1. Management of HIV infected health care workers: lessons from three cases
- Author
-
Laurence Gruer, David S. Goldberg, Jill P. Pell, and Peter Christie
- Subjects
Counseling ,Male ,Pediatrics ,medicine.medical_specialty ,education ,Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) ,HIV Infections ,Disclosure ,medicine.disease_cause ,Infectious Disease Transmission, Professional-to-Patient ,Acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) ,Risk Factors ,Hotlines ,Hiv infected ,Health care ,Medical Staff, Hospital ,medicine ,Humans ,Institutional Management Teams ,Risk factor ,General Environmental Science ,Risk Management ,Transmission (medicine) ,business.industry ,General Engineering ,General Medicine ,medicine.disease ,Scotland ,Duty of confidentiality ,Family medicine ,Duty to protect ,General Earth and Planetary Sciences ,Contact Tracing ,business ,Confidentiality ,Hospital-Patient Relations ,Research Article - Abstract
Three cases in which doctors in Glasgow were diagnosed as having HIV infection were all handled differently in relation to telling patients and the media. In the first patients were not told because the doctor had been doing administrative work and there was thought to be no risk to patients; although the media did report the case, it accepted the assurances given. In the second case, where a doctor had done many jobs in different specialities and places, the media identified the doctor before most patients had been informed: most calls to the helpline subsequently set up by the health authority were from patients who had not been treated by this doctor. This episode, however, allowed the incident team to be prepared for the next case, enabling the helpline to be established swiftly. In this case the doctor voluntarily identified himself, and this served to allay public fears and reduce the number of inappropriate calls to the helpline. The risk of transmission of HIV from an infected health care worker to a patient lies between 1 in 4000 and 1 in 40000.1 HIV antibody tests have been performed on more than 22000 patients treated by infected health care workers.2 3 Although more than 100 patients tested positive, in only one incident was the health care worker, a dentist, implicated as the possible source of infection.2 3 The United Kingdom guidelines on the management of HIV infected health care workers encompass three main principles: a duty to protect patients, a duty of confidentiality towards infected health care workers, and the concept that the risk of HIV transmission is restricted to certain “exposure prone” procedures from which infected staff should refrain (see box).4 5 There have been three recent incidents in Scotland involving HIV infected doctors, all in …
- Published
- 1996
- Full Text
- View/download PDF