1. Reply to Comment by John J.G. Reijmer on 'Understanding carbonate factories through palaeoecological and sedimentological signals – Tribute to Luis Pomar' by Brandano et al. (2022), Sedimentology, 69, 5–23.
- Author
-
Brandano, Marco, Mateu‐Vicens, Guillem, and Baceta, Juan Ignacio
- Subjects
- *
CORAL reefs & islands , *PALEOECOLOGY , *SILICICLASTIC rocks , *SEDIMENTOLOGY , *TAPHONOMY , *CARBONATES - Abstract
Keywords: Bathymetric zonation; carbonate factories; ecological accommodation; grain roundness; sediment sorting EN Bathymetric zonation carbonate factories ecological accommodation grain roundness sediment sorting 2952 2963 12 11/24/22 20221201 NES 221201 INTRODUCTION We acknowledge John Reijmer for providing the opportunity to dive deeper into the concept of "carbonate factories" and, particularly, on the insights and substantial contributions of Luis Pomar on this and other important topics in the interdisciplinary field of carbonate sedimentology. In the same paragraph of his comment, Reijmer quotes: "It needs to be mentioned that the water depth in the basin surrounding the Llucmajor carbonate platform, which forms the base of an extensive series of carbonate factory studies by Pomar between 1991 and 2020 (e.g. Pomar, 1991, 1993, 2001a,b, 2020; Pomar & Haq, 2016), was approx. 50 m (Pomar, 1991, fig. 3), and consequently the major part of the biota populating the platform margin to basin transect were situated in the photic zone. The same type of approach allowed documentation of the migration of the scleractinians upward in the water column from the mesophotic into the euphotic zone, when the first modern type of reefs appeared and developed in shallow and highly agitated waters above the chlorocline (Pomar, 2001b, 2020; Pomar & Hallock, 2007, 2008; Pomar I et al i ., 2017). We respectfully disagree with this statement for the following reasons: Pomar uses the carbonate factories as a I dynamic i analytical tool, something that many researchers acknowledge, for understanding the facies architecture of the different types of carbonate platforms (see Pomar & Ward, 1995; Pomar, 2001a, 2020; Pomar & Kendall, 2008; Pomar & Haq, 2016) and not as a I static i concept for the classification and labelling of carbonate platform systems. [Extracted from the article]
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF