Search

Radiolabelled meta-iodobenzylguanidine (MIBG) is selectively taken up by tumours of neuroendocrine origin, where its cellular localization is believed to be cytoplasmic. The radiopharmaceutical [131I]MIBG is now widely used in the treatment of neuroblastoma, but other radioconjugates of benzylguanidine have been little studied. We have investigated the cytotoxic efficacy of beta, alpha and Auger electron-emitting radioconjugates in treating neuroblastoma cells grown in monolayer or spheroid culture. Using a no-carrier-added synthesis route, we produced 123I-, 125I-, 131I- and 211At-labelled benzylguanidines and compared their in vitro toxicity to the neuroblastoma cell line SK-N-BE(2c) grown in monolayer and spheroid culture. The Auger electron-emitting conjugates ([123I]MIBG and [125I]MIBG) and the alpha-emitting conjugate ([211At]MABG) were highly toxic to monolayers and small spheroids, whereas the beta-emitting conjugate [131I]MIBG was relatively ineffective. The Auger emitters were more effective than expected if the cellular localization of MIBG is cytoplasmic. As dosimetrically predicted however, [211At]MABG was found to be extremely potent in terms of both concentration of radioactivity and number of atoms ml(-1) administered. In contrast, the Auger electron emitters were ineffective in the treatment of larger spheroids, while the beta emitter showed greater efficacy. These findings suggest that short-range emitters would be well suited to the treatment of circulating tumour cells or small clumps, whereas beta emitters would be superior in the treatment of subclinical metastases or macroscopic tumours. These experimental results provide support for a clinical strategy of combinations ('cocktails') of radioconjugates in targeted radiotherapy.

Stochastic models of tumorigenesis have been developed to investigate the implications of experimental data on tumour induction in wild-type and p53-deficient mice for tumorigenesis mechanisms. Conventional multistage models in which inactivation of each p53 allele represents a distinct stage predict excessively large numbers of tumours in p53-deficient genotypes, allowing this category of model to be rejected. Multistage multipath models, in which a p53-mediated pathway co-exists with one or more p53-independent pathways, are consistent with the data, although these models require unknown pathways and do not enable age-specific curves of tumour appearance to be computed. An alternative model that fits the data is the 'multigate' model in which tumorigenesis results from a small number of gate-pass (enabling) events independently of p53 status. The role of p53 inactivation is as a rate modifier that accelerates the gate-pass events. This model implies that wild-type p53 acts as a 'caretaker' to maintain genetic uniformity in cell populations, and that p53 inactivation increases the probability of occurrence of a viable cellular mutant by a factor of about ten. The multigate model predicts a relationship between the time pattern of tumour occurrence and tumour genotype that should be experimentally testable. Stochastic modelling may help to distinguish 'gatekeeper' and 'caretaker' genes in other tumorigenic pathays.

[131I]meta-iodobenzylguanidine ([131I]MIBG) provides a means of selectively delivering radiation to neuroblastoma cells and is a promising addition to the range of agents used to treat neuroblastoma. As MIBG is now being incorporated into multimodal approaches to therapy, important questions arise about the appropriate scheduling and sequencing of the various agents employed. As the ability of neuroblastoma cells to actively accumulate MIBG is crucial to the success of this therapy, the effect of chemotherapeutic agents on this uptake capacity needs to be investigated. We report here our initial findings on the effect of cisplatin pretreatment on the neuroblastoma cell line SK-N-BE (2c). After treating these cells with therapeutically relevant concentrations of cisplatin (2 microM and 20 microM), a stimulation in uptake of [131I]MIBG was observed. Reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) analysis demonstrated that this effect was due to increased expression of the noradrenaline transporter. These results suggest that appropriate scheduling of cisplatin and [131I]MIBG may lead to an increase in tumour uptake of this radiopharmaceutical with consequent increases in radiation dose to the tumour.

Radiolabelled meta-iodobenzylguanidine (mIBG) currently provides one of the most promising options for targeted radiotherapy of neuroblastoma. No means currently exists for prediction of mIBG uptake in tumour cells of individual patients other than semiquantitative inferences from diagnostic scanning which depend on the continued existence of a macroscopic tumour mass. A biological rapid assay which could be applied at initial biopsy would be invaluable in selecting patients for therapeutic strategies which incorporate radiolabelled mIBG. We have assessed the expression of the noradrenaline transporter gene in six human neuroblastoma cell lines and in three non-neural crest-derived cell lines using reverse transcription followed by the polymerase chain reaction. Transcription of this gene was observed in five out of six neuroblastoma cell lines but in none of the control cells. A highly significant correlation was established (P < 0.01) between gene expression and active cellular accumulation of mIBG. It is suggested that semiquantitative evaluation of noradrenaline transporter gene transcripts may be predictive of mIBG uptake by tumours in vivo.

Successful imaging or treatment of neuroblastoma with 131I-meta-iodobenzylguanidine (131I-mIBG) depends on the selectivity of active (type 1) uptake of mIBG in neuroblastoma cells relative to passive (type 2) uptake present in most normal tissues. This study investigates the effects of moderately elevated temperature (39-41 degrees C) on the cellular uptake of 131I-mIBG in two neuroblastoma cell lines [SK-N-BE(2c) and IMR-32] and in a non-neuronal (ovarian carcinoma) cell line (A2780). In SK-N-BE(2c), a cell line with high active uptake capacity, the specific (type 1) uptake was reduced by 75% (P < 0.001) at 39 degrees C. Both IMR-32 and A2780 have a low capacity for accumulation of mIBG by active uptake. These cell lines demonstrated a statistically significant increase in accumulation at 39 degrees C, mainly as a result of increased non-specific transport. At 41 degrees C uptake of 131I-mIBG was reduced in all cell lines. Thus, the active component of mIBG uptake is more vulnerable to increased temperature than the passive component. It seems probable that moderately increased temperature will have an unfavourable effect on the therapeutic differential for targeted radiotherapy of neuroblastoma using radiolabelled mIBG.

Mathematical models have predicted that targeted radiotherapy of neuroblastoma with metaiodobenzylguanidine (mIBG) is less likely to cure small rather than large micrometastases if 131I is the conjugated radionuclide. This study uses multicellular tumour spheroids as an in vitro model to test the hypothesis that smaller tumours of sub-millimetre dimensions are relatively resistant to 131I-mIBG. Spheroids of the human neuroblastoma cell line SK-N-BE(2c), either 250 microns or 400 microns diameter, were incubated with 131I-mIBG at concentrations of up to 6.0 MBq ml-1. Using both regrowth delay and spheroid 'cure' as endpoints, the greater vulnerability of larger spheroids was confirmed. From this in vitro result we conclude that when used in vivo 131I-mIBG may spare smaller micrometastases. Therefore, either a radionuclide such as 211At which emits a shorter path length radiation should be conjugated to mIBG, or targeted radiotherapy should be combined with a treatment such as total body irradiation, the efficacy of which is not reduced in smaller tumours.

Human neuroblastoma cells grown as tumour spheroids were briefly incubated with a conjugate of 131I and an anti-human neuroectodermal monoclonal antibody UJ13A. Unbound 131I was removed by washing and the spheroids observed in culture conditions for up to 4 weeks. Spheroid response to irradiation was evaluated as time to reach 10x treatment volume and proportion of spheroids sterilised. Spheroid growth was found to be affected by both the activity of 131I-UJ13A and the duration of the incubation. Na[131I], 131I-HSA, 131I labelled non-specific antibody and unlabelled antibody were found to be relatively ineffective compared to 131I-UJ13A. The tumour spheroid model has applications in the evaluation of antibodies or antibody fragments and different radionuclides which may be considered for radioimmunotherapy of micrometastases.

Radioiodinated iododeoxyuridine (IUdR) is a novel, cycle-specific agent that has potential for the treatment of residual malignant glioma after surgery. As only cells in S-phase incorporate IUdR into DNA, a major limitation to this therapy is likely to be proliferative heterogeneity of the tumour cell population. Using a clonogenic end point, we have compared the toxicities of three radioiodoanalogues of IUdR--[123I]IUdR, [125I]IUdR and [131I]IUdR--to the human glioma cell line UVW, cultured as monolayers in the exponential and the plateau phase of growth and as multicellular spheroids. Monolayers treated in the exponential growth phase were most efficiently sterilized by [125I]IUdR (concentration resulting in 37% survival (C37) = 2.36 kBq ml(-1)), while [123I]IUdR and [131I]IUdR were less effective eradicators of clonogens (C37 = 9.75 and 18.9 kBq ml(-1) respectively). Plateau-phase monolayer cultures were marginally more susceptible to treatment with [123I]IUdR and [125I]IUdR (40% clonogenic survival) than [131I]IUdR (60% clonogenic survival). In cells derived from glioma spheroids, both [125I]IUdR and [123I]IUdR were again more effective than [131I]IUdR at concentrations up to and including 20 kBq ml(-1). However, the survival curve for [131I]IUdR crossed the curves for the other agents, resulting in lower survival for [131I]IUdR than [123I]IUdR and [125I]IUdR at concentrations of 40 kBq ml(-1) and higher, the clonogenic survival values at 100 kBq ml(-1) were 13%, 45% and 28% respectively. It was concluded that IUdR incorporating the Auger electron emitters 123I and 125I killed only cells that were in S-phase during the period of incubation with the radiopharmaceutical, whereas the superior toxicity to clonogenic cells in spheroids of [131I]IUdR at higher concentration was due to cross-fire beta-irradiation. These findings suggest that [131I]IUdR or combinations of [131I]IUdR and [123I]IUdR or [125I]IUdR may be more effective than Auger electron emitters alone for the treatment of residual glioma, if proliferative heterogeneity exists.