1. Political Regimes, Democratic Institutions and Environmental Sustainability: A Cross-national analysis.
- Author
-
Scruggs, Lyle
- Subjects
- *
ENVIRONMENTAL policy , *DEMOCRACY , *SUSTAINABLE development , *ECONOMIC development & the environment , *POLITICAL science - Abstract
In the last several years political scientists and environmental economists have started to investigate the cross-national differences in environmental policy performance and its political causes. To date, the most sustained attention in empirical studies has concentrated on differences in environmental policy between democracies and non-democracies. These studies are subject to three criticisms. First, these studies do an inadequate job of conceptualizing and measuring âenvironmental policy performance.â For example, almost all existing studies focus on only one or two environmental problemsâ"sulfur dioxide pollution deforestation, access to safe drinking water, lead content on gasolineâ"and fail to ask whether such pollutants are ârepresentativeâ of environmental performance more broadly. Second, the empirical results of many of these papers raise a number of basic methodological problems that seems to impugn their empirical results. Finally, these studies tell us little about whether different types of democratic institutionsâ"electoral laws, constitutional separation of powers, and so forthâ"affect environmental performance differently between countries and over time. Our paper, which develops a cross-national dataset of developed and developing countries, provides advances on all three of these fronts. First, we provide a systematic evaluation of national performance measures. We critically evaluate previous work and develop a multi-dimensional measure that should provide a more accurate indication of national environmental performance. Second, we evaluate the statistical robustness of previous findings and their substantive significance. Finally, we take evaluate recent theoretical findings (e.g., Perrson and Tabeliniâs work) which suggest that different democratic rules tend to produce very different environmental policy performance. ..PAT.-Unpublished Manuscript [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2008