1. Numerical Investigation of Engineering Systems: Analysis of Accuracy Reduction Due to Model Oversimplification.
- Author
-
Pacheco-Vega, Arturo, Dugast, Florian, Renault, Pierrick, and Tohid, Usama
- Subjects
- *
ENGINEERING systems , *MATHEMATICAL models , *APPROXIMATION algorithms , *BOUNDARY value problems , *MATHEMATICAL optimization - Abstract
When faced with the mathematical modeling of any engineering system, whether for design, performance assessment, optimization, or control, the engineer has to determine the level of accuracy versus the simplicity of the mathematical formulation. Although it is universally accepted that the more complex the formulation, the more accurate the results will be, these usually come at the expense of larger CPU times, a substantial amount of computer resources, and are generally limited by the capacity of computers and computing power, which most times precludes their use in favor of simpler models. Many times, however, engineers do not realize the potential risk that oversimplification of a problem generates in terms of accuracy of the results; that is, the model solution does not resemble the system behavior. Through a demonstrative example, the present study addresses the issue of oversimplification of the resulting mathematical model and the corresponding accuracy of its solution. After constructing three sets of models of the physical system, each with a different level of detail, the solutions are then compared to experimental data. The results show that the accuracy of the numerical approximation depends directly on the level of complexity of the mathematical model used, and that oversimplification may result in up to a ninefold degradation of the results. In addition, minor changes in the inlet boundary condition and geometry result in significant changes in the flow pattern, up to a fivefold difference between different models in the recirculation bubble relative error. This information is fundamental for engineering professionals to consider during the modeling process in applications. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2017
- Full Text
- View/download PDF