1. Location and allocation: inequity of access to liver transplantation for patients with severe acute‐on‐chronic liver failure in Europe
- Author
-
Artzner, T, Bernal, W, Belli, L, Conti, S, Cortesi, P, Sacleux, S, Pageaux, G, Radenne, S, Trebicka, J, Fernandez, J, Perricone, G, Piano, S, Nadalin, S, Morelli, M, Martini, S, Polak, W, Zieniewicz, K, Toso, C, Berenguer, M, Iegri, C, Invernizzi, F, Volpes, R, Karam, V, Adam, R, Faitot, F, Rabinowich, L, Saliba, F, Meunier, L, Lesurtel, M, Uschner, F, Michard, B, Coilly, A, Meszaros, M, Poinsot, D, Besch, C, Schnitzbauer, A, De Carlis, L, Fumagalli, R, Angeli, P, Arroyo, V, Fondevila, C, Duvoux, C, Jalan, R, Viganò, R, Mazzarelli, C, Lauterio, A, Giacomoni, A, Donato, F, Lampertico, P, Pasulo, L, Fagiuoli, S, Colledan, M, Cristina Morelli, M, Vitale, G, Ottobrelli, A, Patrono, D, Romagnoli, R, Petridis, I, Cillo, U, Germani, G, Burra, P, Bachellier, P, Schneider, F, Castelain, V, Addeo, P, Deridder, M, Caroline Sacleux Audrey Coilly, S, Faouzi, S, Samuel, D, Guichon, C, Faure, S, Ursic‐bedoya, J, Colmenero, J, Toapanta, D, Hernández‐tejero, M, Vinaixa, C, den Hoed, C, Haan, J, Della Penna, A, Erhard Uschner, F, Welker, M, Zeuzem, S, Bechstein, W, Goossens, N, Raszeja‐wyszomirska, J, Rabinovich, L, Katarey, D, Agarwal, B, Artzner, Thierry, Bernal, William, Belli, Luca S, Conti, Sara, Cortesi, Paolo A, Sacleux, Sophie‐Caroline, Pageaux, George‐Philippe, Radenne, Sylvie, Trebicka, Jonel, Fernandez, Javier, Perricone, Giovanni, Piano, Salvatore, Nadalin, Silvio, Morelli, Maria C, Martini, Silvia, Polak, Wojciech G, Zieniewicz, Krzysztof, Toso, Christian, Berenguer, Marina, Iegri, Claudia, Invernizzi, Federica, Volpes, Riccardo, Karam, Vincent, Adam, René, Faitot, François, Rabinowich, Liane, Saliba, Faouzi, Meunier, Lucy, Lesurtel, Mickael, Uschner, Frank E, Michard, Baptiste, Coilly, Audrey, Meszaros, Magdalena, Poinsot, Domitille, Besch, Camille, Schnitzbauer, Andreas, De Carlis, Luciano G, Fumagalli, Roberto, Angeli, Paolo, Arroyo, Vincente, Fondevila, Constantino, Duvoux, Christophe, Jalan, Rajiv, Viganò, Raffaella, Mazzarelli, Chiara, Lauterio, Andrea, Giacomoni, Alessandro, Donato, Francesca, Lampertico, Pietro, Pasulo, Luisa, Fagiuoli, Stefano, Colledan, Michele, Cristina Morelli, Maria, Vitale, Giovanni, Ottobrelli, Antonio, Patrono, Damiano, Romagnoli, Renato, Petridis, Ioannis, Cillo, Umberto, Germani, Giacomo, Burra, Patrizia, Bachellier, Philippe, Schneider, Francis, Castelain, Vincent, Addeo, Pietro, Deridder, Mathilde, Caroline Sacleux Audrey Coilly, Sophie, Faouzi, Saliba, Adam, Rene, Samuel, Didier, Guichon, Celine, Faure, Stéfanie, Ursic‐Bedoya, Josè, Fondevila, Costantino, Colmenero, Jorde, Toapanta, David, Hernández‐Tejero, María, Vinaixa, Carmen, Polak, Wojciech G., den Hoed, Caroline, Haan, Jubi E., Della Penna, Andrea, Erhard Uschner, Frank, Welker, Martin, Zeuzem, Stefan, Bechstein, Wolf, Goossens, Nicolas, Raszeja‐Wyszomirska, Joanna, Rabinovich, Liane, Katarey, Dev, Agarwal, Banwari, Artzner, T, Bernal, W, Belli, L, Conti, S, Cortesi, P, Sacleux, S, Pageaux, G, Radenne, S, Trebicka, J, Fernandez, J, Perricone, G, Piano, S, Nadalin, S, Morelli, M, Martini, S, Polak, W, Zieniewicz, K, Toso, C, Berenguer, M, Iegri, C, Invernizzi, F, Volpes, R, Karam, V, Adam, R, Faitot, F, Rabinowich, L, Saliba, F, Meunier, L, Lesurtel, M, Uschner, F, Michard, B, Coilly, A, Meszaros, M, Poinsot, D, Besch, C, Schnitzbauer, A, De Carlis, L, Fumagalli, R, Angeli, P, Arroyo, V, Fondevila, C, Duvoux, C, Jalan, R, Viganò, R, Mazzarelli, C, Lauterio, A, Giacomoni, A, Donato, F, Lampertico, P, Pasulo, L, Fagiuoli, S, Colledan, M, Cristina Morelli, M, Vitale, G, Ottobrelli, A, Patrono, D, Romagnoli, R, Petridis, I, Cillo, U, Germani, G, Burra, P, Bachellier, P, Schneider, F, Castelain, V, Addeo, P, Deridder, M, Caroline Sacleux Audrey Coilly, S, Faouzi, S, Samuel, D, Guichon, C, Faure, S, Ursic‐bedoya, J, Colmenero, J, Toapanta, D, Hernández‐tejero, M, Vinaixa, C, den Hoed, C, Haan, J, Della Penna, A, Erhard Uschner, F, Welker, M, Zeuzem, S, Bechstein, W, Goossens, N, Raszeja‐wyszomirska, J, Rabinovich, L, Katarey, D, Agarwal, B, Artzner, Thierry, Bernal, William, Belli, Luca S, Conti, Sara, Cortesi, Paolo A, Sacleux, Sophie‐Caroline, Pageaux, George‐Philippe, Radenne, Sylvie, Trebicka, Jonel, Fernandez, Javier, Perricone, Giovanni, Piano, Salvatore, Nadalin, Silvio, Morelli, Maria C, Martini, Silvia, Polak, Wojciech G, Zieniewicz, Krzysztof, Toso, Christian, Berenguer, Marina, Iegri, Claudia, Invernizzi, Federica, Volpes, Riccardo, Karam, Vincent, Adam, René, Faitot, François, Rabinowich, Liane, Saliba, Faouzi, Meunier, Lucy, Lesurtel, Mickael, Uschner, Frank E, Michard, Baptiste, Coilly, Audrey, Meszaros, Magdalena, Poinsot, Domitille, Besch, Camille, Schnitzbauer, Andreas, De Carlis, Luciano G, Fumagalli, Roberto, Angeli, Paolo, Arroyo, Vincente, Fondevila, Constantino, Duvoux, Christophe, Jalan, Rajiv, Viganò, Raffaella, Mazzarelli, Chiara, Lauterio, Andrea, Giacomoni, Alessandro, Donato, Francesca, Lampertico, Pietro, Pasulo, Luisa, Fagiuoli, Stefano, Colledan, Michele, Cristina Morelli, Maria, Vitale, Giovanni, Ottobrelli, Antonio, Patrono, Damiano, Romagnoli, Renato, Petridis, Ioannis, Cillo, Umberto, Germani, Giacomo, Burra, Patrizia, Bachellier, Philippe, Schneider, Francis, Castelain, Vincent, Addeo, Pietro, Deridder, Mathilde, Caroline Sacleux Audrey Coilly, Sophie, Faouzi, Saliba, Adam, Rene, Samuel, Didier, Guichon, Celine, Faure, Stéfanie, Ursic‐Bedoya, Josè, Fondevila, Costantino, Colmenero, Jorde, Toapanta, David, Hernández‐Tejero, María, Vinaixa, Carmen, Polak, Wojciech G., den Hoed, Caroline, Haan, Jubi E., Della Penna, Andrea, Erhard Uschner, Frank, Welker, Martin, Zeuzem, Stefan, Bechstein, Wolf, Goossens, Nicolas, Raszeja‐Wyszomirska, Joanna, Rabinovich, Liane, Katarey, Dev, and Agarwal, Banwari
- Abstract
Background: There is growing evidence that liver transplantation (LT) is the most effective treatment for acute-on-chronic liver failure grade-3 (ACLF-3). This study examines whether and how this evidence translates into practice by analyzing the variability in intensive care unit (ICU) admissions, listing strategies and LT activity for ACLF-3 patients across transplant centers in Europe. Methods: Consecutive patients who were admitted to the ICU with ACLF-3, whether or not they were listed and/or transplanted with ACLF-3 between 2018 and 2019 were included across 20 transplantation centers. Results: 351 patients with ACLF-3 were included: 33 had been listed prior to developing ACLF-3 and 318 had not been listed at the time of admission to the ICU. There was no correlation between the number of unlisted ACLF-3 patients admitted to the ICU and the number listed or transplanted whilst in ACLF-3 across centers. In contrast, there was a correlation between the number of patients listed and the number transplanted whilst in ACLF-3. 21% of patients who were listed whilst in ACLF-3 died on the waiting list or were delisted. The percentage of LT for ACLF-3 patients varied from 0%-29% of patients transplanted with decompensated cirrhosis across centers (average = 8%), with an I2 index of 68% (95% CI: 49%-80%), showing substantial heterogeneity among centers. The one-year survival for all patients with ACLF-3 was significantly higher in centers that listed and transplanted more ACLF-3 patients (>10 patients) than in centers that listed and transplanted fewer: respectively 36% vs. 20%, p = 0.012. Conclusion: Patients with ACLF-3 face inequity of access to LT across Europe. Wait-listing strategies for ACLF-3 patients influence their access to LT and, ultimately, their survival.
- Published
- 2022