1. Is a scaling factor required to obtain closure between measured and modelled atmospheric O4 absorptions? An assessment of uncertainties of measurements and radiative transfer simulations for 2 selected days during the MAD-CAT campaign
- Author
-
European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts, SCOAP, Wagner, T., Beirle, S., Benavent, Nuria, Bösch, T., Lok Chan, K., Donner, Sebastian, Dörner, Steffen, Fayt, Caroline, Frieß, Udo, García-Nieto, D., Gielen, C., González-Bartolome, D., Gomez, L., Hendrick, F., Henzing, B., Li Jin, J., Lampel, J., Ma, J., Mies, K., Navarro, M., Peters, E., Pinardi, G., Puentedura, O., Pukite, J., Remmers, J., Richter, A., Saiz-Lopez, A., Shaiganfar, R., Sihler, H., Van Roozendael, M., Wang, Y., Yela, M., European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts, SCOAP, Wagner, T., Beirle, S., Benavent, Nuria, Bösch, T., Lok Chan, K., Donner, Sebastian, Dörner, Steffen, Fayt, Caroline, Frieß, Udo, García-Nieto, D., Gielen, C., González-Bartolome, D., Gomez, L., Hendrick, F., Henzing, B., Li Jin, J., Lampel, J., Ma, J., Mies, K., Navarro, M., Peters, E., Pinardi, G., Puentedura, O., Pukite, J., Remmers, J., Richter, A., Saiz-Lopez, A., Shaiganfar, R., Sihler, H., Van Roozendael, M., Wang, Y., and Yela, M.
- Abstract
In this study the consistency between MAX-DOAS measurements and radiative transfer simulations of the atmospheric O absorption is investigated on 2 mainly cloud-free days during the MAD-CAT campaign in Mainz, Germany, in summer 2013. In recent years several studies indicated that measurements and radiative transfer simulations of the atmospheric O absorption can only be brought into agreement if a so-called scaling factor (<1) is applied to the measured O absorption. However, many studies, including those based on direct sunlight measurements, came to the opposite conclusion, that there is no need for a scaling factor. Up to now, there is no broad consensus for an explanation of the observed discrepancies between measurements and simulations. Previous studies inferred the need for a scaling factor from the comparison of the aerosol optical depths derived from MAX-DOAS O measurements with that derived from coincident sun photometer measurements. In this study a different approach is chosen: the measured O absorption at 360nm is directly compared to the O absorption obtained from radiative transfer simulations. The atmospheric conditions used as input for the radiative transfer simulations were taken from independent data sets, in particular from sun photometer and ceilometer measurements at the measurement site. This study has three main goals: first all relevant error sources of the spectral analysis, the radiative transfer simulations and the extraction of the input parameters used for the radiative transfer simulations are quantified. One important result obtained from the analysis of synthetic spectra is that the O absorptions derived from the spectral analysis agree within 1% with the corresponding radiative transfer simulations at 360nm. Based on the results from sensitivity studies, recommendations for optimised settings for the spectral analysis and radiative transfer simulations are given. Second, the measured and simulated results are compared for 2 selecte
- Published
- 2019