1. Zoos consenting to the illegal wildlife trade – the earless monitor lizard as a case study
- Author
-
Vincent Nijman
- Subjects
0106 biological sciences ,Ecology ,biology ,010604 marine biology & hydrobiology ,Lanthanotus borneensis ,General. Including nature conservation, geographical distribution ,QH1-199.5 ,biology.organism_classification ,010603 evolutionary biology ,01 natural sciences ,Fishery ,Wildlife trade ,Geography ,CITES ,illegal wildlife trade ,QH540-549.5 ,protected species management ,Nature and Landscape Conservation ,Earless monitor lizard - Abstract
The illegal wildlife trade has direct relevance for zoo management, animal acquisition and disposition and it has no place in modern zoo management. Zoos must not only act within the law of the country in which it is based, but they should also follow the rules and intentions of international trade regulations and, where relevant, domestic laws of the animal’s country of origin. After its rediscovery in 2012, zoos in Asia and Europe started displaying Bornean earless monitor lizards (Lanthanotus borneensis), the ‘Holy Grail of Herpetology’. Earless monitor lizards have been legally protected in each of its three range countries for over four decades and, over this period, no specimen has ever been legally exported. However, the illicit trade in the species is thriving and individuals become more affordable. Using publicly available data, I present a timeline of how and from where a total of 16 zoos acquired their earless monitor lizards, including from private individuals and non-accredited zoos. Apart from one zoo in Japan (since 2012) and one zoo in the USA (since 2021), all non-range country zoos that currently display the species are based in Europe. Their absence prior to 2021 in US zoos (despite an increasing illegal trade) could be explained as the acquisition of earless monitor lizards would have been in violation of the Lacey Act (1900) that requires buyers to ensure that imported or purchased wildlife has not been taken in violation of any foreign law. While there is no evidence that any of the zoos, their directors or their staff have broken any laws – no-one in the zoo community has been convicted for illegally trading earless monitor lizards – with more zoos speaking out against the illegal wildlife trade, it is imperative that zoos behave in an exemplary manner and set high standards. At present, some zoos do not meet this standard.
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF