1. Are Exercise Interventions in Clinical Trials for Chronic Low Back Pain Dosed Appropriately to Meet the World Health Organization's Physical Activity Guidelines?
- Author
-
Gibbs, Mitchell T., Hayden, Jill A., Cashin, Aidan G., Shah, Brishna, Gilanyi, Yannick L., Natoli, Andrew, Holmes, Grant, Ogilvie, Rachel, Hagstrom, Amanda D., McAuley, James H., Marshall, Paul W., and Jones, Matthew D.
- Subjects
Exercise therapy -- Testing -- Evaluation -- Laws, regulations and rules ,Clinical trials -- Evaluation ,Low back pain -- Care and treatment ,Government regulation ,Health ,World Health Organization -- Laws, regulations and rules - Abstract
Objective. This study aimed to estimate the proportion of exercise interventions tested in clinical trials of people with chronic low back pain (CLBP) that meet the World Health Organization's (WHO) physical activity guidelines. Methods. A secondary analysis of the 2021 Cochrane review of exercise therapy for CLBP was performed. Data from each study were extracted by 1 reviewer and were checked by a second reviewer. Data extracted related to the frequency, duration and intensity of each exercise intervention, and the proportion of exercise interventions that met the WHO's physical activity guidelines (aerobic, muscle strengthening, or both) were determined. Results. The 249 included trials comprised 426 exercise interventions. Few interventions reported an exercise type and dose consistent with the WHO guidelines (aerobic: 1.6%, muscle strengthening: 5.6%, both: 1.6%). Poor reporting of exercise intensity limited our ability to determine whether interventions met the guidelines. Conclusion. Few interventions tested in clinical trials for people with CLBP prescribe an exercise type and dose consistent with the WHO guidelines. Therefore, they do not appear sufficiently dosed to achieve broader health outcomes. Future trials should investigate the effect of WHO guideline-recommended exercise interventions on patient-reported outcomes (pain and disability) as well as health-related outcomes in people with CLBP Impact. This exploratory analysis showed the lack of exercise interventions in the CLBP literature that meet the WHO's physical activity guidelines. With people in chronic pain groups, such as people with CLBP, being at higher risk for noncommunicable disease, it appears this is a key consideration for exercise practitioners when designing interventions for people with CLBP. Keywords: Aerobic, Exercise, Chronic Low Back Pain, Exercise, Physical Activity, Strengthening Exercise, Introduction Exercise is an effective guideline-based treatment for chronic low back pain (CLBP), (1) achieving similar effects on pain and disability compared to other conservative interventions. (2-4) A common justification [...]
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF