to the attention of statisticians. The major weaknesses are in the organization and classification of models and the gaps in coverage. The major issues in resource estimation that Wiorkowski discusses are models for estimating the total oil and gas remaining to be found and a closely related problem, estimating the amount of appreciation in known fields. The problem with the discussion of the models is the lack of a proper classification scheme. Although Wiorkowski mentions the model of researchers E. Barouch and G.M. Kaufman, he fails to note that it is one of a general class of models that are based on the discovery process and fails to emphasize that it is a play model, whereas the others he discusses are used at a higher level of aggregation.
- Published
- 1981
- Full Text
- View/download PDF