Here we report a new plasmid shuffle vector for forcing budding yeast ( Saccharomyces cerevisiae ) to incorporate a new genetic pathway in place of a native pathway - even an essential one - while maintaining low false positive rates (less than 1 in 10 8 per cell). This plasmid, dubbed "Superloser," was designed with reduced sequence similarity to commonly used yeast plasmids ( i.e. , pRS400 series) to limit recombination, a process that in our experience leads to retention of the yeast gene(s) instead of the desired gene(s). In addition, Superloser utilizes two orthogonal copies of the counter-selectable marker URA3 to reduce spontaneous 5-fluoroorotic acid resistance. Finally, the CEN/ARS sequence is fused to the GAL1-10 promoter, which disrupts plasmid segregation in the presence of the sugar galactose, causing Superloser to rapidly be removed from a population of cells. We show one proof-of-concept shuffling experiment: swapping yeast's core histones out for their human counterparts. Superloser is especially useful for forcing yeast to use highly unfavorable genes, such as human histones, as it enables plating a large number of cells (1.4x10 9 ) on a single 10 cm petri dish while maintaining a very low background. Therefore, Superloser is a useful tool for yeast geneticists to effectively shuffle low viability genes and/or pathways in yeast that may arise in as few as 1 in 10 8 cells., (Copyright © 2019 Haase et al.)