1. Investigation into the effect of low temperature in the femoral hip stem on the extraction force required during revision total hip arthroplasty
- Author
-
Botello Arredondo, Adeodato and Zou, Zhenmin
- Subjects
Cryosurgery ,Pull-out Force ,Hip prosthetic ,Total Hip Arthroplasty ,Revision Total Hip Arthroplasty ,Femoral Stem - Abstract
Improvements in Total Hip Arthroplasty (THA) technology, methods of fixation, and cementing techniques of the prosthetic components have resulted in major problems when Revision Total Hip Arthroplasty (RTHA) is required, making the removal of well-fixed femoral stems a challenging and difficult surgical procedure. The promotion of osseointegration in cementless THA means removal of a cementless stem in RTHA is a particularly demanding task. Despite the numerous tools and methods that can be employed to remove the femoral component, the surrounding soft and osseous tissue can be severely damaged by the established revision techniques because no surgical procedure is able to remove a well-fixed femoral stem without causing any damage. This thesis investigates cooling the femoral prosthesis in order to lower the force required to extract the implant during RTHA of cementless femoral stems. Based on this concept, a new methodology was developed, consisting of cooling the neck of the femoral stem to a low temperature and immediately extracting the stem from the femur. As a proof of concept, to demonstrate the potential feasibility of the new method, experimental tests involving the removal of a cemented stem were considered; this was because, amongst other reasons, (i) the difficulty of simulating osseointegration in laboratory experimentation in a controlled and repeatable way, (ii) the favourable similarities of the mechanical and thermal properties of bone cement and bone, (iii) the fact that it has been determined that to pull-out cemented stems requires 60% to 70% of the pulling force to remove cementless stems, thus experimentation on cemented stems can provide a relatively good indication of the behaviour with cementless stems, (iv) the repeatability of the experimental procedure associated with the use of cemented stems. Three sets of in-vitro case studies were carried out with custom-made titanium stems cemented into a trapezoidal steel mould, a composite cylinder and a composite femur using polymethyl-methacrylate with a minimum cement mantle thickness of 3mm. First, a trapezoidal steel mould was employed for four case studies with the femoral neck stem cooled to temperatures of -76ᵒC, -58ᵒC, -49ᵒC, and -40ᵒC. Composite bones were used for the second set of case studies, in which stems were cemented into a) composite cylinders and b) composite femurs. Three case studies were performed for the cylindrical specimens: -76ᵒC, -49ᵒC, and -40ᵒC. Two case studies were considered for the composite femoral specimens: -76ᵒC, and -40ᵒC. In each of the tests, after reaching the temperature of interest, the specimen was immediately clamped in a materials testing machine, and the stem pulled out at a constant rate of 0.5 mm/min. Control tests were undertaken at room temperature for comparison purposes. Results from the first set of case studies showed that the force required to remove the titanium stem was reduced to 56.5% of the control force at a temperature of -76ᵒC, while for temperatures of -58ᵒC, -49ᵒC, and -40ᵒC the release force was reduced by 39%, 28%, and 31% respectively. Subsequent case studies with the cylindrical and femur composites also showed a reduction in the release force compared to their respective control force. The composite cylinder specimens exhibited reductions of 50%, 57% and 53% of the release force for temperatures of -76ᵒC, -49ᵒC, and -40ᵒC while, in the composite femur specimen the release force was reduced by 65% for a temperature of -40ᵒC. The results confirmed that the force required to remove a well-cemented femoral stem was reduced after cooling to temperatures below -40ᵒC allowing easier extraction of the stem. A finite element model was developed to analyse the thermal conditions in the femoral stem and surrounding material. The model can be used to ensure the required thermal balance can be obtained whilst avoiding conditions which may lead to tissue damage. The model was validated using the results of the experiments in which the temperature at strategic points on the stem was monitored during cooling. Furthermore, a concept design of a medical device based on the new methodology was developed.
- Published
- 2017