Search

The article considers the right of the press to ask book award committees about their evaluation procedure. The criteria for prize selection for the Caldecott, Newbery and Sibert awards are ambiguous; many books qualify for multiple awards. The article praises the overlap in prize nominees, saying it helps to establish quality in books.

The author focuses on a proposal intended for the Young Adult Library Services Association. The author provides an argument for an award given to young adult literature that stretches the imagination and demands an exciting orientation to new hypotheses, new ideas, and new dimensions. The article offers criteria for the award as well as implications of the inception of the award.

The author reflects upon the Newbery awards. He discusses the phrase "most distinguished" and believes the phrase is biased at best. The author ponders the impact of a Newbery award on the book and its author. Details are given for the criticism editors face from the Newbery committee if they offer their opinions in their respective magazines and journals about what book titles they would like to see win.