Search

Determining the mechanisms by which genes are switched on and off during development and differentiation is a key aim of current biomedical research. Gene transcription has been widely observed to occur in a discontinuous fashion, with short bursts of activity interspersed with longer periods of inactivity. It is currently not known if or how this dynamic behaviour changes as mammalian cells differentiate. To investigate this, using a newly developed on-microscope analysis, we monitored mouse α-globin transcription in live cells throughout sequential stages of erythropoiesis. We find that changes in the overall levels of α-globin transcription are most closely associated with changes in the fraction of time a gene spends in the active transcriptional state. We identify differences in the patterns of transcriptional bursting throughout differentiation, with maximal transcriptional activity occurring in the mid-phase of differentiation. Early in differentiation, we observe increased fluctuation in the patterns of transcriptional activity whereas at the peak of gene expression, in early and intermediate erythroblasts, transcription appears to be relatively stable and efficient. Later during differentiation as α-globin expression declines, we again observed more variability in transcription within individual cells. We propose that the observed changes in transcriptional behaviour may reflect changes in the stability of enhancer-promoter interactions and the formation of active transcriptional compartments as gene expression is turned on and subsequently declines at sequential stages of differentiation.

Mammalian genomes are subdivided into large (50-2000 kb) regions of chromatin referred to as Topologically Associating Domains (TADs or sub-TADs). Chromatin within an individual TAD contacts itself more frequently than with regions in surrounding TADs thereby directing enhancer-promoter interactions. In many cases, the borders of TADs are defined by convergently orientated boundary elements associated with CCCTC-binding factor (CTCF), which stabilises the cohesin complex on chromatin and prevents its translocation. This delimits chromatin loop extrusion which is thought to underlie the formation of TADs. However, not all CTCF-bound sites act as boundaries and, importantly, not all TADs are flanked by convergent CTCF sites. Here, we examined the CTCF binding sites within a ∼70 kb sub-TAD containing the duplicated mouse α-like globin genes and their five enhancers (5’-R1-R2-R3-Rm-R4-α1-α2-3’). The 5’ border of this sub-TAD is defined by a pair of CTCF sites. Surprisingly, we show that deletion of the CTCF binding sites within and downstream of the α-globin locus leaves the sub-TAD largely intact. The predominant 3’ border of the sub-TAD is defined by a steep reduction in contacts: this corresponds to the transcribed α2-globin gene rather than the CTCF sites at the 3’-end of the sub-TAD. Of interest, the almost identical α1- and α2-globin genes interact differently with the enhancers, resulting in preferential expression of the proximal α1-globin gene which behaves as a partial boundary between the enhancers and the distal α2-globin gene. Together, these observations provide direct evidence that actively transcribed genes can behave as boundary elements.Significance StatementMammalian genomes are complex, organised 3D structures, partitioned into Topologically Associating Domains (TADs): chromatin regions that preferentially self-interact. These chromatin interactions are thought to be driven by a mechanism that continuously extrudes chromatin loops, forming structures delimited by chromatin boundary elements and reflecting the activity of enhancers and promoters. Boundary elements bind architectural proteins such as CCCTC-binding factor (CTCF). Previously, an overlap between the functional roles of enhancers and promoters has been shown. However, whether there is overlap between enhancers/promoters and boundary elements is not known. Here, we show that actively transcribed genes can also behave as boundary elements, similar to CTCF boundaries. In both cases, multi-protein complexes bound to these regions may stall the process of chromatin loop extrusion.

We employ and extensively characterise an ex vivo culture system to study terminal erythroid maturation of CD34+ progenitors from the peripheral blood of normal individuals and patients with Congenital Dyserythropoietic Anaemia type 1 (CDA-I). Using morphological analysis, FACS analysis and the proteomic approach CyTOF, we analysed patient-derived erythroblasts stage-matched with those from healthy donors during the expansion phase and into early differentiation. In patient cells, aspects of disordered erythropoiesis manifest midway through differentiation, including increased proliferation and changes in the DNA accessibility profile. We also show that cultured erythroblasts from CDA-I patients recapitulate the pathognomic feature of this erythroid disorder with up to 40% of the cells having abnormal ‘spongy’ chromatin morphology by electron microscopy, as well as upregulation of GDF15, a marker of ineffective erythropoiesis. In the tertiary phase of culture, patient cells show significantly less enucleation and there is persistence of earlier erythroid precursors. Furthermore, the enucleation defect appears to be more severe in patients with mutations in C15orf41, as compared to the other known causative gene CDAN1, indicating a genotype/phenotype correlation in CDA-I. Such erythroblasts are a valuable resource for investigating the pathogenesis of this disease and provide the opportunity for streamlining diagnosis for CDA-I patients and ultimately other forms of unexplained anaemia.