Search

Research on mixed forests has mostly focused on tree growth and productivity, or resistance and resilience in changing climate conditions, but only rarely on the effects of tree species mixing on timber quality. In particular, it is still unclear whether the numerous positive effects of mixed forests on productivity and stability come at the expense of timber quality. In this study, we used photographs of sawn boards from 90 European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.) trees of mixed and pure forest stands to analyze internal timber quality through the quality indicator knot surface that was quantitatively assessed using the software Datinf® Measure. We observed a decrease in knot surface with increasing distance from the pith as well as smaller values in the lower log sections. Regarding the influence of neighborhood species identity, we found only minor effects meaning that timber qualities in mixed stands of beech and Norway spruce (Picea abies (L.) H. Karst.) tended to be slightly worse compared to pure beech stands.

Timber quality is the main driver of timber prices and is strongly influenced by the competition a tree experiences until its day of harvest. Regulating competition is an integral part of silviculture, and therefore, deeper understanding of the competitor’s influence on timber quality is important. Since mixed forest stands and the share of broadleaved tree species have increased in the recent past because of a changed forest policy in several countries, effects of mixture types on timber quality are of increasing importance. In this study, we investigated the effects of intra- and interspecific competition on the internal timber quality of European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.). To analyze the effects of competition intensity and competitor species identity on the timber quality of 82 target beech trees, three different approaches were used: terrestrial laser scanning (TLS), a quality assessment on the standing tree by local district foresters, and a quality assessment of the sawn wood (boards) after harvesting. We investigated the relationship between external and internal quality features and additionally compared the different approaches to assess quality. We found that the present competitive situation was partly related to internal timber quality, with increasing competition leading to increased internal timber quality. We further observed more discoloration in timber of beech trees growing in mixture with other broadleaved tree species. We also showed that predicting discoloration is possible through the number of bark anomalies on the stem surface. Also, the external quality assessment of local foresters on standing trees predicted the internal timber features well. Finally, TLS appeared to be a valuable addition for assessing timber quality in situ.