Search

A conference paper about auditing and accounting is presented. It discusses the definition of critical synthesis which is an antonym for analysis and how the author will analyze research done on auditing practices and accounting. It examines other papers concerning auditing procedures and accounting methods including the one by Neil Churchill.

A reply by the authors is presented to commentary by Robert R. Sterling and William Harrison on the article "Capital Market Equilibrium, Information Production, and Selecting Accounting Techniques: Theoretical Framework and Review of Empirical Work," included within the issue. The authors' thoroughly restate and clarify their initial conceptual paradigm, asserting that Sterling and Harrison misattribute their position and research design goals.

This article presents comments in regard to the paper "The Time Series Behavior of Earnings," by William H. Beaver. The author explains that there are several weaknesses with Beaver's presentation of data because he fails to explains the significance of many points that he attempts to make. The author also explores the concept of how the release of financial data is viewed and used by public inquirers. The author commends Beaver's execution of empirical analysis throughout the course of the study and its presentation.

The article discusses stock valuation and the role of dividends. Theoretical and empirical analysis in the paper focuses on several problems including the determination of the cost of equity capital, the minimization of the cost of capital, and the maximization of the value of stock. These problems are overlapping in that they directly and indirectly concern stock valuation. When speaking of stock valuation one must also discuss the role of dividends. Dividends can influence stock value through capital structure and income splitting.

This article presents comments of the author on the paper by Ronald M. Copeland related to the income smoothing. The paper cites a number of prior attempts, by others, to empirically test for the occurrence of income smoothing by examination of financial statements and/or reports to governmental agencies. The author states that in each case, Copeland reasons that the findings were inconclusive. He explains that Copeland then embarks on his own test which appears to be a mere variation of some of the earlier studies, except for the fact that his approach uses multiple rather than single manipulative variables.

The article analyzes economist James Ohlson's paper "Analysis of the Usefulness of Accounting Data for the Portfolio Decision: A Decision-Theory Approach," in order to determine if he's making a model comparison or a model choice. Ohlson's thesis is that he used methods of comparing models, but the author demonstrates the inaccuracies in that thesis. The author tests Ohlson's findings and also considers the portfolio-choice problem and whether the findings are conditional upon the comparison of the forecasting models used.

The article reports on the debate over theories of depreciation with particular focus on the paper "The Calculation of Depreciation" by O.G. Ladelle. "The Calculation of Depreciation" paper presents the formula to calculate depreciation which includes the determination of the decrease of an asset's market value, the division of the cost by the number of years that the asset is expected to last, and the setting aside of each year a constant sum and interest will accumulate to a number that can replace it.

The article discusses the long-term credit determined through financial ratios and reports on the paper "The Determination of Long-Term Credit Standing with Financial Ratios," by James O. Horrigan. Horrigan states, in his paper, that the best variable of an independent nature in the study of default risk is one which can be scaled on a continuum which ranges from certain repayment through certain default; however, he says such a variable does not exist. The author believes an alternative measure of default risk may very well be bond yields or the risk premium on bonds.

The article reports on the predictive power of first-quarter financial reports through empirical research and discusses the paper, "The Predictive Power of First-Quarter Earnings Reports: A Replication," by David A. Green and Joel Segall. The study looks into the problem of external reporting through quarterly reports in lieu of internal reporting for interim purposes. It was found that these interim reports, meant to meet the needs of the investor, failed in doing so. Further study looked into improving the usefulness of interim reports for the purposes of managers and investors.

This article discusses the training of accountants in Scotland. A history of Scottish accountancy is presented. The Society of Accountants in Edinburgh received its Royal Charter on October 23, 1854, making it the world's first official accountancy body. The author looks at the apprenticeship system used in the training of accountants. The examination syllabus is presented. The role of the accountant has been changed drastically by the introduction of electronic computers, which allows them to bypass bookkeeping and run statistical analyses. Current and possible future developments in Scotland's accountancy training are discussed.

This article evaluates studies on accounting theory, conducted by a committee of the American Accounting Association in 1973. The most striking feature of the papers is their similarity. They are essentially two versions of the same work. Both preliminary papers consist of two principal sections: the nature of theories in the physical and social sciences; and the classes of accounting theories, as the authors are able to distinguish them. All of the papers survey pertinent works by mathematicians, philosophers and scientists, and conclude that accounting qualifies as an empirical discipline.

The article presents the author's analysis of the report "An Empirical Study of the Role of Accounting Data in Performance Evaluation," by Anthony G. Hopwood. The author questions Hopwood's claim that almost half of the persons in charge of cost centers were rated as representing nonaccounting styles. Furthermore, the author questions the validity of Hopwood using the term budget in his report. The author believes that Hopwood's paper successfully discusses operating results and budgets, and will be valuable in enabling future research on the topic.

The article reports on professional ethics in the accounting profession and discusses the paper, "Professional Responsibilities - An Empirical Suggestion," by Carl Devine. The author questions the accuracy of Devine's research which involves graduate students in a 2 problem paper exercise as he does not think this simulates the stress of job security and other influences of the accounting profession. He also has a problem with Devine's definition of responsibility and was confused as to whether its operational definition was used properly.

The article presents a commentary on the paper "A Statistical Model of Earnings Estimation," by M. N. Greenball. The author notes that the dividend model used in the dividend tests was not in the form suggested by the empirical evidence in the finance literature. He says there is very little value relating to the dividend test results. The author acknowledges that Greenball's research is useful to the extent that it suggests alternative methods of accounting in light of implications of positive models.

The article examines the flow of messages between the accounting system and other knowledge systems, in particular the information flow between the academic and applied accounting networks. The accounting knowledge system falls within the social science knowledge system and is made up of three subsystems: an academic, a management accounting, and a professional system. This paper is based on the analysis of citations in seventeen accounting journals for the period January 1968 to December 1969. Accounting lies within the social science knowledge system. In this study, the number of messages passed to accounting from the other social sciences and the number of messages passed to accounting from nonsocial science knowledge systems is recorded with a column tabulating the proportion of messages transmitted to accounting from other knowledge systems. The proportion of messages passed to accounting from the other social sciences is similar to the proportion passed to sociology and politics and is greater than the proportion of messages passed to psychology and economics.

In this article the author comments on the two methods of conducting accounting research, the search for universal relationship between accounting variables and the behavior of information researchers, and another approach which considers differences in peoples' use of information systems. The author comments on Edward J. Lusk's research paper related to the cognitive aspects of annual reports that the author claims does not successfully use either approach. According to the author, Lusk's paper is very vague about his experimental procedure, presenting data on eighty-seven randomly selected students and on thirty-four randomly selected financial analysts, not stating how the students and analysts were selected, nor why only thirty-five analysts were included.

The article comments on the paper "The Significance of Selected Accounting Procedures: A Statistical Test," by Nicholas J. Gonedes, that appears in the December 1, 1969 issue of the "Journal of Accounting Research." The author states that Gonedes sets out to test the null hypothesis that the use or nonuse of each of the selected accounting procedures has no significant effect on the measured surrogates of investors' perceived degrees of risk. He explains that Gonedes interprets the results of this test to disprove the null hypothesis.

The influence of alternative accounting procedures on the decisions of those who are assumed to be users of accounting messages is an unresolved issue of accounting. Some members of the accounting community suggest that alternative accounting procedures will elicit different decisions. Empirical analyses of the influence of alternative accounting procedures on decisions have provided neither complete support for, nor complete discreditation of, this point of view. In this paper, we presented the results of additional tests of the significance of alternative accounting procedures. The procedures which constituted the axial considerations of our test included two measurement procedures and one reporting procedure: (1) amortization of the investment credit, (2) interperiod tax allocation, and (3) the presentation of funds-flow statements in annual reports. The theoretical foundation of our methodology embraced the relationships among human action, expectations, and the informational content of accounting messages. A message is a purposefully arranged aggregation of signs. A message has informational content if it affects a communicatee's state of uncertainty with respect to the designata of a message. Given the fact that our environment is characterized by risk (or uncertainty), we stated that a message has informational content if it affects a communicatee's evaluation of the likelihood of an event's occurrence or an object's existence. With the above comments in mind, we attempted to evaluate the significance of, or the informational content associated with, alternative accounting procedures by ascertaining the effects of the tatter on the cost of equity capital (Test I). Since the cost of equity capital is, in part, a function of perceived risk, the differences (if any) in the informational content of accounting messages which are based upon different accounting procedures should be associated with differences in the cost of equity capital. In other words, we used the cost of equity capital as a surrogate of investors' perceived degrees of risk. In addition to the cost of equity capital (which embraces surrogates of investors' expectations), we utilized an at post surrogate of perceived degrees of risk, an actual rate of return, in one of our tests (Test II). The use of an actual rate of return as a tool in our inquiry was based upon the assumption that actual rates of return vary directly with perceived degrees of risk, The specific null hypothesis of our tests was: the use or nonuse of each of the selected accounting procedures has no statistically significant effect on the measured surrogates of investors' perceived degrees of risk. According to our interpretation, the results, generated by our analyses are, in general, indicative of a significant relationship between the informational content of accounting messages and the selected accounting procedures. Yet, we recognized that our results—which do not invariably discredit our null hypothesis—may support alternative interpretations. Additionally, we recognized that the results of our tests suffer from several important. deficiencies. If our interpretation of the results presented in this paper is accepted, then one should expect the use of a particular accounting procedure to affect the decisions of those who use accounting messages, ceteris paribus. Decidedly, if our interpretation is accepted, then one should agree that the accounting profession should strive to formulate explicit criteria for the purpose of evaluating alternative accounting procedures and it should utilize those procedures that are deemed to be "best," given the formulated criteria. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The article comments on the paper "The Significance of Selected Accounting Procedures: A Statistical Test," by Nicholas J. Gonedes, that appears in the December 1, 1969 issue of the "Journal of Accounting Research." The author discusses the effect of the selected accounting procedure on the measured surrogates of perceived risks by investors as well as the inference on the choice of a particular accounting procedure. The article also discusses the problem on recording the acquisition of an asset.

Empirical work inevitably forces us to consider whether and with what revisions the work should be replicated. Professor Stallman's paper suggests many intriguing extensions, but let me single out three which particularly interest me. 1. The relationship between predictive capacity and willingness to depart from fictitious market values needs to be explored. Hopefully these two criteria will not be conflicting. If so, one may be operationally easier to apply and can serve as a proxy for the other. If not, a conceptual choice must be made. 2. Any replication should attempt to avoid possible bias from the manner in which the quoted market prices are determined. Perhaps this can only be done by taking data from a real multi-industry firm rather than constructing a fictitious one. 3. Confidence has been used in only the sense of willingness to differ from others (depart from a fictitious market price). If replications ask for point estimates as well as some confidence interval (e.g., 50%) about the point estimate, the dispersion View of confidence can also be tested. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

This article presents comments of the author on the paper "The Auditing Standard of Consistency," by Fred Neumann. The author states that Neumann's paper constitutes a very thoughtful discussion of this subject and that it deserves wide reading by members of the accounting profession. The author explains that it is difficult to reach firm conclusions in this area because of the great variety of circumstances and factors that enter into decisions regarding appropriate disclosure. The article says that it is important first to view the problem of consistency in its proper perspective.

The article discusses the effects of accounting variations on decision making and the paper "An Experimental Design for Study of Effects of Accounting Variations in Decision Making" by R.E. Jensen. The statistical methodology and design used by Jensen in his research of the effects of alternative accounting reporting techniques in the selection of portfolios and their security evaluation is examined as is the data collection. The limitation of whether or not there was adequate control over the research environment and the probability level of the statistical tests is not known in Jensen's paper because he does not mention these issues.

The article reports on the history of information on goodwill valuation. Commercial use of the English term "goodwill" is reported to have begun as early as 1571. Following a paper by Francis More on goodwill read to the Chartered Accountants' Students' Society of Edinburgh in 1891 there has been an increase in information about goodwill valuation as well as accounting in general including the paper by P.D. Leake read to the Leicester Chartered Accountants' Students' Society in 1914. The treatment of goodwill in statements on subscriptions for shares in joint stock companies is a difficult problem.

The article presents an extension of earlier works discussed in "Towards a General Theory of Accounting" and "The Resolution of Some Paradoxes in Accounting." The article adopts the position that accounting is only concerned with the past and present, but presented in a way that remains relevant to the future. The article considers the question of measurement in accounting. The definition of accounting is presented and clarified. The author looks at the monetary and financial aspects associated with choice. Variables to consider regarding the act of valuation are discussed. The author also discussed the accuracy and relevance of accounting measurements.

This article presents comments of the author on the paper by Ronald M. Copeland related to the income smoothing. The author states that Copeland lists attributes of perfect smoothing devices and then states explicitly that decision of the first type, specifically those which affect the level of income for several periods to come, probably are not used for smoothing, while decisions relating to short-lived assets or liabilities are so used. He explains that in another Copeland study he generally used variables, which might well fall into the first class, thus employing, variables classified as nonsmoothing devices to identify smoothers.

The article presents a commentary on the paper "LIFO and the Diffusion of Innovation," by Ronald M. Copeland and John K. Shank. The author suggests that there is some confusion as to what is being attempted in Copeland and Shank's analysis. He explains that the authors state they are testing an alternative to the view that economic variables alone can explain the adoption of innovation and to see if the theory is really useful in explaining the adoption of accounting changes. He notes that there are significant differences in these two purposes.

The article presents a commentary on the article "An Empirical Study of the Cost of Convertible Securities," by Peter H. Knutson. The author notes that Knutson's analysis brought out the unjustifiable nature of the common stock equivalent concept in the primary earnings per share calculation. He contends that the two important earnings per share numbers are actual based on average shares outstanding, which is historical and fully diluted, which is prospective. The author agrees with Knutson's assertion that fully diluted earnings per share provides a close approximation of real earnings per share.

The article reports on the effect of the accounting period concept on management decisions with a discussion of the paper "The Accounting Period Concept and Its Effect on Management Decisions" by William J. Bruns. The report published by Bruns uses an experiment where students played a business game and demonstrated the relationship between the accounting period and management decisions. He acknowledges in his paper that using students for his experiment may have been a mistake. Also, his definition of accounting data is limited to quantitative information set forth in financial statements.

This article analyzes the treatment of the inputs of accounting. There are various ways of analyzing the accounting function and the steps taken to perform this function. One such way is based on information theory and systems theory. Information systems and environmental action systems are treated analytically as separate systems. Analysis of the literature revealed diverse uses of terms, contradictory statements about the limits of accounting inputs. This paper concludes that transactions, transformations and some types of events are generators of the environmental inputs of extant accounting.

A list of articles related to finance, accounting, and taxation that were published in several journals is presented. The articles include "Papers and Proceedings," edited by Lawrence S. Ritter, "Glossary of Financial Terms," by Stefan E. Horn, and "Licensing Abroad," by W. H. Diamond.

A reply by the author is presented to Robert S. Kaplan's commentary on the article "Capital Market Equilibrium, Information Production, and Selecting Accounting Techniques: Theoretical Framework and Review of Empirical Work," included within the issue, reasserting his initial thesis and clarifying Kaplan's criticisms.

Explicit recognition of uncertainty is one feature of much recent work in managerial accounting and, more generally, work in the areas of planning and control. This has led to an increased interest in the use of subjective probability assessments. Often overlooked, however, are the possibilities for subordinates to induce organizational suboptimization via their reported subjective probability assessments. We discussed two specific problems associated with reported subjective probability assessments: (1) dishonest assessments and (2) substantively deficient assessments. Two schemes for alleviating these problems -- the use of scoring rules and Bayesian model comparison procedures -- were then presented and discussed. The limitations and speed-of-effect of each scheme were considered, yielding some nonobvious implications. The organizational framework used throughout this paper incorporated some important features from the theory of teams. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The article analyses equilibrium prices of firms' ownership shares and how they are dependent upon assessed distribution functions of returns to those shares. These distributions are dependent on information pertaining to firms' production-investment decisions. The article considers the existing studies of accounting numbers that deal with the implications of one accounting number or one number at a time, usually the income number. The article examines the information reflected in contemporary accounting reports as determined by several or one of the accounting numbers presented in those reports. An examination of only one accounting number is likely to induce misleading inferences about the information content of contemporary accounting reports, and it has also been argued that an accounting income number is the single most important number provided in accounting reports. This paper considers both of these arguments.

The article reports on the findings of a study by James Ohlson designed to gauge the usefulness of alternative accounting data in corporate earnings statements and their possible effect on security prices. The author considers whether investors use this earnings statement information, and to what extent they might rely upon this information when investing. The objective of Ohlson's paper was to use Bayesian econometric models to evaluate the usefulness of alternative data sets in developing distributions over future security relatives, so the models' usefulness to investors could be determined.

The article presents a commentary on the paper "The Influence of Quarterly Earnings Announcements on Investor Decisions as Reflected in Common Stock Price Changes," by Robert G. May. The author recommends additional research be conducted in the area of interim reporting including contact with the readers of interim financial data to determine their viewpoints as to the reliability of the data and their use of it. He says a great deal remains to be done in the area of interim financial reporting. The author acknowledges that May's study should be useful in advancing the state of the art towards the creation of more useful financial data.

The article presents a commentary on the paper "An Empirical Test of the Relevance of Accounting Information for Investment Decisions," by Alivn Martin. The author says there is some justification in questioning the rationale for regression accounting earnings against market prices of securities. Some economists and accountants have expressed reservations about whether there should be a relationship between market price movements and present accounting earnings since accounting earnings are alleged to be irrelevant to investment decisions. The author suggests that accounting earnings are irrelevant because they are based on prior transactions and prior prices of assets.

The goal of the article is to explore the role that the decomposition approach plays in information system evaluations, while considering the evidence brought to light in G. Feltham's paper "The Value of Information." The decomposition approach has several variants in regard to sets of phenomena. One suggests that some phenomena be eliminated, another states they phenomena should be treated as one entity, and the third says that the relationships between phenomena should be simplified.The author focuses his efforts on the elimination variant.

The article comments on the paper "An Empirical Study of Accounting Methods and Stock Prices," by Francis A. Mlynarczyk, that appears in the December 1, 1969 issue of the "Journal of Accounting Research." The author state that the effect of accounting information on stock prices is an important and relevant topic and that the statistical methodology utilized is appropriate for a cross-section study. He believes that Mlynarczyk is also to be commended for attempting to see whether the magnitude of the accounting effect is in agreement with theoretical expectations.

The article focuses on the allocations in accounting. The authors discuss the implication of formulating the allocation problem under uncertainty and the use of traditional allocation schemes. The authors state that the few examples displayed in the article indicate that this bias may be significant in the sense that the objectives of the allocation scheme may not be achieved. The article also discusses the basis of the net realizable values. The authors conclude that much more exploration into the properties of allocation methods is still needed. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The article discusses the measurement of changes in price levels and comments on an analysis paper by R.L. Mathews. Mathews feels that adjustments designed to measure changes in the general price level actually acquire meaning when they are calculated through reference to data which has been valued consistently. Also, he did not think that the study he analyzed only allowed for changes in historic costs rather than those current. Mathews uses algebraic equations in order to explain and justify his positions on price levels.

The article presents a list of books and papers about finance, accounting and taxation. The books and papers include "Financial Variables in International Business," published in "Harvard Business Review," "Stock Exchange International Directory," by George W. Collins, "Capital Markets of the European Economic Community," by Antonin Basch, "Canadian Bonds and American Investors," published in the "Financial Analysts Journal," and "Europe's Stock Markets Since 1961," published in "Report on Western Europe."

The article comments on the study "Analysis of the Usefulness of Accounting Data for the Portfolio Decision: A Decision-Theory Approach," by James Ohlson in order to determine whether accounting information in corporate reports is useful to investors. The author analyzes Ohlson's experiment involving an individual risk-averse investor selecting an optimal portfolio who wants to make forecasts about stock prices, and tests the Bayesian models used. The author points out several weaknesses in Ohlson's theory involving the utility function, prior values of parameters, and the prediction formulas used.

The article comments on the paper "An Empirical Study of Accounting Methods and Stock Prices," by Francis A. Mlynarczyk, that appears in the December 1, 1969 issue of the "Journal of Accounting Research." The author states that the background material of the paper is adequately covered and Mlynarczyk's choice of industry, from the point of view of the larger question, is appropriate. He states that the model also seems quite acceptable and that the chief determinants of stock prices appear to be included among the independent variables.

This article reviews the formulation of the constrained capital budgeting problem. The article compares the merits of integer programming and continuous linear programming as methods of solving this problem. The paper discusses capital constraints and the question of an appropriate objective function. Additional constraints are presented and problems arising because of the binary nature of capital projects are discussed. Some attempts have been made to include probability considerations in mathematical programming approaches to capital budgeting.

This article examines eight conceptions of the entity concept in accounting. The entity concept relates to the identity of the matter or activity to which an accounting is to occur and the relationship assumed to exist between the entity and external parties. The paper attempts to classify different views on entity concept controversy. The aim of this paper is to document the plurality of views on the object of an accounting--the firm, the organization, the set of relationships, whatever it is that is meant by accounting entity. Different conceptions of the entity inevitably give rise to different solutions of accounting and reporting problems.

Technical information centers have been established in recent years to cope with the "information explosion" problem which confronts the scientific community. These operations are highly analogous to a typical manufacturing firm with functions such as purchasing, production, service, finance, administration, and distribution. Management of a center encounters cost information requirements similar to those found in other enterprises for planning, control, and decision-making purposes. Yet, research indicates that few tangible cost-accounting applications have been attempted in information centers. The purpose of this paper is to describe a research project conducted at a technical information center to test the hypothesis that: A theoretically-sound managerial cost-accounting system con be designed to meet the specific characteristics of a technical information center by revising and innovating systems utilized by other enterprises. A computerized cost system was developed and operated for a three-month period to test this hypothesis. The results of the study indicate that effective managerial cost accounting is possible for o technical information center. Relevant cost information was generated periodically to measure the operating performance of the center's production process. A summary of the data that were reported regularly to management is presented in this paper. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

This paper presents the characteristics of the National Accounting System of Hungary and outlines its development in the last decades and the insufficiencies still existing. Hungary has joined with great interest in the work performed within the frame of the United Nations Statistical Commission concerning the development of the Systems of National Accounts, being interested in applying—as far as possible—the results of the revision of the SNA and MPS in its national practice. The paper first presents a conceptual matrix containing all the major items in the MPS system in order to explain the contents of the items and the interdependencies among them. In this connection a brief account is given of the major differences between the SNA and MPS. The following part of the paper presents the National Accounting System introduced in Hungary in 1968. It is put also within the framework of a matrix, which supplies the items of both the SNA and MPS by means of simple aggregation as well as satisfying the national requirements, so that it is possible to compare the structure and development of the Hungarian economy with those of any other countries. The major differences between the Hungarian system and the current MPS and the revised SNA are then presented. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

This note comments on an article by James A. Knoblett which presented an interesting application of the Bayesian decision model to auditing, published in the second issue of the periodical "Decision Sciences." Questions which arise when studying Knoblett's paper are discussed. It is noted that Knoblett appears to have placed too many restrictions upon the auditor in the problem. The author concludes by implying that Knoblett has not recognized that an assessed probability distribution should incorporate all relevant information available to the assessor regarding the likelihoods of occurrence for possible values of the state variable.

The article reports on the results of research designed to determine an informativeness ranking among positive, negative, and blank forms in accounting. In expressing an opinion on financial statements, independent auditors conduct inspections, observations and confirmations. Confirmations utilize positive, negative, and blank forms, and constitute alternative information systems. Each form represents a system which generates messages indicating the respondent's opinion as to the correctness or incorrectness of individual accounts. This ranking was based on the statistical concept of sufficiency. The results of the study suggest that negative confirmations are least informative and that positive and blank confirmations are equally informative.

The article analyses the reliability of using the old method of estimating the means and variances of the past distributions of sales demands with the cost-volume-product (CVP) model. The undesirable feature of this CVP analysis was the assumption that demand, price, and variable and fixed expenses were known with certainty. The concept of uncertainty was introduced into this equation by Harold Bierman and Robert K. Jaedicke and Alexander A. Robichek. The assumption in both models was that sales volume followed a normal distribution, but Jaedicke and Robichek extended the analysis by stating that price and variable expenses were random variables with normal distributions. More recently, Glenn L. Johnson and S. Stephen Simik introduced correlations between product demands in a multiproduct situation, while assuming constant prices and expenses.