Search

Background: The phalanges are the final skeletal elements to form in the vertebrate limb and their identity is regulated by signaling at the phalanx forming region (PFR) located at the tip of the developing digit ray. Here, we seek to explore the relationship between PFR activity and phalanx morphogenesis, which define the most distal limb skeletal elements, and signals associated with termination of limb outgrowth., Results: As Grem1 is extinguished in the distal chick limb mesoderm, the chondrogenesis marker Aggrecan is up-regulated in the metatarsals and phalanges. Fate mapping confirms that subridge mesoderm cells contribute to the metatarsal and phalanges when subridge Grem1 is down-regulated. Grem1 overexpression specifically blocks chick phalanx development by inhibiting PFR activity. PFR activity and digit development are also disrupted following overexpression of a Gli3 repressor, which results in Grem1 expression in the distal limb and downregulation of Bmpr1b., Conclusions: Based on expression and fate mapping studies, we propose that downregulation of Grem1 in the distal limb marks the transition from metatarsal to phalanx development. This suggests that downregulation of Grem1 in the distal limb mesoderm is necessary for phalanx development. Grem1 downregulation allows for full PFR activity and phalanx progenitor cell commitment to digit fate., (© 2021 American Association for Anatomy.)

Background: Interdigits (IDs) determine digit identity in chick limbs. They are located between the digital rays and act as secondary signaling centers downstream of sonic hedgehog to provide positional information for determining digit identity in the phalanx-forming region (PFR). We examined the dynamic developmental mechanism by which PFR cells obtain positional information from IDs to determine the identity of individual digits in the chick hindlimb., Results: We identified the specific region of the IDs responsible for determining digit identity and showed that PFR cells actively receive positional information only from the posteriorly, and not the anteriorly, located IDs. We also demonstrated that digits 1, 2, and 3 are interchangeable with each other, but not with digit 4. Finally, we found that both ID4 and digital ray 4 are necessary for determining digit 4 identity., Conclusions: The digital rays are naïve during the initial stages of their development, at which time digit identity is not determined. To determine digit identity, each PFR cell shows a unidirectional response to obtain positional information specifically from the IDs located posterior to the PFR, regardless of the signal strength from the anteriorly located IDs., (© 2021 American Association of Anatomists.)

The evolutionarily conserved, non-coding ~800-base-pair (bp) zone of polarizing activity (ZPA) regulatory sequence (ZRS) controls Shh expression in the posterior limb. We report that the chicken mutant oligozeugodactyly (ozd), which lacks limb Shh expression, has a large deletion within the ZRS. Furthermore, the preaxial polydactylous, Silkie Breed chicken, which develops ectopic anterior limb Shh expression, has a single bp change within the ZRS. Using an in vivo reporter assay to examine enhancer function in the chick limb, we demonstrate that the wild-type ZRS drives β-galactosidase reporter expression in the ZPA of both wild-type and ozd limbs. The Silkie ZRS drives β-galactosidase in both posterior and anterior Shh domains in wild-type limb buds. These results support the hypothesis that the ZRS integrates positive and negative prepatterned regulatory inputs in the chicken model system and demonstrate the utility of the chicken limb as an efficient genetic system for gene regulatory studies., (Copyright © 2011 Wiley-Liss, Inc.)

We have cloned the chicken and mouse orthologues of the Caenorhabditis elegans heterochronic gene lin-41. During limb development, lin-41 is expressed in three phases over developmental time and most notably is associated with the developing autopod. Using chicken and mouse mutants and bead implantations, we report that lin-41 is genetically and biochemically downstream of both the Shh and Fgf signaling pathways. In C. elegans, it is proposed that lin-41 activity is temporally regulated by miRNAs (let-7 and lin-4) that bind to complementary sites in the lin-41 3'-untranslated region (UTR). Taking a bioinformatics approach, we also report the presence of potential miRNA binding sites in the 3'-UTR of chicken lin-41, including sites for the chicken orthologues of both C. elegans let-7 and lin-4. Finally, we show that these miRNAs and others are expressed in the chick limb consistent with the hypothesis that they regulate chicken Lin-41 activity in vivo., (Copyright 2005 Wiley-Liss, Inc.)

In most instances of preaxial polydactyly (PPD), Sonic Hedgehog (Shh), an essential limb patterning signal, is ectopically expressed in an anterior region of the developing limb in addition to the normal posterior domain. It is thought that this anterior Shh expression leads directly to the development of the extra digits. Recent reports have identified a conserved limb-specific Shh enhancer approximately 1 megabase upstream of the Shh transcription initiation site, and individual base pair changes within this region are associated with PPD. We report here that a single base pair change within this enhancer is sufficient to drive beta-galactosidase expression in both anterior and posterior limb domains, similar to Shh expression in animal PPD models, whereas a wild-type construct is expressed only in the posterior limb, similar to Shh expression in normal embryos. These findings provide the first direct evidence that a single base pair change within the limb-specific Shh enhancer acts as a genetic basis for PPD., (Copyright 2004 Wiley-Liss, Inc.)

Removal of the posterior wing bud leads to massive apoptosis of the remaining anterior wing bud mesoderm. We show here that this finding correlates with an increase in the level of the repressor form of the Gli3 protein, due to the absence of the Sonic hedgehog (Shh) protein signaling. Therefore, we used the anterior wing bud mesoderm as a model system to analyze the relationship between the repressor form of Gli3 and apoptosis in the developing limb. With increased Gli3R levels, we demonstrate a concomitant increase in Bmp4 expression and signaling in the anterior mesoderm deprived of Shh signaling. Several experimental approaches show that the apoptosis can be prevented by exogenous Noggin, indicating that Bmp signaling mediates it. The analysis of Bmp4 expression in several mouse and chick mutations with defects in either expression or processing of Gli3 indicates a correlation between the level of the repressor form of Gli3 and Bmp4 expression in the distal mesoderm. Our analysis adds new insights into the way Shh differentially controls the processing of Gli3 and how, subsequently, BMP4 expression may mediate cell survival or cell death in the developing limb bud in a position-dependent manner.

The induction and specification of a large number of vertebrate organs require reciprocal signaling between an epithelium and subjacent mesenchyme. In the formation of integumentary organs, the initial inductive signaling events leading to the formation of the organ primordia stem from the mesenchyme. However, the epithelium must have the capacity to respond to these signals. We demonstrate that bone morphogenetic protein 7 (Bmp7) is an early molecular marker for epidermal organ development during development of feathers and scales of the chick. Bmp7 is expressed broadly in the preplacode epidermis and subsequently becomes localized to the forming placodes of feathers and scales. An examination of Bmp7 expression in the scaleless mutant chicken integument indicates that Bmp7 expression in the epidermis is associated with the ability to form epidermal organs. We show that BMP7 function is necessary for the formation of epidermal placodes in both feather and scale forming epidermis. In addition, precocious expression of Bmp7 in the metatarsal epidermis of the Silkie mutant or treatment of the metatarsus with ectopic BMP7 protein results in feather development from scale forming integument. From these data, we propose that Bmp7 is necessary and sufficient, in a developmental context, to mediate the competence of an epithelium to respond to inductive signals from the underlying mesenchyme to form epidermal organs in the chick. We propose that regulation of Bmp7 in localized areas of the embryonic epidermis facilitates the development of regional formation of integumentary organs.

In the developing amniote limb, anteroposterior (A/P) patterning is controlled through secretion of the Sonic Hedgehog (SHH) protein by cells in the zone of polarizing activity (ZPA) located in the posterior mesoderm. In the chicken mutant oligozeugodactyly (ozd), Shh is expressed normally in the entire embryo with the exception that it is undetectable in the developing limbs; this results in the loss of specific bones in wings and legs. The ozd phenotype is similar to that of humans affected with acheiropodia (ACHR), and the ACHR mutation has been mapped to a deletion of exon 4 and portions of introns 3 and 4 in the LMBR1 gene. We have cloned the chick ortholog of LMBR1, Lmbr1, and report that, in chick, Lmbr1 is expressed within the ZPA. Although the ozd phenotype is similar to ACHR, the open reading frame of Lmbr1 is normal in ozd. Sequence analysis of Lmbr1 intron 3 demonstrated that this particular genomic region segregates with the ozd phenotype. In addition, overexpression of Lmbr1 throughout the developing limb mesoderm resulted in morphologically normal limbs. Collectively, these data suggest that the Lmbr1 coding sequence is not required for normal chick limb development. We propose that the ozd mutation is linked to the genomic region containing Shh and Lmbr1., (Copyright 2004 Wiley-Liss, Inc.)

Fibroblast growth factor homologous factors (FHFs) have been implicated in limb and nervous system development. In this paper we describe the expression of the cFHF-4 gene during chicken craniofacial development. cFHF-4 is expressed in the mesenchyme of the frontonasal process, and in the mesenchyme and ectoderm of the mandibular processes. The expression of cFHF-4 and other genes implicated in facial patterning have been analyzed in talpid(2) embryos or in the presence of exogenous retinoic acid. Talpid(2) mutants show abnormal patterns of gene expression, including up-regulation of cFHF-4 in the developing face, which correlate with defects in cartilage formation. By contrast, expression of cFHF-4 in the developing face is strongly downregulated by teratogenic doses of all-trans retinoic acid in a dose-dependent manner. Low levels of retinoic acid that produce distal upper beak truncations do not affect cShh, c-Patched-1, or c-Bmp-2 expression in the face, but downregulate cFHF-4 in the frontonasal process., (Copyright 2001 Wiley-Liss, Inc.)

Rapid progress is being made in understanding how integrated signaling pathways direct patterned outgrowth of the vertebrate limb. In contrast, the mechanisms that constrain limb outgrowth, and thus delimit adult morphology, remain poorly understood. Two recent pioneering reports have implicated bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) in negatively regulating the function of the apical ectodermal ridge (AER), an inductive structure required for continued proximodistal specification of limb elements. These studies provide the first insights into how the termination of a limb bud signaling center is accomplished, and intriguingly suggest how distinct aspects of limb morphogenesis are regulated., (Copyright 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.)

There is evidence that the interdigital mesoderm may be in an undifferentiated state. For example, under experimental manipulation in vivo it may be diverted from cell death to digit formation. In the present work we wanted to analyze the maximum morphogenetic potential of the interdigital cells. To do this we made recombinant limbs of three types, the first using dissociated-reaggregated leg interdigital mesoderm, the second using the same tissue but without dissociation and the third adding a piece of polarizing region to the dissociated interdigit. In all three the massive cell death of the interdigit failed to occur. The first type of recombinant formed a small nodule of cartilage while the other two formed a well-developed digit. Our data indicate that the maximum morphogenetic potential of the interdigital tissue appears constrained to form digits and that dissociation of the tissue decreased this ability; polarizing region restores the ability of dissociated cell recombinants to form a digit. We also analyzed in these recombinants the expression of a battery of genes implicated in interdigital cell death or in digital morphogenesis. The pattern of expression of each gene analyzed was identical in the three types of recombinant limbs. The expression of Msx1 and Msx2 genes was maintained under the ridge indicating a good interaction between the interdigital cells, both dissociated and undissociated, and the apical ridge. The expression of Hoxd-12, Hoxd-13 and Hoxa-13 genes was maintained in the recombinants, indicating that these cells carry information about their autopodial origin, and this correlates well with their distal restricted morphogenetic potential. Finally, the patterns of expression of the Bmp-2, Bmp-4 and Bmp-7 genes indicated that they are independently regulated in the recombinants and that Bmp-4 and Bmp-7 have wider expression domains than the areas of cell death that were only detected under the regressing apical ridge during day 3 of the experiment.

Members of the fibroblast growth factor (FGF) family of growth factors are key regulators of limb skeletal patterning and growth. Abnormal expression of FGFs or mutations in their receptors (fgfrs) result in skeletal disorders. Here we show that changes in the expression of fgfrs are intrinsic properties of differentiating cartilage. In mesenchymal micromass cultures differentiating into cartilage, as in ovo, fgfr 1 mRNA was found predominantly in undifferentiated, proliferating mesenchyme, fgfr 2 in precartilage cell aggregates, and fgfr 3 in differentiating cartilage nodules. Thus, our data suggest that switches in the expression of fgfr 1, 2, and 3 mRNAs are associated with phases of cartilage patterning both in vitro and in ovo, and mark distinct stages in the development of the limb skeleton.

FGF-2 protein is present in the ectoderm and mesoderm of the developing chick limb bud. Its importance has been shown by the ability of ectopically applied FGF-2 to replace the apical ectodermal ridge, allowing complete outgrowth and subsequent pattern formation of the limb bud. The first goal of this study was to determine whether FGF-2 mRNA was present in the same ectodermal and mesodermal regions of the chick embryo as FGF-2 protein. FGF-2 also has an antisense message that is convergently transcribed from the opposite DNA strand (Kimelman and Kirschner [1989] Cell 59:687-696; Volk et al. [1989] EMBO J. 8:2983-2988). The second goal was to demonstrate the expression and distribution of the antisense message. Using RNAse protection assays we detected a full length protected fragment that corresponds to chick embryo FGF-2 mRNA, and a partially protected fragment that corresponds to the antisense message. We used in situ hybridization to show that FGF-2 mRNA was present in the ectoderm and subjacent mesoderm of the chick wing bud. FGF-2 mRNA was also present in body ectoderm and undifferentiated mesoderm throughout the embryo, and in muscle cells, dorsal neural tube, and mesonephros. In situ hybridization also revealed evidence for the presence of the natural antisense message in the embryo in most, but not all, of the same regions as the FGF-2 mRNA. FGF-2 mRNA and its antisense message colocalized in undifferentiated limb mesoderm; however, antisense message was not detected in differentiated muscle or cartilage. It is important to note that FGF-2 mRNA was always present in the mesonephros but that the antisense message was never observed in the mesonephros, thereby providing an internal control for non-specific signal. Although little is known about its function, Kimelman and Kirschner ([1989] Cell 59: 687-696) proposed that the antisense message may increase turnover of FGF-2 mRNA. When we compared the in situ hybridization data of both mRNAs with levels of FGF-2 protein (Savage et al. [1994] Dev. Dyn. 198:159-170), interesting tissue specific patterns emerged that support this hypothesis.

Retinoids influence both morphogenetic events and differentiation during development of the vertebrate limb. These effects are mediated through nuclear retinoid receptors, which modulate target gene expression. We report here the cloning and characterization of three promoter- and splicing-variants of the retinoic acid receptor-beta (RAR-beta) from chick. These receptor isoforms are independently expressed during limb development. RAR beta 2 but not RAR beta 1 transcripts are enriched three-fold in the posterior limb bud, reflecting the increased RA concentrations in this region. RAR beta 1 transcripts are initially present throughout the limb bud mesenchyme and ectoderm, then become restricted within perichondrial regions and loose connective tissue of the limb. RAR beta 1 expression closely overlaps that of NCAM (neural cell adhesion molecule) and tenascin in non-neuronal tissues. RAR beta 2 transcripts are present within a subset of those limb tissues which express RAR beta 1. In the early limb bud RAR beta 2 transcripts are detected in proximal limb mesenchyme and in the initial mesenchymal condensate. In older limbs RAR beta 2 mRNAs are abundant in cells lateral to the digit cartilage. Neither RAR beta 1 nor RAR beta 2 transcripts are associated specifically with regions of limb cell death. The differential expression and regulation of RAR beta isoforms suggests these variants may have different roles in limb development.

We developed and characterized antibodies specific for FGF-2 and used them to locate FGF-2 during chick embryo development. A series of micrographs demonstrated the progression of FGF-2 staining during development of the different tissues and organs. FGF-2 was present in the ectoderm covering the entire embryo, muscle cells, nervous system, neural crest cells, and mesonephros. FGF-2 was also present in the limb from initiation of budding through differentiation. The limb ectoderm and subjacent mesoderm showed the strongest immunostaining, with lower levels in the center of the bud. However, the distribution of FGF-2 positive cells in the mesoderm was not homogeneous. This heterogeneity was not due to cell cycle specific distribution of FGF-2 protein, as flow cytometric analysis showed that FGF-2-positive cells were distributed throughout the cell cycle. However, the amount of anti-FGF-2 fluorescence varied most during G1, consistent with the possibility that FGF-2 is low after M phase and increases during G1. A bioassay was used to demonstrate FGF-2 levels in the wing ectoderm were approximately 2.7-fold greater than in the mesoderm. We propose that the location of FGF-2 in the embryo is consistent with a role in epithelial-mesenchymal interactions; in the limb bud it may prevent differentiation and permit limb outgrowth and subsequent expression of patterning events.

We have studied the expression patterns of the chick homeobox-containing genes, GHox-7 and GHox-8, in the talpid2 (ta2) chick mutant whose limbs have abnormal pattern. These studies provide new insight into how homeobox gene expression and limb patterning may be related. This is the first study demonstrating a natural change in GHox-7 and GHox-8 along the anteroposterior axis. While GHox-7 is expressed asymmetrically in normal limb buds, it is expressed at a uniform level across the anteroposterior axis of ta2 limb buds. GHox-8 is expressed in anterior mesoderm of normal limb buds, but is undetectable in ta2 limb bud mesoderm. These data are consistent with the subtle anteroposterior polarity in ta2 limbs, and allow us to propose that ta2 limb buds lack anterior positional information, but have a narrow range of posterior positional values. We suggest that in normal limb buds GHox-8 may establish the anterior limb bud boundary. Furthermore, we point out that coexpression of GHox-7 and GHox-8 in normal anterior limb bud mesoderm can be correlated with the reduced apical ridge maintenance activity of this tissue, while the lack of coexpression in ta2 limb buds is correlated with the strong ridge maintenance activity in the mutant's anterior limb bud mesoderm. Last, ta2 limbs contain no dying cells in their anterior and posterior border mesoderm; nevertheless, they express GHox-7 in these regions. These data challenge the proposal that this gene determines cell death.

Recent in situ hybridization studies have correlated expression of potential regulatory genes with pattern formation in limb bud mesoderm (Tabin: Cell 66:199-217, 1991); however, the mechanism(s) controlling their expression in mesoderm and their relevance to the establishment of a limb morphogenetic pattern remain unknown. One likely candidate for regulating patterning events in limb mesoderm is the apical ectodermal ridge, as its removal in ovo results in a graded truncation of limb skeletal elements in the proximal-distal axis dependent upon the time of excision (Rowe and Fallon: J Embryol Exp Morph 68:1-7, 1982). In the present study, we investigate whether the hypothetical imprint of ridge ectoderm is retained in cultured mesoderm. Specifically, we sought to determine if a subpopulation of limb mesoderm that forms in collagen gel culture (Markwald et al: Anat Rec 226:91-107, 1990), retains any expression of "limbness" in the absence of limb ectoderm as characterized by the formation of a predictable number and distribution of limb-like chondrogenic elements in comparison to the temporal and spatial relationships of the in situ proximal, hindlimb skeletal structures. Accordingly, explants of undissociated mesoderm from stage 18-22 chicken leg buds were cultured without ectoderm on collagen gel lattices and the central subpopulation of mesoderm was examined morphologically. We show that this central subset of mesoderm will form chondrogenic cells which were not expressed uniformly throughout the subset, but rather distinct nodules or elements of cartilage were elaborated. Moreover, the number of elements expressed by the central subset increased with the age of the mesoderm at the time of explantation; spatially and temporally, the sequence of elements that formed always proceeded from the proximal, anterior margin of the subset to its distal, posterior border. The shapes of the initial elements (designated I and II) resembled the forms of in situ proximal skeletal structures (girdle and femur-like), whereas more distal elements (III-V) were often fused and without structural similarity to in situ skeletal structures. When cultures were established from the posterior mesoderm of stage 19/20 or 21 mesoblasts, the frequency of element I formation was reduced approximately one-half, whereas formation of more distal elements was unaffected. Conversely, element formation from the central subset established from isolated anterior mesoderm was virtually identical to intact mesoblasts, indicating a capacity to regulate for the loss of mesoderm as occurs in situ (Hampé: Archs Anat Microsc Morph Exp 48:345-378, 1959).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

The talpid2 (ta2) chick mutant has wide, polydactylous wings and legs. Talpid2 limb cartilages have abnormal morphology and a very subtle anteroposterior polarity. Specifically, posterior ta2 limb structures are identifiable, while more anterior cartilages are less distinctive. Here, we investigate the development of anteroposterior limb pattern in the ta2 embryo. We show that ta2 posterior limb bud mesoderm is capable of respecifying the anteroposterior axis of a normal wing. However, the average duplication obtained after grafting a ta2 polarizing region was significantly less than the average duplication formed after a graft of normal wing bud polarizing zone. Thus, polarizing activity appears to be weak in ta2. Grafts of normal polarizing zone to the posterior edge of ta2 wing buds had no effect on the ta2 phenotype. This result suggests that a weakly functioning polarizing signal does not account for the altered anteroposterior polarity in ta2 limbs, and that normal polarizing zone activity is not sufficient for formation of normal limb bud cartilages. We demonstrated that transmission of a polarizing signal through the ta2 limb mesoderm was normal. In addition, ta2 anterior border mesoderm had no polarizing activity. We also assessed the ability of ta2 limb bud mesoderm to respond to a polarizing signal. Either normal polarizing zone tissue or a bead containing retinoic acid was placed at the anterior edge of ta2 wing buds at stages 18-23. Both polarizing zone and retinoic acid caused respecification of the ta2 wing anteroposterior axis. The result was that a ta2 ulna replaced the radius, and the most posterior digit was duplicated anteriorly. Limb cartilages with normal morphology never formed. When a bead containing retinoic acid was placed at the posterior edge of ta2 wing buds, there was no effect on anteroposterior pattern. However, beads with retinoic acid always caused a reduction in the number of ta2 wing digits which formed, whether the beads were placed at the anterior or posterior edge of the developing ta2 limb.