1. A novel approach to evaluate soil heat flux calculation: An analytical review of nine methods
- Author
-
Gao, Zhongming, Russell, Eric S., Missik, Justine E. C., Huang, Maoyi, Chen, Xingyuan, Strickland, Chris E., Clayton, Ray, Arntzen, Evan, Ma, Yulong, and Liu, Heping
- Abstract
There are no direct methods to evaluate calculated soil heat flux (SHF) at the surface (G0). Instead, validation and cross evaluation of methods for calculating G0usually rely on the conventional calorimetric method or the degree of the surface energy balance closure. However, there is uncertainty in the calorimetric method itself, and factors apart from G0also contribute to nonclosure of the surface energy balance. Here we used a novel approach to evaluate nine different methods for calculating SHF, including the calorimetric method and methods based on analytical solutions of the heat diffusion equation. The SHF (Gz) measured by a self‐calibrating SHF plate at a depth of z= 5 cm below the surface (hereafter Gm_5cm) was deployed as a reference. Each SHF calculation method was assessed by comparing the calculated Gzat the same depth (hereafter Gc_5cm) with Gm_5cm. The calorimetric method and simple measurement method performed best in determining Gc_5cmbut still underestimated Gm_5cmby 19% during the daytime. Possible causes for this underestimation include errors and uncertainties in SHF measurements and soil thermal properties, as well as the phase lag between Gc_5cmand Gm_5cm. Our results indicate that the calorimetric method achieves the most accurate SHF estimates if self‐calibrating SHF plates are deployed at two depths (e.g., 5 cm and 10 cm), soil temperature and water content measurements are made in a few depths between the two plates, and soil thermal properties are accurately quantified. We evaluated nine methods of soil heat flux calculation using field observationsAll nine methods underestimated the soil heat flux by at least 19%This large underestimation is mainly caused by uncertainties in soil thermal properties
- Published
- 2017
- Full Text
- View/download PDF