1. Analytical solution versus the Monte Carlo simulation for studying the H+ beam neutralization in H2 gas target neutralizer.
- Author
-
Masoumzadeh, Amin, Habibi, Morteza, and Mirzaei, Hamid Reza
- Subjects
- *
ANALYTICAL solutions , *CHARGE exchange reactions , *ELECTRON impact ionization , *STATISTICAL errors , *MONTE Carlo method , *GASES - Abstract
A comparative Study on the conversion of an energetic H+ beam inside a cell neutralizer filled with hydrogen gas target is conducted by two different methods to determine the maximum beam neutralization efficiency and corresponding optimal gas thickness in terms of beam energy, ranging from 1 keV to 10 MeV. One method analytically solves the equations of particle flux with a deterministic response. The other uses the random collisional probability based on the Monte Carlo simulation with non-deterministic response, which is implemented by COMSOL software. Effective reactions of charge exchange and reionization are commonly considered in both methods with the energy-depended collisional cross section. The results obtained from the two methods are compared, demonstrating good fitness with a mean difference of ±1.5 %. This acceptive difference arises often due to statistical errors that occur in the Monte Carlo calculations. Additionally, a close agreement is found between calculated and measured efficiencies. [Display omitted] • The Monte Carlo simulation agrees with the analytical solution and experiment. • The hydrogen neutralization is influenced by beam energy and gas target thickness. • Increasing the density increases the rate of neutralization, not its maximum value. • Collisional cross section of hydrogen considerably affects the calculational results. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF