1. Polygenic burden in focal and generalized epilepsies
- Author
-
Leu C., Stevelink R., Smith A. W., Goleva S. B., Kanai M., Ferguson L., Campbell C., Kamatani Y., Okada Y., Sisodiya S. M., Cavalleri G. L., Koeleman B. P. C., Lerche H., Jehi L., Davis L. K., Najm I. M., Palotie A., Daly M. J., Busch R. M., Lal D., Feng Y. -C. A., Howrigan D. P., Abbott L. E., Tashman K., Cerrato F., Churchhouse C., Gupta N., Neale B. M., Berkovic S. F., Goldstein D. B., Lowenstein D. H., Cossette P., Cotsapas C., De Jonghe P., Dixon-Salazar T., Guerrini R., Hakonarson H., Heinzen E. L., Helbig I., Kwan P., Marson A. G., Petrovski S., Kamalakaran S., Stewart R., Weckhuysen S., Depondt C., Dlugos D. J., Scheffer I. E., Striano P., Freyer C., Krause R., May P., McKenna K., Regan B. M., Bellows S. T., Bennett C. A., Johns E. M. C., Macdonald A., Shilling H., Burgess R., Weckhuysen D., Bahlo M., O'Brien T. J., Todaro M., Stamberger H., Andrade D. M., Sadoway T. R., Mo K., Krestel H., Gallati S., Papacostas S. S., Kousiappa I., Tanteles G. A., Sterbova K., Vlckova M., Sedlackova L., Lassuthova P., Klein K. M., Rosenow F., Reif P. S., Knake S., Kunz W. S., Zsurka G., Elger C. E., Bauer J., Rademacher M., Pendziwiat M., Muhle H., Rademacher A., Van Baalen A., Von Spiczak S., Stephani U., Afawi Z., Korczyn A. D., Kanaan M., Canavati C., Kurlemann G., Muller-Schluter K., Kluger G., Hausler M., Blatt I., Lemke J. R., Krey I., Weber Y. G., Wolking S., Becker F., Hengsbach C., Rau S., Maisch A. F., Steinhoff B. J., Schulze-Bonhage A., Schubert-Bast S., Schreiber H., Borggrafe I., Schankin C. J., Mayer T., Korinthenberg R., Brockmann K., Dennig D., Madeleyn R., Kalviainen R., Auvinen P., Saarela A., Linnankivi T., Lehesjoki A. -E., Rees M. I., Chung S. -K., Pickrell W. O., Powell R., Schneider N., Balestrini S., Zagaglia S., Braatz V., Johnson M. R., Auce P., Sills G. J., Baum L. W., Sham P. C., Cherny S. S., Lui C. H. T., Barisic N., Delanty N., Doherty C. P., Shukralla A., McCormack M., El-Naggar H., Canafoglia L., Franceschetti S., Castellotti B., Granata T., Zara F., Iacomino M., Madia F., Vari M. S., Mancardi M. M., Salpietro V., Bisulli F., Tinuper P., Licchetta L., Pippucci T., Stipa C., Muccioli L., Minardi R., Gambardella A., Labate A., Annesi G., Manna L., Gagliardi M., Parrini E., Mei D., Vetro A., Bianchini C., Montomoli M., Doccini V., Marini C., Suzuki T., Inoue Y., Yamakawa K., Birute T., Ruta M., Algirdas U., Ruta P., Jurgita G., Ruta S., Sadleir L. G., King C., Mountier E., Caglayan S. H., Arslan M., Yapici Z., Yis U., Topaloglu P., Kara B., Turkdogan D., Gundogdu-Eken A., Bebek N., Ugur-Iseri S., Baykan B., Salman B., Haryanyan G., Yucesan E., Kesim Y., Ozkara C., Sheidley B. R., Shain C., Poduri A., Buono R. J., Ferraro T. N., Sperling M. R., Lo W., Privitera M., French J. A., Schachter S., Kuzniecky R. I., Devinsky O., Hegde M., Khankhanian P., Helbig K. L., Ellis C. A., Spalletta G., Piras F., Gili T., Ciullo V., Leu C., Stevelink R., Smith A.W., Goleva S.B., Kanai M., Ferguson L., Campbell C., Kamatani Y., Okada Y., Sisodiya S.M., Cavalleri G.L., Koeleman B.P.C., Lerche H., Jehi L., Davis L.K., Najm I.M., Palotie A., Daly M.J., Busch R.M., Lal D., Feng Y.-C.A., Howrigan D.P., Abbott L.E., Tashman K., Cerrato F., Churchhouse C., Gupta N., Neale B.M., Berkovic S.F., Goldstein D.B., Lowenstein D.H., Cossette P., Cotsapas C., De Jonghe P., Dixon-Salazar T., Guerrini R., Hakonarson H., Heinzen E.L., Helbig I., Kwan P., Marson A.G., Petrovski S., Kamalakaran S., Stewart R., Weckhuysen S., Depondt C., Dlugos D.J., Scheffer I.E., Striano P., Freyer C., Krause R., May P., McKenna K., Regan B.M., Bellows S.T., Bennett C.A., Johns E.M.C., Macdonald A., Shilling H., Burgess R., Weckhuysen D., Bahlo M., O'Brien T.J., Todaro M., Stamberger H., Andrade D.M., Sadoway T.R., Mo K., Krestel H., Gallati S., Papacostas S.S., Kousiappa I., Tanteles G.A., Sterbova K., Vlckova M., Sedlackova L., Lassuthova P., Klein K.M., Rosenow F., Reif P.S., Knake S., Kunz W.S., Zsurka G., Elger C.E., Bauer J., Rademacher M., Pendziwiat M., Muhle H., Rademacher A., Van Baalen A., Von Spiczak S., Stephani U., Afawi Z., Korczyn A.D., Kanaan M., Canavati C., Kurlemann G., Muller-Schluter K., Kluger G., Hausler M., Blatt I., Lemke J.R., Krey I., Weber Y.G., Wolking S., Becker F., Hengsbach C., Rau S., Maisch A.F., Steinhoff B.J., Schulze-Bonhage A., Schubert-Bast S., Schreiber H., Borggrafe I., Schankin C.J., Mayer T., Korinthenberg R., Brockmann K., Dennig D., Madeleyn R., Kalviainen R., Auvinen P., Saarela A., Linnankivi T., Lehesjoki A.-E., Rees M.I., Chung S.-K., Pickrell W.O., Powell R., Schneider N., Balestrini S., Zagaglia S., Braatz V., Johnson M.R., Auce P., Sills G.J., Baum L.W., Sham P.C., Cherny S.S., Lui C.H.T., Barisic N., Delanty N., Doherty C.P., Shukralla A., McCormack M., El-Naggar H., Canafoglia L., Franceschetti S., Castellotti B., Granata T., Zara F., Iacomino M., Madia F., Vari M.S., Mancardi M.M., Salpietro V., Bisulli F., Tinuper P., Licchetta L., Pippucci T., Stipa C., Muccioli L., Minardi R., Gambardella A., Labate A., Annesi G., Manna L., Gagliardi M., Parrini E., Mei D., Vetro A., Bianchini C., Montomoli M., Doccini V., Marini C., Suzuki T., Inoue Y., Yamakawa K., Birute T., Ruta M., Algirdas U., Ruta P., Jurgita G., Ruta S., Sadleir L.G., King C., Mountier E., Caglayan S.H., Arslan M., Yapici Z., Yis U., Topaloglu P., Kara B., Turkdogan D., Gundogdu-Eken A., Bebek N., Ugur-Iseri S., Baykan B., Salman B., Haryanyan G., Yucesan E., Kesim Y., Ozkara C., Sheidley B.R., Shain C., Poduri A., Buono R.J., Ferraro T.N., Sperling M.R., Lo W., Privitera M., French J.A., Schachter S., Kuzniecky R.I., Devinsky O., Hegde M., Khankhanian P., Helbig K.L., Ellis C.A., Spalletta G., Piras F., Gili T., Ciullo V., Commission of the European Communities, Medical Research Council (MRC), Tumienė, Birutė, Mameniškienė, Rūta, Utkus, Algirdas, Praninskienė, Rūta, Grikinienė, Jurgita, Samaitienė-Aleknienė, Rūta, Centre of Excellence in Complex Disease Genetics, Aarno Palotie / Principal Investigator, Institute for Molecular Medicine Finland, Genomics of Neurological and Neuropsychiatric Disorders, University of Helsinki, Helsinki Institute of Life Science HiLIFE, and Department of Medical and Clinical Genetics
- Subjects
0301 basic medicine ,Male ,Multifactorial Inheritance ,Epi25 Consortium ,Databases, Factual ,FEATURES ,Genome-wide association study ,Epilepsies ,3124 Neurology and psychiatry ,Cohort Studies ,Epilepsy ,0302 clinical medicine ,Cost of Illness ,1ST SEIZURE ,HISTORY ,genetics ,POPULATION ,11 Medical and Health Sciences ,education.field_of_study ,medicine.diagnostic_test ,SCORES ,Single Nucleotide ,Biobank ,3. Good health ,17 Psychology and Cognitive Sciences ,Genetic generalized epilepsy ,Epilepsy, Generalized ,Female ,Partial ,Cohort study ,Human ,medicine.medical_specialty ,Population ,European Continental Ancestry Group ,Clinical Neurology ,BIOBANK ,Polymorphism, Single Nucleotide ,epilepsy ,genetic generalized epilepsy ,common variant risk ,Databases ,03 medical and health sciences ,Genetic ,Internal medicine ,medicine ,Journal Article ,Genetics ,Humans ,Genetic Predisposition to Disease ,Polymorphism ,GENOME-WIDE ASSOCIATION ,Generalized epilepsy ,education ,SEIZURE RECURRENCE ,Factual ,METAANALYSIS ,Genetic testing ,Neurology & Neurosurgery ,RISK PREDICTION ,Generalized ,business.industry ,3112 Neurosciences ,Common variant risk ,Genetic Variation ,Original Articles ,medicine.disease ,Comorbidity ,Cost of Illne ,Epilepsies, Partial ,Genome-Wide Association Study ,030104 developmental biology ,Neurology (clinical) ,Cohort Studie ,business ,030217 neurology & neurosurgery - Abstract
See Hansen and Møller (doi:10.1093/brain/awz318) for a scientific commentary on this article. Using polygenic risk scores from a genome-wide association study in generalized and focal epilepsy, Leu et al. reveal a significantly higher genetic burden for epilepsy in multiple cohorts of people with epilepsy compared to population controls. Quantification of common variant burden may be valuable for epilepsy prognosis and treatment., Rare genetic variants can cause epilepsy, and genetic testing has been widely adopted for severe, paediatric-onset epilepsies. The phenotypic consequences of common genetic risk burden for epilepsies and their potential future clinical applications have not yet been determined. Using polygenic risk scores (PRS) from a European-ancestry genome-wide association study in generalized and focal epilepsy, we quantified common genetic burden in patients with generalized epilepsy (GE-PRS) or focal epilepsy (FE-PRS) from two independent non-Finnish European cohorts (Epi25 Consortium, n = 5705; Cleveland Clinic Epilepsy Center, n = 620; both compared to 20 435 controls). One Finnish-ancestry population isolate (Finnish-ancestry Epi25, n = 449; compared to 1559 controls), two European-ancestry biobanks (UK Biobank, n = 383 656; Vanderbilt biorepository, n = 49 494), and one Japanese-ancestry biobank (BioBank Japan, n = 168 680) were used for additional replications. Across 8386 patients with epilepsy and 622 212 population controls, we found and replicated significantly higher GE-PRS in patients with generalized epilepsy of European-ancestry compared to patients with focal epilepsy (Epi25: P = 1.64×10−15; Cleveland: P = 2.85×10−4; Finnish-ancestry Epi25: P = 1.80×10−4) or population controls (Epi25: P = 2.35×10−70; Cleveland: P = 1.43×10−7; Finnish-ancestry Epi25: P = 3.11×10−4; UK Biobank and Vanderbilt biorepository meta-analysis: P = 7.99×10−4). FE-PRS were significantly higher in patients with focal epilepsy compared to controls in the non-Finnish, non-biobank cohorts (Epi25: P = 5.74×10−19; Cleveland: P = 1.69×10−6). European ancestry-derived PRS did not predict generalized epilepsy or focal epilepsy in Japanese-ancestry individuals. Finally, we observed a significant 4.6-fold and a 4.5-fold enrichment of patients with generalized epilepsy compared to controls in the top 0.5% highest GE-PRS of the two non-Finnish European cohorts (Epi25: P = 2.60×10−15; Cleveland: P = 1.39×10−2). We conclude that common variant risk associated with epilepsy is significantly enriched in multiple cohorts of patients with epilepsy compared to controls—in particular for generalized epilepsy. As sample sizes and PRS accuracy continue to increase with further common variant discovery, PRS could complement established clinical biomarkers and augment genetic testing for patient classification, comorbidity research, and potentially targeted treatment.
- Published
- 2019