Search

The question of how alterations in cell behavior produced by retinoic acid (RA) influenced the development of skeletogenic mesenchyme of the limb bud was examined in this study. Our established model was employed, which involves treatment of pregnant mice with a teratogenic dose of RA (100 mg/kg) on 11 days postcoitum (dpc) resulting in a severe truncation of all long bones of the forelimbs in virtually every exposed fetus. It is shown that RA, administered at a stage to induce phocomelia in virtually all exposed embryos, resulted in immediate appearance of enhanced cell death within the mesenchyme in the central core of the limb bud, an area destined for chondrogenesis. The central core mesenchyme, which in the untreated limb buds experiences a sharp decline in cell proliferation heralding the onset of chondrogenesis, demonstrated a reversal of the process; this mesenchyme maintained a higher rate of cell proliferation upon RA exposure. These events resulted in a truncation and disorganization of the chondrogenic anlage, more pronounced in zeugopodal mesenchyme than in the autopod. We conclude that an inhibition of chondrogenesis was secondary to a disruption in cellular behavior caused by RA, a likely consequence of misregulation in the growth factor signaling cascade.

Because of the automatic restrictions and warning requirements imposed on substances identified by the state as "known to cause developmental toxicity," the Expert Committee recommends the use of criteria that emphasize human relevancy, biological plausibility, and evidence in support of a selective, adverse developmental effect at non-maternally-toxic doses. In many instances, data for substances of public concern will be insufficient at present to meet these criteria. The fact that a substance is not listed as "known to cause developmental toxicity" does not create a presumption that the substance is safe. The Expert Committee, therefore, urges that these substances be recommended for further testing and that high priority be given to conducting the necessary tests. The Expert Committee reiterates its concern that substances listed by the SAP be identified according to the toxic endpoints (cancer, male reproductive toxicity, female reproductive toxicity, and/or developmental toxicity) that led to listing. Further, the Expert Committee recommends that the state Health and Welfare Agency institute education programs emphasizing appropriate courses of action for citizens informed of exposures to substances known to the state to cause cancer, birth defects, or reproductive toxicity.

The transplacental pharmacokinetics of single teratogenic doses of etretinate and motretinide were compared with particular emphasis on distribution and concentrations in the exposed embryos of the free acid metabolite, etretin. The three aromatic retinoids were also tested for their direct inhibitory effect on chondrogenesis in the limb bud mesenchymal cell "micromass" culture assay. After a standard dose of 100 mg/kg administered on day 11 of gestation in NMRI mice, all three compounds were teratogenic, but they differed from each other in potency. Etretinate was most active as a teratogen, equalling the potency of our standard all-trans-retinoic acid; every exposed fetus was deformed with severe shortening of all limb bones as well as cleft palate. Etretin was less potent than etretinate, and motretinide was considerably less active as a teratogen than the other two. In the in vitro assay, only etretin suppressed chondrogenesis and this activity was equivalent to that of all-trans-retinoic acid (IC50 of 12 ng/ml). Both etretinate and motretinide (which contain an ethyl ester and ethylamide terminal group, respectively) were essentially inactive in vitro, demonstrating the fact that a free carboxylic group may be a requirement for the in vitro suppression of chondrogenesis. These differences between the results obtained in vivo and in vitro could be resolved by pharmacokinetic investigations using HPLC methods. Both etretinate and motretinide were metabolized in vivo to etretin, their likely common teratogenic metabolite. The high teratogenic potency of etretinate was probably the result of high concentrations as well as AUC values of its metabolite etretin in the embryo. On the other hand, the comparatively low teratogenicity of motretinide could be related to approximately 5 x lower embryonic peak levels as well as AUC values of etretin. A comparison of these results with those previously obtained for all-trans- and 13-cis-retinoic acids confirms the correlation between embryonic exposure and teratogenic potency in the mouse. Our results indicate that pharmacokinetic studies are essential for the interpretation of relative teratogenic potencies of retinoids as well as apparent differences between in vivo and in vitro teratogenesis. A free carboxyl group at the terminal end of the tetraene chain was necessary for high activity of the retinoids studied.