1. The bell-clapper deformity of the testis: The definitive pathological anatomy
- Author
-
Charlotte Dumble, Kiarash Taghavi, John M. Hutson, S. Ali Mirjalili, and Imran Mushtaq
- Subjects
Male ,medicine.medical_specialty ,medicine.medical_treatment ,Autopsy ,Spermatic cord ,03 medical and health sciences ,0302 clinical medicine ,030225 pediatrics ,Cryptorchidism ,Deformity ,Humans ,Medicine ,Testicular torsion ,Spermatic Cord Torsion ,Orchiopexy ,Pathological ,Gonadal Dysgenesis, 46,XY ,Spermatic Cord ,business.industry ,Tunica vaginalis ,General Medicine ,medicine.disease ,medicine.anatomical_structure ,030220 oncology & carcinogenesis ,Pediatrics, Perinatology and Child Health ,Surgery ,Radiology ,medicine.symptom ,business - Abstract
Introduction The bell-clapper deformity (BCD) predisposes to intravaginal torsion (IVT) and is classically bilateral. The precise pathological definition of what constitutes a BCD is not clear. The current study aims to clarify the specific anatomic details of this anomaly. Methods A systematic review was performed utilizing the PRISMA principles. Studies are presented chronologically based on their level of evidence. They are further divided into study types: autopsy and operative studies of acute torsion, intermittent torsion and studies of the contralateral testis in vanishing testis. Results The bell-clapper deformity is best defined by complete investment of the testis, epididymis and a length of the spermatic cord by the tunica vaginalis. Based on autopsy studies the rate of BCD in scrotal testis varied from 4.9% to 16%; with bilaterality in 66%–100%. In cases of acute IVT bilaterality was noted in 54%–100%. The most disparate results were in cases of testicular regression syndrome where contralateral BCD was noted in 0%–87% of cases. Conclusion We suggest future studies employ the strict anatomical definition above. As there is evidence of age-dependent investment of the testes, it will be important to develop age-standardized measurements of intravaginal length of spermatic cord. This critical morphometric measurement will allow a better understanding of the risk of IVT. Level of evidence Systematic review of diagnostic studies: lowest level of evidence of included manuscripts Level IV (case–control studies with a poor reference standard).
- Published
- 2021