Search

Research objective: Reliable and unambiguously defined performance indicators are fundamental to objective and comparable measurements of hospitals' quality of care. In two separate case studies (intensive care and breast cancer care), we investigated if differences in definition interpretation of performance indicators affected the indicator scores. Design: Information about possible definition interpretations was obtained by a short telephone survey and a Web survey. We quantified the interpretation differences using a patient-level dataset from a national clinical registry (Case I) and a hospital's local database (Case II). In Case II, there was additional textual information available about the patients' status, which was reviewed to get more insight into the origin of the differences. Participants: For Case I, we investigated 15 596 admissions of 33 intensive care units in 2009. Case II consisted of 144 admitted patients with a breast tumour surgically treated in one hospital in 2009. Results: In both cases, hospitals reported different interpretations of the indicators, which lead to significant differences in the indicator values. Case II revealed that these differences could be explained by patient-related factors such as severe comorbidity and patients' individual preference in surgery date. Conclusions: With this article, we hope to increase the awareness on pitfalls regarding the indicator definitions and the quality of the underlying data. To enable objective and comparable measurements of hospitals' quality of care, organizations that request performance information should formalize the indicators they use, including standardization of all data elements of which the indicator is composed (procedures, diagnoses).

IntroductionLocalization studies are mandatory prior to revision surgery in patients with persistent hyperparathyroidism in order to improve surgical outcome and reduce the risk of lengthy explorations. However, in this case, noninvasive localization studies are reported to have a poor sensitivity. The aim of our study is to determine the accuracy of selective venous sampling (SVS) for parathyroid hormone (PTH) in localizing residual hyperactive parathyroid glands in patients with persistent or recurrent hyperparathyroidism.Patients and methodsWe retrospectively evaluated the localizing accuracy of 20 PTH SVS performed prior to revision surgery in 18 patients with persistent or recurrent primary hyperparathyroidism (n=11) or autonomous (tertiary) hyperparathyroidism (n=7). Tc99m-methoxy-isobutyle-isonitrile (MIBI)-single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) was also performed in all patients prior to revision surgery. Operative and pathological data were obtained from hospital records.ResultsThe SVS was able to accurately localize 15 of the 20 pathological glands removed at revision surgery, representing a sensitivity of 75%. This sensitivity is significantly higher than that of Tc99m-MIBI-SPECT, which was only 30% (P=0.012).ConclusionOur findings demonstrate that SVS is a valuable localization study in patients with persistent or recurrent hyperparathyroidism, with a sensitivity significantly higher than that of Tc99m-MIBI-SPECT. Our data suggest that SVS represents a useful addition to the preoperative workup of these patients prior to revision surgery.

ObjectiveAdrenal cortical carcinoma (ACC) is an aggressive tumour with a high mortality. We describe six patients living 12–28 years despite recurrent and/or metastatic ACC.PatientsThe first patient presented in 1979 with an ACC of 8 cm. After resection, she developed seven recurrences for which she was treated with resection and/or mitotane (o,p′-DDD) treatment. The patient is still alive 28 years after diagnosis. The second patient presented with an ACC of 9 cm. After resection, the patient developed liver metastases, which were treated witho,p′-DDD. The patient is still alive 25 years after diagnosis. The third patient presented with an ACC of 12 cm. The tumour was resected followed byo,p′-DDD treatment. She had a local recurrence that was completely resected. She is still alive 18 years after diagnosis. The fourth patient presented with an ACC of 14 cm. After resection, adjuvanto,p′-DDD was started. Subsequently, the patient developed two recurrences, which were resected. He is still alive 17 years after the initial diagnosis. The fifth patient presented with an ACC of 10 cm. After diagnosis, she developed lung metastasis, which were treated witho,p′-DDD and chemotherapy. The patient is still alive with slowly progressive disease 12 years after diagnosis. The sixth patient presented with an ACC of 7 cm. After resection, she developed four recurrences, which were resected. The patient is still alive 28 years after diagnosis.ConclusionSome patients can have an extremely long survival of ACC, despite recurrent disease and metastases. The mainstay of therapy in our patients was repeated surgery ando,p′-DDD.

To assess the impact of variables related to setting, study design and definition on adverse outcome occurrence and mortality in hospitalized patients.Pubmed and Embase.Articles in English from 1980 onwards, in non-selected patients or surgical patients only.Data were extracted independently by two authors using a predefined form. Included study methodology variables were general variables such as setting, patient variables like age, study variables like number of reviewers and definition and the resulting adverse outcome occurrence and mortality.Eleven studies reporting on 76 617 non-selected patients and 18 studies representing 136 292 surgical patients were included. Adverse outcomes were estimated to occur in 16% (12-19%) of non-selected patients and in 18% (14-22%) of surgical patients, taking into account the heterogeneity between studies. The study methodology variables were not statistically significant in explaining variation in adverse outcome occurrence, but the individual studies, when used as a random effect variable, were significant. Conversely, the study variable was not significant to explain variation in mortality rates, whereas the study methodology variables were: having more than one reviewer increased mortality by 30-80%, older study populations resulted in higher mortality and including a cause in the definition halved the mortality rate.Study methodology variables do not explain differences in adverse outcome occurrence between studies. Other inter-study differences are more important. However, study methodology is an important predictor for mortality differences and should be taken into account when interpreting differences between studies.

To find out which procedure was the safest for each indication for operation in diseases of the thyroid gland.Retrospective study.Two teaching hospitals, The Netherlands.599 consecutive patients who had 601 thyroid operations between 1 October 1985 and 1 June 1993.Incidence of complications, particularly postoperative hypocalcaemia and injuries to the recurrent laryngeal nerve.Accidental injuries to the recurrent laryngeal nerve occurred in 0.7% of the nerves at risk (7/948) and the incidence of permanent hypocalcaemia was 5.2% (31/599). In subtotal procedures (bilateral subtotal thyroidectomy with the remnant left dorsally or total hemithyroidectomy combined with subtotal hemithyroidectomy on the other side with a remnant left at the upper pole) the rate was 11/390 (2.8%) compared with 18/525 (3.4%) after total resections. The corresponding numbers of accidental injuries to the recurrent laryngeal nerve were 2 and 4.Total thyroidectomies are more likely to be done for malignant disease, so the slightly higher complication rates probably reflect the nature of the disease, which requires more radical resection. Both subtotal procedures can be done with comparable low morbidity.

To ascertain whether women who consulted their GP because they perceived themselves as at increased risk of familial breast cancer were indeed at increased risk, and to evaluate potential strategies for assessing genetic risk of breast cancer in general practice.Sixty-seven out of 81 women who had consulted their GP for advice about their possible increased risk of developing breast cancer due to breast cancer in the family were interviewed. Familial breast cancer risk was assessed by a clinical geneticist. This assessment was compared with two recent guidelines for referral for genetic counselling.More than half (52%; n = 35) the women had a relative risk of two and over for developing breast cancer, while another half of these 35 (25%; n = 17) had a relative risk of three and over. All the women (n = 17) with a relative risk of three and over were identified by means of the two current guidelines for referral for genetic counselling, while more than half of the women (61%; n = 11) with a relative risk between two and three were identified.More than half the women concerned about their familial risk of breast cancer are indeed at increased risk of breast cancer. Current guidelines correctly identify women at high risk. However, doubts about the health gain and feasibility of referral warrant caution, and need further investigation.

A 51-year-old Caucasian man with multiple endocrine neoplasia (MEN) type I syndrome presented with clinical features of acromegaly. Exploration of the pituitary gland only revealed somatotrophic hyperplasia and his plasma growth hormone (GH) levels remained elevated. Production of growth hormone-releasing hormone (GHRH) by an ectopic tumor was suspected and, after additional investigations, a large pancreatic tumor was detected and removed. As the pancreatic tail contained multiple (occult) adenomas, lifelong follow-up was considered necessary. The patient has been recurrence-free for 10 years. All 19 living relatives of this patient were analysed for endocrine disorders related to MEN I syndrome. A brother was found to suffer from peptic ulcer disease caused by hyperparathyroidism and, during screening for other organ involvement associated with the MEN I syndrome, two tumors were found, one (4 cm) in the pancreatic tail region and one in the right adrenal gland. To date, six other family members have been found to suffer or have suffered from hyperparathyroidism and in a male subject, a prolactinoma and hyperparathyroidism were detected.