Search

This study evaluated the precipitation forecast produced by the operational China Meteorological Administration Mesoscale model (CMA‐MESO) during the "super violent" Meiyu season of 2020. Generally, CMA‐MESO, which runs with ∼3‐km‐grid resolution, is able to reproduce the distribution and diurnal variation of precipitation. However, the precipitation amount is greatly overestimated, especially in eastern coastal areas of China. Precipitation in that region usually occurs with two peaks: one in the morning that mostly reflects organized precipitation systems, and the other in the afternoon generated mostly by local convection. Analyses showed that overestimation of low‐level wind speed is the main reason for the overestimation of precipitation. CMA‐MESO produces low‐level winds that are overly strong, which greatly enhance the predicted convergence at night, leading to overestimation of precipitation. Additionally, the stronger wind speed increases the estimated transport of water vapor to the eastern coastal area, producing fake convection near the coastal mountains as the perturbed wind direction turns toward the mountain area in the afternoon. In comparison with ERA5, CMA‐MESO tends to overestimate (underestimate) the temperature in the northwest (southeast), and the larger temperature gradient increases the pressure gradient, resulting in the stronger low‐level wind speed. Plain Language Summary: The resolution of the operational China Meteorological Administration Mesoscale model (CMA‐MESO) was upgraded to 3 km in 2020. However, the overall performance of the precipitation forecast has not been evaluated comprehensively, and the main factors causing precipitation forecast biases are not well understood. This study analyzed the CMA‐MESO precipitation forecasts during the 2020 super Meiyu season. Generally, CMA‐MESO well reproduced the distribution and propagation of precipitation, but the intensity was overestimated, especially in eastern coastal areas of China. CMA‐MESO tended to produce an overly strong southwesterly low‐level wind that transported too much warm moist air to eastern coastal areas, resulting in excessive rainfall. Further comparative evaluation suggested that the overestimation of low‐level winds might be related to the larger NW–SE temperature gradient of CMA‐MESO. The findings of the current study could provide guidance for improving physical parameterization in the future. Key Points: Performance of the operational CMA‐MESO in China at convection‐permitting resolution was evaluatedCMA‐MESO can well reproduce the distribution and propagation of precipitation, but overestimates precipitation in eastern coastal areasOverestimation of low‐level wind speed is the main reason for the overestimation of precipitation in eastern coastal areas [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

With the development of refined numerical forecasts, problems such as score distortion due to the division of precipitation thresholds in both traditional and improved scoring methods for precipitation forecasts and the increasing subjective risk arising from the scale setting of the neighborhood spatial verification method have become increasingly prominent. To address these issues, a general comprehensive evaluation method (GCEM) is developed for cross-scale precipitation forecasts by directly analyzing the proximity of precipitation forecasts and observations in this study. In addition to the core indicator of the precipitation accuracy score (PAS), the GCEM system also includes score indices for insufficient precipitation forecasts, excessive precipitation forecasts, precipitation forecast biases, and clear/rainy forecasts. The PAS does not distinguish the magnitude of precipitation and does not delimit the area of influence; it constitutes a fair scoring formula with objective performance and can be suitable for evaluating rainfall events such as general and extreme precipitation. The PAS can be used to calculate the accuracy of numerical models or quantitative precipitation forecasts, enabling the quantitative evaluation of the comprehensive capability of various refined precipitation forecasting products. Based on the GCEM, comparative experiments between the PAS and threat score (TS) are conducted for two typical precipitation weather processes. The results show that relative to the TS, the PAS better aligns with subjective expectations, indicating that the PAS is more reasonable than the TS. In the case of an extreme-precipitation event in Henan, China, two high-resolution models were evaluated using the PAS, TS, and fraction skill score (FSS), verifying the evaluation ability of PAS scoring for predicting extreme-precipitation events. In addition, other indices of the GCEM are utilized to analyze the range and extent of both insufficient and excessive forecasts of precipitation, as well as the precipitation forecasting ability for different weather processes. These indices not only provide overall scores similar to those of the TS for individual cases but also support two-dimensional score distribution plots which can comprehensively reflect the performance and characteristics of precipitation forecasts. Both theoretical and practical applications demonstrate that the GCEM exhibits distinct advantages and potential promotion and application value compared to the various mainstream precipitation forecast verification methods. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

With the development of refined numerical forecasts, the problems such as the score distortion due to the division of precipitation thresholds in both traditional and improved scoring methods for precipitation forecast and the increasing subjective risk arisen from the scale setting of the neighbourhood spatial verification method have become increasingly prominent. To solve this issue, a general comprehensive evaluation method (GCEM) has been developed for cross-scale precipitation forecasts by directly analysing the proximity of precipitation forecasts and observations in this study. In addition to the core element of the precipitation forecast accuracy score (PAS) index, the GCEM system also includes score indices for insufficient precipitation forecasts, excessive precipitation forecasts, precipitation forecast biases and clear/rainy forecasts. The PAS does not distinguish the magnitude of precipitation and delimit the area of influence, it constitutes a fair scoring formula with objective performance and can be suitable for evaluating the rainfall events such as general and extreme precipitation. The PAS can be used to calculate the accuracy of numerical models or quantitative precipitation forecasts, enabling the quantitative evaluation of the comprehensive capability of various refined precipitation forecasting products. Based on the GCEM, comparative experiments between the PAS and TS are conducted for two typical precipitation weather processes. The results show that relative to TS, the PAS aligns with subjective expectations much more, indicating that the PAS is more reasonable than the TS. In addition, other indices of the GCEM are utilized to analyse the range and extent of both insufficient and excessive forecasts of precipitation, as well as the precipitation forecast ability in two weather processes. These indices not only provide overall scores for individual cases similar to the TS but also offer two-dimensional score distribution plots, which can comprehensively reflect the performance and characteristics of precipitation forecasts. Both theoretical and practical applications demonstrate that the GCEM exhibits distinct advantages and potential promotion and application value compared to the various mainstream precipitation forecast verification methods. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The diurnal variation characteristics of precipitation in summer (June–August) during the period of 2015–2019 over the Northern Slope of the Tianshan Mountains (NSTM) was analyzed using hourly simulated data from Nanjing University's real-time forecasting system (WRF_NJU) with 4 km resolution, Automatic Weather Station (AWS) data, and the ERA5-Land data through using methods such as the Rotated Empirical Orthogonal Function (REOF) and Coefficient of Variation (CV). The results show that the diurnal variation pattern of the precipitation over the NSTM simulated by WRF_NJU aligns closely with that of the observational AWS data, and it captured spatial distribution, peak values, and the times of precipitation reasonably well. The hourly precipitation amount (PA), precipitation frequency (PF), and precipitation intensity (PI) all show characteristics of being greater in the afternoon to nighttime than from early morning to noon, and the diurnal variations of precipitation in this region are significantly influenced by altitude. The PA, PF, and PI peak over the southern edge of the Junggar Basin (JB) below 1000 m occurred at around 2200 Local Solar Time (LST). In contrast, peak PA over the mountainous regions above 3000 m occurred at around 1500 LST. Further analysis with REOF and CV indicated that the difference in diurnal variations of precipitation between the mountainous regions and the JB is most pronounced likely due to the topographical influences. The peak PA over the mountainous regions mainly occurred at around 1500 LST, while that of the JB occurred at around 0100 LST. High CV regions for PI are predominantly found over the area near the central JB and the middle Tianshan mountains, whereas high CV regions for the PF are located in the central and northern parts of Urumqi and Changji. In addition, different land surface categories exhibit distinct patterns of diurnal precipitation variation, i.e., the forests, grasslands, and water bodies exhibit their peak PA in the period from early morning to noon, while the impervious surfaces, croplands, and barren lands exhibit their peak PA in the period from afternoon to nighttime. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

We have successfully incorporated a 3‐dimensional sub‐grid terrain solar radiative effect (3D STSRE) parameterization scheme into a convection‐permitting Weather Research and Forecasting model (WRF_CPM) in this study. Impacts of 3D STSRE scheme on the ability of WRF_CPM in forecasting the precipitation in summer over the Tibetan Plateau (TP) and nearby regions with complex terrain have been systematically addressed by conducting experiments without and with the 3D STSRE scheme. Results show that the application of 3D STSRE scheme can obviously mitigate the overestimation of surface solar radiation (SSR) and rainfall over TP and nearby regions, especially over the areas with much more rugged terrain (i.e., southern TP) in the WRF_CPM without 3D STSRE scheme. Further mechanism analyses indicate that the decreased surface heating induced by the reduction of SSR reduces the intensity of the thermal‐low pressure over the TP, which leads to the diminished strength of southwesterly winds and thereafter the weaker convergence of moisture flux over the southern TP. Moreover, the weakened surface thermal forcing makes the local atmosphere more stable, suppressing the vertical water vapor transport and local convection. These effects greatly alleviate the overestimation of precipitation over the southern TP produced by the WRF_CPM without the 3D STSRE scheme. Plain Language Summary: The sub‐grid terrain solar radiative effect (STSRE) is crucial to land‐air interaction, especially over the regions with complicated terrain, such as the Tibetan Plateau (TP). While the plane‐parallel radiative scheme which neglects the STSRE on the surface solar radiation (SSR) is used in most current weather models. Inaccurate depiction of SSR would cause large biases in the surface temperature and precipitation forecast. In this study, a newly developed 3‐dimensional (3D) STSRE scheme with solid physical processes and accurate sub‐grid terrain features is introduced into a convection‐permitting Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF_CPM) model. Results indicate that the adoption of 3D STSRE scheme can reduce the overestimation of the SSR and precipitation over the TP. Findings of this work emphasize the importance of considering the STSRE in high‐resolution weather models and provide an effective way to improve the short‐range precipitation forecast over regions with complex terrain. Key Points: A 3D sub‐grid terrain solar radiative effect scheme has been applied in the Weather Research and Forecasting model and its impact on weather forecast has been studiedThe 3‐dimensional sub‐grid terrain solar radiative effect reduces the overestimation of surface solar radiation, leading to the thermal low over the Tibetan Plateau weakenedThe weakened thermal low together with the more stable atmosphere reduces the overestimation of precipitation forecast over Tibetan Plateau [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]