1. Community Builders and Campus Bureaucrats: The Challenges of Student Peer Leadership
- Author
-
Stump, James Douglas
- Abstract
Most universities provide many opportunities for students to be leaders (Planety, Hussar, Snyder, Provasnik, Kena, Dinkes, KewalRamani, & Kemp, 2008). Providing student leadership opportunities can positively influence the development of leadership qualities to serve students post-graduation (Dugan & Komives, 2007). By placing students in these positions there exists the potential to create a unique set of challenges. This research focused on the specific realities of the challenges associated with leading peers on a university campus as they exist for the participants and desired an understanding of the social and cultural context in which these challenges exist. The problem that this study addresses is, "what are the challenges undergraduate students assigned to leadership positions face when leading peers?" The two primary research questions are, "In what ways are participant student leaders able to identify and describe their experiences leading their peers, and in what ways are participant student leaders able to identify specific challenges in peer leadership?" For students who experience peer leadership firsthand, the realities of the challenges of their work are multiple and relative, and student leaders define the reality of their challenges as subjective. This was a basic field study using ethnographic techniques, collecting data through focus groups and interviews, where student leader participants discussed the experiences of leading peers. Four types of student leaders participated: Sports Team Captains, Resident Assistants, Academic Mentors and SGA Officers. The data revealed three themes: Theme One -- Construct of Peer Leadership, or "this is how I think about peer leadership"; Theme Two -- Understanding Leader Work, or "this is what I understand about doing my job as student leader"; and Theme Three -- Leader-Life Convergence, or "I am a leader but I am also a student." These themes revealed challenges student leaders faced and that student leaders thought about and functioned within their leader roles in different ways, indicating that perhaps student leaders understand the concept of peer leadership within the context of their assigned roles. Two types of student leaders emerged: Community Builders (Resident Assistants and Sports Team Captains) and Campus Bureaucrats (Academic Mentors and SGA Officers). [The dissertation citations contained here are published with the permission of ProQuest LLC. Further reproduction is prohibited without permission. Copies of dissertations may be obtained by Telephone (800) 1-800-521-0600. Web page: http://www.proquest.com/en-US/products/dissertations/individuals.shtml.]
- Published
- 2019