1. Language processing, acceptability, and statistical distribution: A study of null and overt subjects in Brazilian Portuguese
- Author
-
Jefferson de Carvalho Maia, Maria Luiza Cunha Lima, Mirta Vernice, Amit Almor, Carlos Gelormini-Lezama, Almor, A, de Carvalho Maia, J, Cunha Lima, M, Vernice, M, and Gelormini Lezama, C
- Subjects
Linguistics and Language ,Overt pronoun ,Experimental and Cognitive Psychology ,050105 experimental psychology ,Language and Linguistics ,Repeated name ,Brazilian Portuguese ,Artificial Intelligence ,Personal pronoun ,0501 psychology and cognitive sciences ,Null pronoun ,Language and Linguistic ,Repeated-name-penalty ,060201 languages & linguistics ,Pronoun ,05 social sciences ,Null (mathematics) ,06 humanities and the arts ,Pragmatics ,language.human_language ,Preference ,Linguistics ,Comprehension ,Neuropsychology and Physiological Psychology ,Salient ,0602 languages and literature ,language ,Overt-pronouns-penalty ,Psychology - Abstract
Two experiments and a corpus study tested whether Brazilian Portuguese (BP), which has been argued to be shifting from null subjects toward overt subjects indeed shows a comprehension preference for reduced over fuller anaphors for salient antecedents, and whether comprehension is better explained as an imbalance between processing cost and discourse function (pragmatics account), or simply the frequency of different constructions (usage-based account). Sentences with overt pronouns were read slower (Experiment 1) but rated more acceptable (Experiment 2) than sentences with null pronouns when the antecedents were salient. Sentences with repeated names showed weaker effects than overt pronouns. The corpus analysis confirmed that BP is changing, but that null subjects are not yet infrequent, especially in academic writings. We argue that these results reflect a “pronoun avoidance strategy” in BP related to its transitory state, and propose a new view that integrates elements from both the pragmatics and usage-based accounts.
- Published
- 2017
- Full Text
- View/download PDF