1. Not 'either-or' but 'which-when': A review of the evidence for integration in sensory preconditioning
- Author
-
Youcef Bouchekioua, R. Fred Westbrook, Francesca S. Wong, and Nathan M. Holmes
- Subjects
Sensory preconditioning ,0303 health sciences ,Process (engineering) ,Computer science ,Event (computing) ,Cognitive Neuroscience ,Information processing ,Novelty ,Context (language use) ,Rats ,Mice ,03 medical and health sciences ,Behavioral Neuroscience ,0302 clinical medicine ,Neuropsychology and Physiological Psychology ,Conditioning, Psychological ,Chaining ,Memory formation ,Animals ,Rabbits ,Neuroscience ,030217 neurology & neurosurgery ,030304 developmental biology - Abstract
Sensory preconditioning protocols can be used to assess how the brain integrates memories that share common features. In these protocols, animals are first exposed to pairings of two relatively innocuous stimuli, S2 and S1 (stage 1), and then to pairings of one of these stimuli, S1, with an event of motivational significance (stage 2). Following this training, test presentations of S2 elicit responses appropriate to the motivationally significant event, and these responses are taken to indicate formation of distinct S2-S1 and S1-event memories that are integrated in some way to generate that responding. This paper reviews studies of sensory preconditioning in rats, mice, rabbits and people to determine whether S2-S1 and S1-event memories are integrated through a chaining process at the time of their retrieval (i.e., test presentations of S2 trigger retrieval of S1, and thereby, responses appropriate to the event); or “online” at the time of memory formation (i.e., in stage 2, S1 activates a representation of S2 such that both stimuli associate with the motivationally significant event). It finds that the type of integration is determined by the manner in which stimuli are presented in preconditioning as well as their familiarity. When the stimuli in preconditioning are presented repeatedly and/or serially (i.e., one after the other), the S2-S1 and S1-event memories are chained at the time of retrieval/testing. In contrast, when the stimuli in preconditioning are relatively novel and/or presented simultaneously, the S2-S1 and S1-event memories are integrated online. These statements are related to prior claims regarding the circumstances that promote different types of memory integration and, more generally, mechanisms of information processing in the mammalian brain.
- Published
- 2022