Search

Affinity maturation is one of the cardinal strategies for improving antibody function using in vitro evolutionary methods; one such well-established method is phage display. To minimise gene deletion, we previously developed an open sandwich (OS) method wherein selection was performed using only phage-displaying VH fragments after mixing with soluble VL fragments. The decrease in anti-EGFR antibody 528 affinity through humanization was successfully recovered by selecting VH mutants using this OS method. However, the affinity was not similar to that of parental 528. For further affinity maturation, we aimed to isolate VL mutants that act in synergy with VH mutants. However, the OS method could not be applied for selecting VL fragments because the preparation of soluble VH fragments was hampered by their instability and insolubility. Therefore, we initially designed a modified OS method based on domain-swapping of VH fragments, from added soluble Fv fragments to phage-displaying VL fragments. Using this novel Fv-added OS selection method, we successfully isolated VL mutants, and one of the Fv comprising VH and VL mutants showed affinity almost equivalent to that of parental 528. This method is applicable for engineering other VL fragments for affinity maturation.

We showed previously that humanization of 528, a murine anti-epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) antibody, causes reduced affinity for its target. Here, to improve the affinity of the humanized antibody for use in cancer immunotherapy, we constructed phage display libraries focused on the complementarity-determining regions (CDRs) of the antibody and carried out affinity selection. Two-step selections using libraries constructed in a stepwise manner enabled a 32-fold affinity enhancement of humanized 528 (h528). Thermodynamic analysis of the interactions between the variable domain fragment of h528 (h528Fv) mutants and the soluble extracellular domain of EGFR indicated that the h528Fv mutants obtained from the first selection showed a large increase in negative enthalpy change due to binding, resulting in affinity enhancement. Furthermore, mutants from the second selection showed a decrease in entropy loss, which led to further affinity maturation. These results suggest that a single mutation in the heavy chain variable domain (i.e. Tyr(52) to Trp) enthalpically contributed for overcoming the energetic barrier to the antigen-antibody interaction, which was a major hurdle for the in vitro affinity maturation of h528. We reported previously that the humanized bispecific diabody hEx3 Db, which targets EGFR and CD3, shows strong anti-tumor activity. hEx3 Db mutants, in which the variable domains of h528 were replaced with those of the affinity-enhanced mutants, were prepared and characterized. In a growth inhibition assay of tumor cells, the hEx3 Db mutants showed stronger anti-tumor activity than that of hEx3 Db, suggesting that affinity enhancement of h528Fv enhances the anti-tumor activity of the bispecific diabody.